They Took My Dog Tags Over $3.48 of Stew and Crackers

William Turner

The toe of my left boot had split so wide that it opened every time I shifted my weight, like a dog waiting for a treat. I stood in front of that judge on Friday morning trying to keep my foot still so nobody would see it. That was what I was worried about. My boot.

I was 66. I’d slept two winters at an Altoona bus shelter. For three days I’d lived on church coffee, and on the fourth, Thursday at 6:15 that evening, I entered the little market at the corner on Union Avenue and put a tin of beef stew and a sleeve of saltines inside my coat. Two twenty-nine and a dollar nineteen. The door chimed, the night manager put me on a crate, and by eight o’clock the county had my belt, my eleven dollars and my dog tags in a numbered plastic bag.

So there I stood in orange, cuffed, with nothing on my neck.

The prosecutor, Newell, clicked her pen and asked for five hundred dollars cash bail. Then she turned to the benches like it was happy hour and said, “Honestly, jail’s warmer than where he sleeps anyway.”

Two people laughed. I turned around and looked at both of them.

The judge never looked up. He read my file, the two citations for sleeping and the address that said NONE, and finally asked if I understood the charge, Mr. Granger.

Twenty-two years of habit answered for me. Heels together, cuffs and all.

“Granger, Hugo T. Staff Sergeant. Yes, sir.”

He stopped. He took his glasses off. He stood up, ordered Pang to take my cuffs off, and came down off the bench to the rail, in his robe, with fifteen people watching.

He had a scar under his left ear that ran down into his collar.

“Staff Sergeant,” he said. “Do you know who I am?”

The scar

I didn’t, for about three seconds.

Then I did. And I’ll tell you what came first, because it wasn’t his face. It was the smell. Diesel and burning canvas. My body remembered it before my head did, the way your tongue finds a chipped tooth.

February 1991. A desert road north of the Saudi line, a supply truck on its side and on fire, and a kid in the cab who couldn’t get his door open because the door was underneath him. Nineteen years old. Skinny as a rake handle. I went in through the windshield, and I got him by his collar, and his collar was burning, and I pulled anyway. He screamed the whole way out. I’d have screamed too.

His name was Shin. Lance Corporal Shin. He used to eat his peaches out of the can with a knife, and I told him once he’d cut his lip off doing it, and he said, “Then I’ll be quieter, Staff Sergeant,” which was the only funny thing anybody said that week.

I looked at the scar going into that collar.

“Shin,” I said.

“Yes, Staff Sergeant.”

“Lance Corporal Shin.”

“Rahul,” he said. “You never once called me Rahul.”

“You never once earned it.”

He laughed. It came out broken in the middle, half a laugh and half something else, and he put his hand over his mouth. A judge. In a robe. With his hand over his mouth like a kid caught crying in church.

I had forty things to say and not one of them would come out. What I did was salute. In an orange jumpsuit, which you’re not supposed to do, and with no cover on my head, which you’re really not supposed to do. My shoulder doesn’t go up all the way anymore. I did it anyway, and he straightened up and returned it, there at the rail, robe sleeve hanging off his arm like a bedsheet.

Somebody on the benches said, “Oh my God.” Not one of the laughers. The laughers weren’t saying anything.

“You went back to Pennsylvania,” he said. “You told me Pennsylvania. I looked for you. Twice. You weren’t in anything.”

“I wasn’t in anything because I didn’t have anything to be in.”

“You were in this courthouse,” he said, “twice.” He meant the citations. Two times I’d been written up for sleeping in a bus shelter and two times my name had gone across some desk in this building, and he hadn’t been the one reading it.

He turned around then. He turned all the way around, slowly, and looked at the room.

Pang was standing there with my cuffs still dangling off one hand like he’d caught a fish he didn’t want. The clerk had both hands on her keyboard and wasn’t typing. The reporter was writing so fast her pen sounded like rain on a tarp. The two cops at the back had stopped leaning on the wall.

And Newell. Newell was holding her pen without clicking it, the first time all morning it had been quiet.

“Your Honor,” she said. “With respect. If you have a personal relationship with the defendant, the State would ask that you recuse yourself.”

I’ll give her this. She was fast. She’d gone from smiling to procedure in about a minute and a half, which is quicker than I ever got out of a foxhole.

My public defender, a young fella named Eli with a tie that looked borrowed, said, “Oh, come on.”

Judge Shin didn’t look at either of them.

“Madam Clerk,” he said. “Read back the State’s last remarks before I asked my question. The ones about where Mr. Granger sleeps.”

The clerk looked at him. Then at Newell.

“Your Honor…” Newell said.

“Read them back, please.”

The clerk scrolled. You could hear the little wheel on her mouse in that room. She found it, and she read it in the same grocery-list voice she’d used for my case number, which somehow made it worse.

