My Dad Hung Up on My Hospital Call for Paige’s Party

William Turner

The nursery soap at Saint Vincent’s smells like green apples somebody described to a chemist over the phone. Wesley came back smelling of it every time they brought him to me, and by midnight it was the only thing in Erie I trusted.

He was five weeks old. That Saturday, around 6:20, a landscaping truck blew through a red light and folded my driver’s door in. The paramedics went over Wesley twice in his car seat and found nothing. Then they took scissors to my shirt and found plenty: a broken left collarbone, two cracked ribs, and a line of stitches on my jaw that pulled every time I opened my mouth.

At 11:12 I called my father one-handed. He picked up on the fourth ring, and behind him I heard the patio tent, the string lights, a glass getting tapped for a toast at Paige’s engagement party.

“What now, Kristen?”

I told him. Truck, collarbone, nursery. One night, that’s all I wanted. Mom, anybody.

He said Paige gets one engagement party. I said, “Dad, I can’t even pick him up.” He said I’d decided to have a baby with no husband, and that wasn’t Paige’s problem. Then he was gone.

Paige is four years younger. Her tears got an audience. Mine got a review. I was thirty-one and still waiting on a better review.

Yvette, the night nurse, fifty-ish, glasses on a beaded chain, laid Wesley along my good arm around 11:40 and told me I hadn’t done one thing wrong. I fell asleep. When I woke he was back in the nursery, and the whiteboard said so in her capitals.

At 1:38 somebody knocked. In came Aunt Lorraine, rain on her coat, and Uncle Hal behind her with my son asleep on his chest in the striped hat. Lorraine read my chart before she read my face. Then she sat down and told me my dad’s party had ended early.

“I called him,” she said. “On speaker. All thirty-two of them heard him say it again.”

The striped hat

“Say what again?” I said, though I knew. The stitches made it come out like I had a mouthful of gravel.

Lorraine took her glasses out of her coat pocket, looked at them, and put them back. She does that when she’s deciding how much a patient can take. I’ve seen her do it to a goat.

“I asked him to put me on speaker so I could say something to Paige and Trent,” she said. “He did. He thought I was calling to apologize for not coming.”

“Were you?”

“I was in a Buick on Route 19 doing seventy-four, Kristen. No.”

Hal, in the window chair, made a sound that might have been a laugh. He kept patting Wesley’s back with two fingers. Hal has hands like catcher’s mitts and he was using about two percent of them.

“So I congratulated the couple,” Lorraine said. “And then I said, ‘Dennis, before I drive the rest of the way to Saint Vincent’s, I want to make sure I heard right. Kristen called you at eleven from a hospital bed with a broken collarbone and asked you to keep the baby, and you told her no.'”

I put my good hand over my mouth, which hurt.

“He said I was being dramatic,” Lorraine said. “Which is funny, because that’s what your family says when one of you is bleeding.”

“And then?”

“And then a woman’s voice said, ‘Kristen’s in the hospital? Dennis, you told us she was out of town.'”

I didn’t understand. I stared at her like she’d switched to Portuguese.

“Out of town,” Lorraine said. “Apparently around eight o’clock your father told the whole tent you couldn’t make it. That you were away and sent your love.”

Eight o’clock. I’d been in the ER at eight, with a tech asking me to rate my pain one to ten. I’d said six because I didn’t want to be dramatic.

“Who was the woman?”

“Trent’s mother. Carol. Very nice voice. She’s a dental hygienist, she told me later. People tell me things.”

“Later?”

“She called me back from her car.” Lorraine smoothed the coat on her knees. “So I said to your father, in front of all of them, ‘Dennis, tell me what you told your daughter.’ And he did. He said, ‘She decided to have a baby with no husband. That’s not Paige’s problem.’ Word for word. I think he expected applause. He’s always played to a room.”

I could see it. The string lights my mother makes him hang. Dad holding his phone out like a microphone, his face doing the thing it does when he’s sure he’s the reasonable one.

“Nobody clapped,” Lorraine said.

“What did Paige do?”

“I don’t know. I hung up. I had a granddaughter-in-law to… no. A grandnephew. Hal, what’s he to me?”

“Yours,” Hal said.

Lorraine nodded like that settled the genealogy.

“Carol said she and her husband left within ten minutes. Then the neighbors. Then everybody. She said your mother was unplugging the speaker when they drove off.” Lorraine looked at my jaw. “Who did these stitches?”

“I don’t know. Someone with a ponytail.”

“Decent work.” She stood, went to the sink, washed her hands like the hospital was hers, and took Wesley off Hal’s chest. Then she laid him along my right arm and built a wall of blanket on the far side of him, tighter than Yvette’s.

