Curtis Never Saw Two Passports or a Transfer Marked 14B Coming

Daniel Foster

The pen Curtis used belonged to Feldman. My husband handed it back before the lawyer could turn to the page about money.

It was Thursday, October 22, at 10:05 in the morning. After twelve years of marriage, Curtis Haldane was finished signing, and apparently finished listening.

I sat across the oak conference table with my handbag between my feet. At thirty-eight, I still caught myself waiting for permission to interrupt him.

Twelve minutes later, he gave me something better than permission.

“Take the girls, then. They’d only weigh me down while I start over.”

His mother, Lorraine, smiled. Beyond the door, eight-year-old Molly held her ladybug backpack against her chest while Josie, five, drew horses around the edges of a sticker book.

Curtis answered Dana Voss’s call and told his thirty-one-year-old office manager that he was coming to meet the heir. Lorraine added that this family would finally have a son.

I laid down my house keys, followed by the girls’ passports.

“Dublin,” I said. “We fly this afternoon, 3:50.”

He laughed and asked how I could afford it.

“Nine minutes ago you called them baggage.”

The agreement he hadn’t read gave me sole custody and unrestricted international travel with both children. My late mother’s savings had paid for our tickets.

Lorraine called it a bluff.

At 10:30, Curtis followed us outside to a gray town car. The driver mentioned Mr. Okafor and said we were expected at O’Hare by noon.

Once the girls were buckled in, he handed me a banded folder.

Tuesday’s transfer, labeled “unit 14B,” was there with thirteen others: fourteen payments of $15,000. Our $210,000 had gone toward a lakefront condo bearing Curtis’s name and Dana’s.

I rested the folder on my knees. Molly’s eye exam had been postponed while that money left our account.

The Call at 11:12

Josie leaned across the space between us and put her finger on the folder’s band.

“Is that homework?”

“Something like it.”

“You’re too big for homework.”

I almost told her that being too big was no protection against anything. Instead, I tucked the folder into my bag and helped her retrieve a horse sticker from her sleeve.

At 10:58, Okafor’s message appeared on my phone.

“They’re in with Dr. Brandt now. Eyes forward. Board the plane.”

I read it twice. He had arranged for financial papers to reach Curtis at the private women’s clinic on Michigan Avenue, where the scan was scheduled for eleven. Roy, Curtis’s sixty-eight-year-old father, was already there. Lorraine had gone with Curtis from the law office.

My lawyer knew about the appointment because Curtis had insisted that nothing delay it. He had mentioned it in messages, in negotiations, and once while Feldman was explaining the children’s arrangements. His heir had quite a calendar before being born.

Okafor knew nothing about what Dr. Brandt would say. Neither did I.

My phone rang at 11:12.

Curtis.

I let it ring until Molly looked over.

“Is Daddy coming?”

“No, sweetheart.”

I put in an earbud before answering.

“What did you tell him?” Curtis said.

Through the phone came Lorraine’s voice, asking someone to sit down. Another woman said Curtis’s name.

“Tell whom?”

“Brandt. What did you send him?”

“Nothing.”

“Don’t do this, Erin.”

There it was, the familiar request to stop whatever was making him uncomfortable, including having ears.

“You’re calling me,” I said.

Roy spoke next, farther from the phone.

“Ask her whatever you’re asking her, but stop shouting.”

Curtis said I was on the line. He put me on speaker, perhaps expecting me to confess to whatever trick he thought I’d played.

That was how I heard the room myself.

“Dr. Brandt,” Curtis said, “tell her what you just told us.”

The doctor asked whether Curtis was consenting to discuss his medical history with me and the family present. Curtis said yes, impatiently, twice.

Then Dr. Brandt said, “I performed Curtis’s vasectomy three years ago.”

My hand closed around the phone.

Three years earlier, Curtis had told me that another pregnancy would be too much for us financially. I had agreed that two children were enough. He had never told me he’d arranged anything permanent.

Dr. Brandt continued, “His follow-up testing confirmed the procedure had worked. A pregnancy now would require proper investigation before anyone assumed paternity. I told him he cannot simply declare this baby his.”