“‘No fixed address, two priors. He’ll be back here in a week, Your Honor. Honestly, jail’s warmer than where he sleeps anyway.'”

She stopped.

“And then?” the judge said.

The clerk swallowed. “The record reflects laughter in the gallery.”

“How many?”

She looked up. “Two, Your Honor.”

He nodded, like she’d given him a number off a gauge.

Then he turned back to Newell, and he said, very quiet, “Counselor, I’m going to recuse myself. You’re right. I’ll do it in about ten minutes. First, you’re going to stand there, and you’re going to look at this man while I tell you where he slept in February of 1991.”

On the record

Newell said, “That’s not relevant to bail.”

“No,” Shin said. “It’s relevant to warm.”

And he told her. He stood about four feet from her table and told it to her face, and to the reporter, and to the cops, and to the two people on the second bench, and the clerk typed every word because he told her to keep typing.

He told them about the road. He told them the truck was carrying fuel bladders and nobody was supposed to go near it. He told them I went in anyway, through the glass, and that my hands were burned bad enough I couldn’t hold a fork for a month and the other guys had to feed me, and that I complained about the feeding more than the burns.

That part was true. One of them used a spoon like he was shoveling gravel.

“He slept that night on the ground next to my litter,” Shin said, “because I wouldn’t stop shaking and the corpsman said to keep me talking. So he talked. Eight hours. About Altoona. About a diner that put gravy on everything. About a horseshoe curve in the railroad he said was the most beautiful thing in America.” He turned to me. “Is it?”

“It’s a curve,” I said. “In a railroad.”

The benches laughed again. Different laugh. I’ll take that one.

Then he looked back at Newell, and the room went flat as a table.

“That’s where Staff Sergeant Granger slept, Counselor. Now tell me again about the bus shelter.”

Newell’s face did the thing a kid’s face does when the teacher reads their note to the class. Red from the collar up. She put her pen down on the table, very carefully, like it was a gun she’d been told to drop.

“Your Honor, I didn’t know his history,” she said.

“No. You didn’t ask. You read no fixed address and decided that was all of him.” He waited. “Nobody in this building asked him one question before you asked for five hundred dollars he doesn’t have. Over three dollars and forty-eight cents. Is that the number? The clerk can check.”

“That’s the number,” the clerk said, without being asked. I liked her better after that.

“Say it to him,” Shin said.

“Your Honor?”

“Not to me. I wasn’t laughed at. Say it to him.”

And here’s the part I keep turning over at night. I didn’t want her to. I’d wanted, ten minutes before, to climb under that defense table and die. Now some old sergeant part of me wanted to tell her at ease, forget it, you’re young. I nearly did. My mouth got halfway open.

Eli put his hand on my sleeve again. “Not yet,” he said. He was learning.

Newell came around her table. She had to walk past the benches to do it, past the two who’d laughed. One of them was a heavy guy in a Steelers jacket who’d been waiting on his own case. He stared at his shoes like they owed him money. The other one, the one who hadn’t looked away when I turned around, a woman in a fur-collared coat, looked away now.

Newell stopped in front of me. She was shorter than she’d seemed from across the room. Clicky pens make people tall.

“Mr. Granger,” she said. “What I said was cruel. I said it to get a laugh. I’m sorry.”

“Staff Sergeant,” Shin said, from behind her.

She closed her eyes for one second. “Staff Sergeant Granger. I’m sorry.”

“Okay,” I said.

That was all I had. Okay. She’d said it out loud in front of fifteen people and a reporter, and it was in the transcript, and the transcript is forever. That was plenty.

It wasn’t plenty for Shin.

“Counselor, a copy of today’s record is going to your supervisor before lunch, with my letter,” he said. “And to the bar’s disciplinary office, with the same letter. You can explain warm to them.”

Newell said, “Your Honor, that’s my license.”

“Yes,” he said. “It is. And this was his winter.”

She went back to her table and sat down without being told, which you don’t do while a judge is standing. Nobody corrected her. The guy in the Steelers jacket got up, said “Excuse me” to nobody, and walked out the back door. The woman in the fur collar stayed, but she’d moved all the way to the end of the bench.

Then Shin did one more thing before he recused himself.

He walked back up the two steps, sat down, put his glasses on, and said, “On the motion of the State, which the State is about to make, the charge is dismissed.”

Newell looked up at him.

“Isn’t it, Counselor?”

There was a long second. You could hear the radiator.

“The State moves to dismiss, Your Honor,” she said.

“Granted. Mr. Granger is released. Restitution to the market on Union Avenue is satisfied.” He reached under his robe, into his back pocket, and pulled out his wallet, right there on the bench. He took out a five-dollar bill and held it out to Pang.