“Aunt Lorraine,” I said. “He’s going to say you ruined Paige’s party.”

“He will.”

“Mom’s going to say it too.”

“Your mother said I ruined Easter of 1986 by bringing store-bought rolls. I’ve survived her.”

Wesley made the little goat noise he makes before he really wakes up. I couldn’t lift him. I could only turn my face toward him. Lorraine watched me try and didn’t help, which I understood later was the kindest thing anybody did that night. Then she reached down and moved him two inches, so my lips reached his hat.

“Go to sleep,” she said. “Hal and I have him.”

“Where will you sleep?”

“I was a nurse for twenty-eight years. I don’t sleep. I wait.”

Hal was already asleep in the window chair, with his mouth open.

My phone buzzed on the tray table. Lorraine looked at it before I could.

“Your father,” she said. “Six missed calls.”

“Should I answer?”

She put the phone face down. “Not tonight.”

It buzzed again under her hand.

Six a.m.

I woke to grey light and Lorraine giving Wesley a bottle in Yvette’s chair like they’d been doing it for years. Yvette was standing in the door with her coat on, shift over, the cough drop finally gone.

“He took two ounces,” Yvette told me. “Your aunt corrected my swaddle.”

“She does that.”

“I’ve been swaddling since 1998.” Yvette didn’t sound mad. She sounded like someone who’d met her match at a bowling alley. “Good luck, honey.”

At 6:04 my phone lit up. Paige.

I didn’t want to answer. My sister and I have two kinds of phone calls: the ones where she needs something, and the ones where she’s crying and I’m supposed to fix it. I didn’t have either arm for it.

Lorraine handed it to me anyway.

“Kris?” Paige’s voice was wrecked, like she’d been screaming at a concert. “Kris, are you okay? Are you actually in the hospital?”

“I’m actually in the hospital.”

“He said you were in Pittsburgh. He said you had a work thing. I was mad at you all night. I told Trent’s sister you didn’t care about me.”

That landed somewhere under the cracked ribs.

“I would have come,” I said. “I was coming. I had a dress in the back seat. It’s in the car somewhere. The car is in a lot of pieces.”

She made a sound I hadn’t heard from her since she was nine and fell off the garage roof.

“He told everybody you sent your love,” she said. “He made a toast with it. ‘Kristen sends her love.’ And they all went aww.”

“Paige.”

“And then Aunt Lorraine called and he just… said it. Like it was normal. Carol looked at me like I’d been raised in a barn. Trent’s dad didn’t even finish his beer. He put it down on the cooler and walked out. Trent’s dad never doesn’t finish a beer.”

Lorraine, across the room, raised an eyebrow at that. She knows a man and his beer.

“Is Trent mad?”

“Trent’s mad at Dad. Mom’s mad at Lorraine. Dad’s mad at everybody. He’s been in the garage since two o’clock running the shop vac. There’s nothing to vacuum, Kris. He’s vacuuming the floor.”

I almost laughed. It hurt so I stopped.

“I’m sorry about your party,” I said, and I meant it, and that made me angry at myself.

“Don’t.” Her voice went flat in a way I’d never heard. “Don’t you dare apologize to me. You were lying there with Wesley, and I was doing a shot with Trent’s cousin.”

There was a pause where we were both the same age for once.

“I’m coming,” she said. “I’m coming right now.”

“Paige, it’s six in the morning.”

“Mom and Dad are coming too. Dad says he wants to ‘clear the air.’ He’s ironing a shirt.”

She hung up. I looked at Lorraine.

“He’s ironing a shirt,” I said.

“Of course he is.” She burped Wesley over her shoulder, three hard pats, a sergeant’s burp. “He’ll want to explain. Your father has never in his life believed something was wrong once he explained it.”

“Should I let him in?”

Lorraine thought about it the way she’d thought about the chart.

“It’s your room,” she said. “But I’d like to be in it.”

Hal woke up in the window chair, wiped his mouth, and said, “Is that Dennis coming?”

“Yes.”

He stood and pulled the chair over by the door, the one by the window, and sat back down in it. Seventy years old, bad knees, and he’d put himself between me and the hallway without a word.

At 8:40 the elevator dinged at the end of the hall. I knew his walk. Heel first, like the floor owed him money.

The ironed shirt

Dad came in first, in a blue button-down with the sleeve creases sharp enough to slice bread. Mom came behind him holding a gift bag with tissue paper sticking out of it. Paige came last, still in last night’s mascara, and she didn’t come all the way in. She stood against the wall by the whiteboard where Yvette had written NURSERY. SLEEPING.

