Hana had packed her own backpack the night before. Crayons, a coloring book of horses, a pack of gummy bears she was saving for “the sky part,” and a sweater I made her bring because planes are cold and Phoenix is not.
She hugged that bag down the jet bridge at Logan like it held state secrets.
This was the 7:10 to Phoenix on a Tuesday, her first real flight, to see my mother, Elvira. Three weeks earlier I’d paid $46 a seat so we could sit together. Ninety-two dollars. On a dental receptionist’s paycheck, that is not nothing. That is a month of somebody else’s teeth.
Row 23. Hana in the middle, me on the aisle, a sixty-ish man already snoring at the window.
Except a teenager in a cream hoodie was sitting in my aisle seat, headphones the size of salad plates, not moving them an inch.
“Yeah, I know. I like the aisle. You don’t mind sitting back there, right? She’s fine.”
He flashed his pass. 26B. Then he went back to his phone like the matter was closed.
The line behind me stalled. A man said, “Lady, come on.” A flight attendant waved me along. And my daughter looked up at me with her whole face asking what happens now.
So I went three rows back and watched the top of her head turn around every few minutes, looking for me.
Forty minutes in, the cart came, pushed by a flight attendant named Perla. I gave her my boarding pass. She sent him packing.
Before he went, I leaned in and told him, low, “You’re too big to act like this, and still young enough to quit.”
He said, “Fine. Sorry,” to the floor, and walked back to 26B.
An hour later, over the middle of the country, Hana pulled my sleeve.
“Mom. That boy is crying.”
His hood was all the way up. His shoulders were shaking.
26C
I would love to tell you my first thought was pure and motherly.
My first thought was, Oh no. I made a child cry on an airplane.
My second thought was that he was seventeen, not a child, and he had just spent forty minutes treating my daughter like a piece of carry-on.
My third thought was Hana, kneeling backward on her seat with her chin on the headrest, looking at me the way she looks at me when she’s decided I’m the adult and I’d better start acting like it.
“Sit down, baby,” I said.
“Are you going to go see?”
“Sit down and I’ll think about it.”
She sat. She did not color. She held the purple crayon in her fist like a microphone she was about to hand me.
I got up.
The seatbelt sign was off. The aisle smelled like coffee and somebody’s microwaved egg. Row 26 had a hole in it. The college girl in 26C was standing in the restroom line by the back galley, scrolling with one thumb, so the seat beside him was empty.
The man with the breakfast sandwich was asleep against the window, foil still in his lap.
I sat down in 26C.
He didn’t look over. His hands were pressed flat between his knees and his headphones were in his lap, the cord wound around one finger so tight the tip had gone white.
“Hey,” I said.
Nothing.
“I’m not here to finish yelling at you. I didn’t start yelling at you. My mother would be very proud.”
That got a breath out of him that was almost a laugh. Almost.
“I’m fine,” he said.
“Okay. My daughter disagrees, and she’s eight, and she’s usually right. She told me my eyebrows were crooked last week. They were.”
He wiped his face with the sleeve of the hoodie. The sleeve was so long it went past his hand.
“What’s your name?” I said.
“Josiah.”
“Shelly.”
He nodded at the seatback. That was the whole conversation for a minute. The plane hummed. Somebody up front laughed at a movie.
Then he said, “My mom’s in the hospital.”
I didn’t say anything. I’ve worked a front desk for nineteen years. When a person starts telling you the real thing, you shut up and let them.
“In Phoenix. She went in for a cough. Like, a cough that wouldn’t go away. And they did a scan yesterday and there’s a thing in her lungs. A mass.” He said the word like it was in a foreign language. “They said mass. They don’t know what it is yet. They’re doing more stuff today.”
“Is anybody with her?”
“My aunt. Sort of. My aunt and my mom don’t really talk.” He turned the headphones over in his lap. “I live with my dad in Quincy. Mom moved out there two years ago for work. I was supposed to go at Christmas.”
“So when did you book this?”