“You said it couldn’t be mine,” Curtis said.

“I said it was highly unlikely. I also said we should speak privately.”

Dana began crying.

I could hear the paper on the examination bed moving beneath her.

“Curtis, please. I was going to explain.”

He stopped arguing with the doctor.

For several seconds there was only a sound like someone trying to draw breath through a blocked nose.

Then he said, “Explain what?”

“I was seeing someone else before we moved in together.”

“Before?”

“And after. For a little while.”

Lorraine said, “Dana.”

Just her name. She had spent twelve years finding complete sentences for my shortcomings.

Dana said, “The timing fits him. I knew it probably wasn’t yours.”

Molly touched my elbow. I turned toward her, pulled the earbud away, and asked what she needed.

“Josie’s sticker fell.”

I picked it off the seat. A little brown horse with one leg folded under the adhesive.

In my ear, Curtis was demanding dates. Dana kept asking him not to do this in front of his parents. Roy said the doctor shouldn’t have to stand there.

Nobody asked whether I wanted to be there either.

I put the earbud back in.

“Erin,” Curtis said. “Say something.”

“What do you want me to say?”

“You knew.”

“No.”

“The lawyer knew. This morning, the papers, the car. You set this up.”

“I found our money. That’s what I did.”

His breathing changed.

“What money?”

“The fourteen transfers.”

He said nothing.

“The last one cleared Tuesday. Unit 14B.”

A door closed at his end. Dr. Brandt said he would give the family a few minutes and that Dana’s care would continue when she was ready. I was grateful to him for saying that. Whatever Dana had done, she was still a patient, and her baby hadn’t signed up for any of us.

Curtis came back to the phone.

“The condo is a separate matter.”

“It was our savings.”

“We’ll discuss it when you get home.”

“We aren’t going home.”

“Put the girls on.”

“No.”

He said my name so sharply that I pulled the earbud out again.

Molly was looking through the car window. Her hand had gone inside the broken opening of her backpack, holding its contents in place.

I ended the call and rang Okafor.

“They know I found the transfers,” I said. “Please tell me they can’t move that money again.”

“They can’t,” he said. “The order came through this morning. The condo funds are frozen.”

For the first time that day, I let my head touch the seat.

Then he added, “Curtis wants a conference before your flight. You don’t have to agree.”

I looked at Molly’s hand inside that bag.

“I’ll agree,” I said. “Without the children.”

Four Faces on a Screen

Okafor stayed on the line while I checked the time. We were approaching O’Hare, and there was room before our flight for one conversation, not another twelve years.

He arranged a video conference for 12:20. The clinic had given the family a room where they could speak after Dana’s appointment. I would join from the airport, and he would join from his office.

I told him I wanted Feldman there too.

“I don’t want Curtis telling his parents I stole something he agreed to give me.”

“He signed the provisions,” Okafor said.

“He’ll say he didn’t understand them.”

“He was offered an explanation.”

“I’d like them to hear that from the person who offered.”

At the airport, I checked our bags and took the girls through security. Josie was offended that her shoes had to stay on while mine came off. Molly carried the passports until we reached the other side, checking every few steps that they were still in her hand.

Near our gate, I bought them sandwiches and found two seats facing the windows. I sat just behind them, close enough to touch Molly’s shoulder, with my earbud in.

They could see airplanes. They would not see their father trying to take back a morning.

At 12:20, the screen filled with faces.

Curtis sat nearest the camera. Lorraine was beside him, her handbag on her lap. Roy stood behind them. Dana occupied a chair near the wall.

Four people, all of them waiting for me to make their day less unpleasant.

Feldman joined from the Loop office. Okafor appeared next.

Curtis began before anyone greeted anyone.

“This has got completely out of hand. Erin is leaving the country with my children, and somebody has interfered with a property purchase that has nothing to do with her.”

Feldman put on his glasses.

“The travel authorization was part of the agreement you signed this morning.”

“I know what I signed.”

“You just described it as something she isn’t entitled to do.”

“I didn’t know she meant today.”