Dad looked at my jaw and then at Lorraine. He picked the wrong one to talk to.

“I hope you’re proud of yourself,” he said to her.

“Morning, Dennis.”

“You humiliated my daughter at her own engagement party. In front of her future in-laws.”

“I asked you a question,” Lorraine said. “You answered it.”

Mom set the gift bag on my tray table. Inside was a stuffed lamb with a tag still on it. They’d bought it at the gift shop downstairs on the way up. I could see the Saint Vincent’s sticker.

“Kristen, honey,” Mom said. “Your father was under a lot of stress.”

“I was under a truck,” I said.

Paige made a noise against the wall. Mom didn’t look at her.

Dad stepped to the foot of my bed, where Lorraine had stood at 1:38, and put both hands on the rail like a man at a podium.

“Let’s be adults about this,” he said. “You called me in the middle of Paige’s toast. I didn’t know how bad it was. You said Wesley was fine. You said you were fine.”

“I said my collarbone was broken.”

“People break collarbones. I broke mine in ’81 and drove myself to work.”

“With a five-week-old?”

He ignored that. “I made a call. One night. Your sister has waited her whole life for this, and I was not going to have it be about you again.”

There it was. Again. Like I’d spent thirty-one years stealing scenes.

“Why did you tell them I was out of town?” I said.

He blinked. His face did a thing I’d never seen it do, like a computer screen when you pull the plug.

“I didn’t want people asking questions,” he said.

“What questions?”

“About the baby. About the… situation. Trent’s parents are churchgoing people. Carol asked me last month where the father was, and I didn’t have a good answer. So I said you were traveling. It was easier.”

“So I was out of town,” I said, “because you didn’t want to explain Wesley.”

“That’s not what I—”

“Dennis.” Paige, from the wall. Not Dad. Dennis. “You toasted with her love. You used her for a toast.”

“Paige, sweetheart, stay out of this.”

“Out of it?” She pushed off the wall. “It was MY party. You hid my sister at my party. You told my in-laws she didn’t care enough to show up. Carol texted me at four in the morning and asked if we were all like that.”

Mom said, “Paige, lower your voice, this is a hospital.”

“Then he should’ve come to it!”

She was crying now, real crying, the kind that used to get people running. Nobody ran. Dad stood at the rail and looked at her like she’d pulled a gun.

“I did it for you,” he said.

“No,” Paige said. “You did it for you. You wanted the perfect tent. You wanted the string lights.”

She went to my bed and took my good hand. Her fingers were freezing.

“Trent and I talked last night,” she said, still looking at him. “We’re paying for the wedding ourselves. All of it. I don’t want your check.”

The check. Dad had been bragging about that check since Christmas. Thirty thousand dollars, he’d said, at Thanksgiving, at Easter, to the guy at the hardware store. His big gift. His name in the program. Father of the bride.

“Paige.” It was the first time I’d ever heard him say her name like a question.

“And Kristen is walking me down the aisle,” she said. “Collarbone and all. If she can.”

Mom sat down on the edge of the radiator like her legs went out. Dad’s hands came off the rail.

He looked at me. Not at Lorraine, not at Paige. At me. He wanted me to fix it. He wanted me to say Paige was being dramatic. It’s what I’d always done, smoothed it over, said the thing that let everybody eat dinner.

Wesley woke in Lorraine’s arms and made his goat noise.

“Dad,” I said. “Could you hand me my son?”

He hesitated. Then he reached toward Lorraine. She stood and gave Wesley to him, careful, supporting the head, watching his hands the way she’d watched my chart.

He held his grandson for the first time. Thirty-five days old, and it was the first time. He’d come to the hospital the day Wesley was born and stayed nine minutes because he had a tee time.

He stood there with him, stiff, like the baby was a casserole he hadn’t made.

“Put him on my right side,” I said. “Along my arm. Tuck the blanket so he can’t slide.”

He did it badly. Lorraine fixed it with two moves.

Then I looked up at him.

“Now go home,” I said.

He opened his mouth.

“Kristen—”

“I asked you for one night. You picked a party. Lorraine drove seventy minutes in the rain. Go home, Dad.”

Hal stood up from the chair by the door. Didn’t say anything. Just stood, all six-foot-three of him, and opened the door.

Mom picked up her purse. She left the lamb. Dad went out last, and his shirt had already wrinkled at the elbows. The door clicked behind them.

Paige sat down on my bed, carefully, on the right.

“He’s going to call you a hundred times,” she said.

“I know.”

“Are you going to answer?”

I thought about the shop vac running at two in the morning over a clean floor.