“Last night. Like eleven. I used the card she gave me for emergencies.” He swallowed. “I figured this counted.”
I thought about Hana asleep in her bed last night with her backpack zipped and ready by the door. I thought about this kid at eleven o’clock on a laptop, alone, typing his mother’s card number with his hands shaking.
“Does your dad know you’re on this plane?”
“He drove me. He had to be at work at six.” He shrugged one shoulder. “He said call when I land.”
I am not proud of how long it took me to understand the next part.
“The aisle,” I said.
He closed his eyes.
“I wanted to be first off,” he said. “When we land. I didn’t want to be stuck in the middle waiting for everybody to get their bags down. I just wanted to be close to the door.” He pushed the heels of his hands into his eyes. “That’s so stupid. It’s like four seconds.”
“It’s not stupid.”
“It was your seat.”
“It was my seat,” I said, because it was, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just because the story got sadder. “And you could have told me that. I’d have given you the aisle in 23 and moved Hana to the middle with the snoring man before I let you sit three rows back crying into a hoodie.”
“I didn’t want to tell anybody,” he said. “If I say it, it’s like, real.”
And there it was. The other thing I’d said to him, the thing I’d felt so good about. Still young enough to quit. I’d said it like I knew who he was. Some entitled boy who’d never been told no.
He’d been told something a lot worse than no, about fourteen hours ago.
“Josiah,” I said. “What I said up there.”
“You were right.”
“I was right about the seat. I don’t know if I was right about you.”
He looked at me then, for the first time, really looked. His eyes were red and very young.
“You don’t even know me,” he said. “And you still said it like you thought I could do better.”
Up front, I could see the top of a small head rise over the seatback in row 23 and turn toward us.
The Gummy Bears
The college girl came back from the restroom and found me in her seat.
“Oh, I’m sorry,” I said, and started to get up.
She looked at Josiah. She looked at me. She was maybe twenty and had a sticker on her water bottle that said I Brake For Iced Coffee.
“Is there an open one up there?” she said.
“23C. Aisle. Next to an eight-year-old who will tell you everything about horses.”
“Sold,” she said, and went.
I don’t know her name. I hope she gets everything she wants in life.
So I stayed in 26C. And about three hours in, somewhere over what Perla later told me was New Mexico, the plane dropped.
Not a long drop. Just the kind where your stomach stays where it was and the rest of you leaves. The seatbelt sign dinged back on. Somebody up front said, “Whoa.” The breakfast sandwich man woke up, said, “Hm,” and went back to sleep, which I believe is the most a man of his kind will ever say about anything.
Josiah grabbed the armrest between us so hard the plastic creaked.
“It’s just bumps,” I said.
“I know.”
“Planes are built for this. It’s like a pothole.”
“I know.” He didn’t let go. “I just keep thinking if something happens I won’t get there.”
I put my hand on top of his on the armrest. He let me. That told me more than anything he’d said.
We rode it out like that for about ten minutes. When it smoothed, Perla came down the aisle checking belts and stopped at 26.
She looked at me in the wrong seat. She looked at him. She took in the hood and the red eyes and my hand.
“Everything okay back here?” she said.
“Getting there,” I said.
She crouched next to the armrest, right there in the aisle, which I’m fairly sure they teach them not to do.
“Can I get you anything, hon? Water? Ginger ale?”
“I’m good,” Josiah said. Then, “Sorry about before. With the seat.”
Perla’s face did something soft. “You fixed it,” she said. “That’s the part I’ll remember.” She patted the armrest and moved on.
The seatbelt sign went off.
Thirty seconds later, a small person in a pink sweater was coming down the aisle with a backpack hugged against her chest like it held state secrets.
“Hana,” I said. “Seat.”
“The seatbelt light’s off.”
“That doesn’t mean roam.”
“I’m not roaming. I’m visiting.” She stopped at row 26 and looked at Josiah with the frankness of somebody who has never once been embarrassed in her life. “Are you okay now?”