“The itinerary was attached.”

Curtis looked toward his father.

Roy didn’t help him.

Lorraine leaned toward the camera.

“Erin, whatever has happened between adults, you cannot punish us by taking those little girls away.”

Behind my screen, Josie held half a sandwich against the window to show it to an airplane.

I kept my eyes on Lorraine.

“You smiled when he said they would weigh him down.”

“I didn’t hear him properly.”

“You answered him.”

Her mouth opened, then shut.

Curtis moved his chair.

“We were upset. People say things. I don’t see why we need to conduct some kind of trial over one sentence.”

“Then let’s discuss the money,” Okafor said.

He held up the transfer records, one page at a time.

Fourteen payments. Fifteen thousand dollars each. The total spoken without hurry.

Curtis rubbed his forehead.

“That account included earnings from my company.”

“Your marital savings account,” Feldman said.

“I run a business with thirty people depending on me. Money moves around.”

“Into Dana’s condo?” Roy said.

Curtis turned.

“Into an investment.”

Dana lifted her face.

“You told me it was money from the settlement.”

“It was going to be.”

“You said Erin had agreed.”

Curtis made a cutting motion with his hand.

“Don’t start.”

Dana sat back. Her tears had stopped.

I remembered the months I’d brought home outlet-store shoes and felt pleased with myself for making the money stretch. Curtis had praised me for it once, while standing in shoes that cost more than both girls’ wardrobes.

I wanted to tell him that. I wanted to empty every small humiliation onto that clinic floor.

Instead, I said, “Molly needed an eye exam.”

He looked into the camera.

“Don’t.”

“I put it off because you said we couldn’t afford it.”

“I said we needed to watch spending.”

“She sits close to the television now.”

Roy pulled out the empty chair behind Curtis and sat down.

“What else?” he said.

I shook my head. I wasn’t going to inventory my daughters’ needs for a room that had celebrated their replacement.

Okafor explained the order. The money remained tied up in the unfinished building’s purchase account; neither Curtis nor Dana could draw it out or complete the purchase with it while the claim was pending.

Curtis leaned toward the screen.

“So you’ve wrecked the purchase.”

“I asked for our savings to be accounted for.”

“Same result.”

“No,” Dana said.

He turned on her again.

“You don’t get to speak about honesty.”

“No,” she said. “I don’t. But I’m not taking her money.”

Lorraine pressed both hands over her handbag.

Curtis appealed to Roy.

“Dad, we can cover the gap until this gets straightened out.”

Roy shook his head.

“I came here because you said I was meeting my grandson.”

“Dad.”

“You didn’t mention you’d emptied the girls’ household savings to buy another woman a home.”

“It’s not that simple.”

“Then make it simple enough for me.”

Curtis talked for almost two minutes. Business income. Cash flow. His plans to repay the account. How expensive the divorce had been. How I had become impossible to talk to.

Roy waited until he finished.

“How much did Erin know about the condo?”

Curtis looked down.

Roy pushed his chair back.

“You won’t get a dollar from me.”

For the first time, Curtis stopped trying to explain the money.

He looked directly at me.

“Come back, Erin. We’ll sort everything out.”

The Seats We Kept

I turned the phone slightly so I could check the girls without showing them the screen.

Molly had opened Josie’s sticker book. They were deciding whether a horse needed wings. Molly said it didn’t, and Josie said that was exactly why she was adding them.

Curtis was still talking.

“We can undo the travel arrangements. You don’t have to make this permanent because you’re angry.”

“I’m leaving because I planned to leave.”

“Before today.”

“Yes.”

His expression changed, as though preparation were an insult worse than anything he’d said.

My mother’s savings had paid Okafor’s retainer as well as the tickets. Spending that money had hurt. I had kept it separate for years, imagining something cheerful with her name attached to it.

Instead, it bought advice, two seats beside mine, and the right to stop asking Curtis whether we could afford to exist.

I didn’t regret a penny.

Feldman spoke.

“The financial agreement also requires full disclosure. Signing it didn’t erase the undisclosed transfers. Erin has not waived that claim.”