“Not for a while,” I said.

Gravel

Lorraine signed me out on Tuesday, and she didn’t take me home. She took me to the farm.

“Six weeks,” she said, in the parking lot, buckling Wesley in the back of the Buick. “Collarbone takes six weeks. You’re not doing it alone in a second-floor apartment with a bassinet.”

“I have a lease.”

“Your lease can survive without you. It’s a lease.”

Hal drove. Lorraine sat in the back with Wesley. I rode up front with my arm strapped to my chest and a pillow between me and the seat belt, and every pothole on Route 19 felt like a personal insult. I counted them. Forty-one. Hal apologized for every single one.

The gravel road was exactly what my parents always made it sound like. Pocked. Muddy. A mailbox with a rooster painted on it, badly. Twelve chickens came running when the car pulled in, like we were celebrities. One of them was named Dennis.

“Since when?” I said.

“Since Tuesday,” Lorraine said.

The house smelled like coffee and lawnmower oil. Hal had built a bassinet stand out of a sawhorse and an old cabinet door, at the exact height of my right hip, so I could slide Wesley in and out with one arm without bending. He’d done it Sunday, while I slept in the hospital. He’d measured me with a tape measure in the hallway when he thought I wasn’t looking.

“Hal,” I said.

“It’s nothing. It’s a door.”

For the first two weeks I couldn’t do anything. Lorraine did the night feeds. She’d bring Wesley in at three, prop him on my good side, and sit in the rocking chair while I fed him, reading a seed catalogue with a flashlight. She never once said “You’re doing great.” She said things like “His latch is better” and “You’re holding your shoulder wrong again” and “That chicken’s been in the yard all night, Hal.”

Paige came out every Sunday. The first time she brought Trent, and Trent brought Carol, and Carol brought a pound cake and stood in the kitchen talking to Lorraine about the Army for forty minutes like they were old friends.

“I worked a field hospital in Germany in ’91,” Lorraine told her.

“I’ve never been to Germany,” Carol said. “I’ve been to Cleveland.”

They got along terribly well.

Dad called every day the first week. Thirty-one calls. I counted those too. Then a text: Your mother misses the baby. Then: This is getting ridiculous. Then, in week three: Paige is not answering either. Then nothing.

Mom sent a card with a check for two hundred dollars and the word Love and no name. I didn’t cash it. I put it in the drawer with the stuffed lamb’s tag.

In week four, Paige sat with me on the porch steps and told me the wedding was at a VFW hall in Meadville, which was all she and Trent could afford without the thirty thousand. Two hundred dollars for the hall. Carol’s sister was doing the flowers. Trent’s dad was doing the grill.

“Is Dad invited?” I asked.

“He’s invited,” she said. “He’s not walking me.”

“Is he coming?”

“He said he’d think about it.” She pulled her knees up. “Mom’s coming. She called me crying. She said he hasn’t hung the string lights back up. They’re still in a pile in the garage.”

I pictured that pile. Every summer of my life.

“Good,” I said.

Paige looked at me, surprised, and then she laughed, the first real laugh I’d heard from her since the hospital.

“You’re mean now,” she said.

“I’m on a farm. A chicken bit me yesterday.”

At five weeks, the orthopedist in Erie looked at my X-ray and said the bone had knit. I could lift ten pounds. Wesley weighed eleven pounds four ounces by then. Lorraine said, “Close enough,” and the doctor did not argue with her. Nobody argues with her.

That afternoon, back at the farm, Wesley was asleep in the bassinet Hal built, in the striped hat, which was getting tight on him. The rain had come back, the same thin rain from that night, beading on the kitchen window.

Lorraine stood by the door with her coat on, rain already on the shoulders from the chicken run.

“Go on,” she said.

I’d held him with one arm for five weeks, since the truck. I hadn’t lifted him out of anything with both since that Saturday.

I slid my left hand under his back. It ached. It held.

Hal came in from the barn, wiping his hands on a rag, and stopped in the doorway.

I picked my son up. Both arms. Pulled him to my chest, and he woke and looked at me, mad, then sneezed.

Hal walked over and patted Wesley’s back with two fingers, the way he’d done at 1:38 in the morning in a hospital chair.

“There he is,” Hal said.

Lorraine took her coat off and folded it over the back of the rocking chair, slow, the way she does everything.

“Well,” she said. “Somebody showed up.”

If this one got to you, send it to the person whose number you’d write on every form.

For more family drama that turns celebrations into painful betrayals, read about the wedding seat that left a sister in 38B and the ski week a mother canceled after her daughter paid for it. There’s also the ex-husband who proposed using his former wife’s company card.