He sat up. He actually pulled his hood down. I hadn’t seen his whole face this close before. He had a little scar on his chin and a cowlick that was fighting the curls and winning.
“Yeah,” he said. “I’m okay.”
“You were crying.”
“Hana.”
“He was, Mom. It’s okay to cry. Grandma Elvira cries at the dog food commercial with the old dog.”
“She does,” I said. “Every time.”
Josiah laughed. A real one, short and surprised, like it got out before he could stop it.
Hana unzipped the backpack. She dug past the crayons and the horse book and the sweater I’d made her bring, and she came up with the pack of gummy bears. The ones she’d been saving for the sky part. She’d told me about them at the gate, in the security line, at the coffee stand, and once in the car at 5:30 in the morning when I was too tired to know what day it was.
She held them out to him.
“These are for when you’re sad,” she said. “Or in the sky. It’s both.”
He didn’t take them right away. He looked at me.
“She’s been saving those since Saturday,” I said.
That was the wrong thing to tell him, because his eyes filled right back up.
“I can’t take those,” he said.
“You have to,” Hana said. “I already gave them.”
That’s her grandmother in her. Once something is given, it’s yours; arguing is rude.
He took them. He held the pack in both hands like a ticket.
Then he did a thing I didn’t ask him to do and didn’t expect.
He turned in the seat so he was facing her straight on, not over a shoulder, not with one ear covered.
“Hana,” he said. “I’m sorry I took your mom’s seat.”
She blinked.
“It was your first flight. And I sat next to you for like an hour and I didn’t even say hi. And you kept turning around, and I saw you, and I just kept my headphones on.” His voice cracked on headphones. “That was really messed up. You should’ve had your mom.”
The woman with the coffee from row 23, across the aisle, had come back to the restroom line. She stood there holding the cup and did not pretend to look at anything else. Two people in row 25 had turned all the way around. I could feel row 27 breathing on my hair.
Nobody said a word.
Hana considered him the way she considers a math problem she’s pretty sure has a trick in it.
“Why did you want the aisle so bad?”
“So I could get off first,” he said. “My mom’s sick. She’s in the hospital in Phoenix. I wanted to get to her fast.”
Hana’s face changed all at once. You can watch an eight-year-old’s whole heart move across her face like weather.
“You should’ve said,” she said.
“I know.”
“My mom would’ve let you.”
“I know,” he said. “She told me.”
Hana looked at me, then back at him, and then she made her ruling.
“You can have the aisle when we land,” she said. “But you have to sit in 26 until then. Because that’s your real seat.”
“Deal,” Josiah said.
She shook his hand. He let her.
Then she pointed at the gummy bears. “Eat the red ones first. They’re the best.”
Gate B
We landed at 10:30 Phoenix time. The man at the window in row 26 woke up as we touched down, looked out, said, “Hm,” and that was the full extent of his trip.
Josiah had eaten the red ones first. I watched him do it.
When the plane stopped and the seatbelt light went off, the whole cabin stood at once the way they always do, everybody bent under the bins like question marks. Josiah stood too, backpack already on his shoulder. Hood down. Headphones around his neck, where they’d been since New Mexico.
He looked up the aisle at row 23.
I knew what he was looking at. The door. All those people between him and it.
Hana knew too.
She was standing on her seat in 23B, which she is NOT supposed to do, and she yelled down the cabin in the voice she uses on the playground.
“He gets to go first! His mom’s in the hospital!”
I have never seen a planeload of tired adults move so fast. The college girl in 23C stepped back into the row. The coffee woman pressed against her armrest. Row 24 flattened. Row 25 said, “Go, go, go, honey.” A man in a Red Sox cap pulled a stranger’s bag down out of the way and said, “You’re good, kid, go.”
It was the same man who’d said, “Lady, come on,” on the jet bridge. I’d know that voice anywhere. I decided to let him have his redemption.
Josiah stood frozen in the aisle with a whole airplane holding it open for him.
“Go,” I said.