“Bailiff, that’s three forty-eight for the stew and the crackers. Walk it over at lunch. Get a receipt. Tell the manager to keep the change and that it came from a Marine.”

Pang took it like it was a folded flag. He was a big man, Pang. His eyes were wet too. Everybody’s were except the clerk’s, and hers were working on it.

“I am now recused,” Shin said. “We’re in recess for thirty minutes. Nobody leave.”

Nobody left. The reporter wrote Nobody leave in her notebook. I saw it.

Property bag 2214

They gave me my clothes back in a little room off the hallway, and I was glad, because I don’t think a man can be a staff sergeant and a jumpsuit at the same time. The jeans. The flannel. The boots, with the toe flapping open.

Then a deputy put the property bag on the counter. Number 2214. I’d been thinking about that number all night like it was a dog I’d left tied up somewhere.

Belt. Eleven dollars, a five and six ones, folded twice the way I fold them. And the tags.

I picked them up and the chain ran through my fingers. Cold. They’d been in a drawer all night and they were cold. I put them on, and they went down inside my shirt where they belong, and that cold metal against my chest was the first time since the crate in that market that I felt like I was standing on my own feet.

When I came out into the hallway that afternoon Shin was there, without the robe. Just a man in a white shirt and a tie, with that scar going down into his collar and nowhere to hide it.

Next to him was a woman about forty, with a lanyard and a tote bag that said VA PITTSBURGH on it and a face that had heard every excuse there is.

“Staff Sergeant, this is Daisy,” he said. “She drove up from the regional office. I called her during the recess.”

“And she came?” I said.

“I called her,” he said.

Daisy shook my hand. She had a grip like a carpenter. “Mr. Granger, you were in for twenty-two years?”

“Twenty-two.”

“And you’ve never once filed for anything. Not a disability rating. Not housing. Nothing.”

“I didn’t need anything.”

“You had burns on both hands in 1991,” she said. She was reading from a sheet. “The judge says you couldn’t hold a fork.”

“The judge talks too much.”

“The judge,” said Shin, “is not a judge in this hallway. He’s a lance corporal. And the lance corporal says you’re going to fill out every form she puts in front of you, Staff Sergeant.”

I looked at him.

“That’s an order?” I said.

“It’s the closest thing I’ve got.”

Daisy laughed. Then she got serious, and told me what she had. A room tonight, at a veterans’ residence on Eighth Avenue, with a door that locked and a bed that wasn’t bolted to concrete. A caseworker, which was her. An appointment Monday for my hands, and my back, and anything else that hurt, which I told her was a long list, and she said, “We’ve got all day.” A claim, which might take months. Might pay back years.

I want to tell you I said something good. I said, “Is there a bus that goes there?”

“I’ll drive you,” Daisy said.

“No,” Shin said. “I’ll drive him. You follow.”

We went out through the front of the courthouse. The reporter was on the steps, and she asked if she could ask me one question, and I said one. She asked what I’d want the woman who said that line to know.

I thought about it.

“That I paid for the stew,” I said. “Eventually.”

She wrote it down. Later that week it was in the paper, under Newell’s line, which was printed word for word. I’m told it was a big week for that paper.

Before Shin’s car, though, there was one more stop. He drove us the long way, down Union Avenue, and parked in front of the corner market where the chime had gone off. Pang had already been. The manager came out from behind his counter when he saw me, the same man who’d put me on the crate, and he stood there wiping his hands on his apron for a long time.

“The bailiff told me,” he said. “I’m sorry. I didn’t know.”

“You weren’t supposed to know,” I said. “You were supposed to call. I took it.”

He went back inside, and came out with a can of beef stew and a sleeve of saltines in a paper bag, and tried to hand them to me.

I took the eleven dollars out of my shirt pocket instead. Five and six ones.

“No,” I said. “I’m going down the street for boots. But I’ll buy those.”

He rang it up. Three forty-eight. I paid him with four of the ones, and he gave me fifty-two cents, and I put it in my pocket.

Then we went down the street to the shoe store, and I bought a pair of black work boots on sale with the seven dollars I had left and the two hundred and fourteen Shin slipped the clerk when I wasn’t looking. I let him. I’m not stupid twice in one week.

I left the old boots in the box on the counter, split toe and all.

Out on the sidewalk, in front of his car, in the cold, Shin stopped me. He reached out and pulled the chain up out of my collar, just a couple inches, so the tags sat on top of my shirt where anyone could see them.

“There,” he said. “So the next one looks.”

I looked down at the tags, and the new boots, and the scar running into his collar.

“Get in the car, Lance Corporal,” I said.

“Yes, Staff Sergeant.”

For more stories of people standing up to cruelty and finding strength in unexpected moments, read the mechanic locked in the pit, the daughter pulled back by spare dog tags, and the twin called a quitter at Gate Twelve.