Curtis said, “What do you want?”

Okafor answered with the proposal we had prepared: the full $210,000 restored, credited against Curtis’s share in the final accounting, with the condo claim released only when the return was secured.

Curtis stared at me.

“All of it?”

“All of it.”

Dana moved her chair forward.

“I’ll sign what I need to sign to release my interest. I don’t want the condo.”

“You don’t get to abandon this and leave me with it,” Curtis said.

She looked at him for a long moment.

“You brought your ex-wife into my appointment to accuse her of causing my pregnancy.”

“You let me think—”

“I did. I lied to you. I’m sorry. But she didn’t.”

He stood, knocking his chair against Roy’s.

Lorraine began to cry.

“Curtis, sit down. Please.”

He remained standing.

For years, that would have been enough to end a conversation. His height, his silence, the chair shoved back. I would start smoothing things over before I even knew I was doing it.

On the airport screen, he was smaller than my hand.

Okafor asked whether Feldman could review the written terms with Curtis that afternoon. Feldman said he could.

Curtis sat down.

“Fine. Send them.”

“The entire amount,” Okafor said.

“I heard you.”

“With Dana’s release.”

She nodded.

“And you understand that the children’s arrangements aren’t conditional on this money?”

Curtis looked at me again.

“Yes.”

Lorraine wiped under her eyes.

“Can I at least say goodbye to them?”

“Not today.”

“Erin, I’m their grandmother.”

“Then don’t call a grandson the thing that makes this family complete.”

She folded her tissue. She didn’t answer.

Roy leaned toward the camera.

“Tell Molly and Josie I love them. If they’ll let me, I’d like to call after you’re settled.”

“I’ll ask them.”

He nodded. No demand, no reference to what he was owed. I could work with that.

Curtis waited until the lawyers began arranging the paperwork, then spoke over them.

“So that’s it. You get to go off to Ireland and start fresh, and I lose everything.”

I thought about correcting him. His company remained his. He had somewhere to sleep. His daughters were alive and well and could someday decide what place he deserved in their lives.

But I had spent twelve years supplying the details he left out.

“You signed,” I said.

Then I ended the call.

Molly turned around.

“Are you done with homework?”

“Yes.”

She handed me the other half of her sandwich. I hadn’t asked her to save it.

We stayed at the gate until boarding. I made a little bridge across the broken zipper of her backpack with a safety pin from my handbag, and she tested it by tugging both sides.

“That’ll hold until we get it fixed,” I said.

“Can we keep this one?”

“Of course.”

She tucked the bag under her feet when we took our seats. Josie sat by the window and demanded to know which cloud belonged to Dublin.

Our 3:50 flight carried us out of Chicago.

The condo did not become Curtis and Dana’s home. They signed the release, and the purchase was canceled. The frozen funds went back into the marital account before the final distribution. The accounting credited $210,000.00 against Curtis’s share, exactly as agreed.

I read the figure while sitting on the floor of our rented Dublin flat, with Molly beside me and Josie trying to make a curtain reach her doll’s bed.

There was no lakefront balcony for Curtis to show off. No son he could announce as his own. The girls’ passports stayed in my drawer.

His first request for a call came through Okafor. I asked Molly whether she wanted to speak to him. She said not yet.

For once, not yet was an answer an adult would have to accept.

That afternoon, after Molly’s eye appointment, we stopped to collect her backpack from a repair shop. She opened and closed the new zipper six times before letting me pay.

Outside, she held my sleeve while I checked the address of the bus stop. Josie stood on my other side with her sticker book tucked under her coat.

“Are we too much stuff for the bus?” Josie said.

I put my phone away.

“Never.”

Molly took her sister’s hand, and when the bus pulled in, I stepped aboard behind them carrying the ladybug bag.

For more stories of family betrayal and the quiet strength it takes to endure it, read “My Son-in-Law Put Yellow Roses Beside My Hospital Bed” and “My Sister Kept the Torn Button in Her Sock”. And for another painful moment when a husband failed to see his wife’s worth, there’s “My Husband Left Me Holding a Stranger’s Glass”.