He went three steps. Then he stopped at row 23 and looked down at Hana on her seat.
“Thank you,” he said.
“Text my mom what the doctors say,” she said. “She has a phone.”
He looked back at me. I already had my phone out. I’d typed my number into his while we were over Albuquerque, under Shelly from the plane, because I’m a dental receptionist and I believe in follow-up appointments.
Perla was at the front, by the door, saying, “Bye now, bye, thank you,” to nobody yet, because nobody had reached her. When Josiah got there, she put one hand on his shoulder and said something I couldn’t hear. He nodded hard and went out onto the jet bridge almost running.
Then he was gone.
Hana climbed down and put her backpack on. It was lighter by one pack of gummy bears.
“Was that okay?” she said. “The yelling?”
“Grandma Elvira would have yelled,” I said.
“I know. I did it for her.”
We were the last ones off, more or less. Perla was still at the door.
“You two,” she said, and shook her head, and gave Hana a set of plastic wings from a drawer by the cockpit. I didn’t know they still did that. Hana pinned them to her pink sweater like a medal of honor.
“He’s going to be okay?” Hana asked her.
“I hope so, baby,” Perla said. “He’s got good people in his corner. You know that? He got on that plane with nobody, and he got off with two.”
We came up the jet bridge into the gate area, into that dry Phoenix air that smells like hot pavement even indoors.
And he was standing there.
Josiah. Right outside the doors at Gate B, backpack on, phone in his hand, rocking from foot to foot. He’d gotten off first and then he’d waited.
“You’re supposed to be running,” I said.
“My aunt’s outside, she’s circling. She said two minutes.” He looked at Hana’s wings and almost smiled. Then he looked at me, and his face went serious, the way it had when he’d turned to face her in the seat.
“I wanted to say something to you,” he said. “Before.”
“Okay.”
He took a breath. People were streaming past us toward baggage claim, roller bags clicking.
“That thing you said. About me being too big to act like that.”
“Josiah, I didn’t know—”
“No, let me.” He held up a hand, the hoodie sleeve falling past his wrist. “My mom says stuff like that. She says it all the time. You’re better than this, Josiah. And I always roll my eyes. And then I’m on a plane by myself and I take a little girl’s mom’s seat because I’m scared and I don’t want anybody to see. And some lady I’ve never met leans down and says it to me. Like she’s my mom.”
He stopped. His chin was doing the thing.
“I was sitting back there thinking, what if that’s the last time anybody says it to me. Because she’s not.” He couldn’t finish that one. He didn’t have to.
“She’s going to say it plenty more times,” I said. “I’m only borrowing it.”
He laughed, wet. Then he said it, the thing I’ll keep for the rest of my life, the thing I wrote on a sticky note that’s still on my monitor at work next to the appointment book.
“Somebody had to say it to me,” he said. “I’m glad it was you.”
His phone buzzed. AUNT TINA. He looked at it, then at us.
“Go,” Hana said. “Your mom’s waiting.”
He went. He got about ten feet and turned around and walked backward a few steps, and he held up the empty gummy bear pack, folded small, and put it in the front pocket of his hoodie like a ticket stub. Then he turned and ran for the doors.
My mother was at the bottom of the escalator in baggage claim with a sign she’d made on a piece of cardboard that said HANA in letters a foot tall, and Elvira Paredes, seventy years old, who taught me you lose the argument the minute you lose your voice, screamed my daughter’s name so loud a baggage handler dropped a suitcase.
Hana ran to her with both arms out, wings flashing on her sweater.
Four days later, on a Saturday, my phone buzzed while my mother was teaching Hana to make tortillas wrong on purpose so she could fix them.
It’s not cancer. It’s an infection. A bad one but they can treat it. She wants to meet the lady who yelled at me.
I wrote back that I didn’t yell.
Three dots. Then:
I know. That’s what I told her.
Hana read it over my shoulder, flour up to her elbows.
“Tell him he owes me gummy bears,” she said.
If this one got to you, send it to somebody who taught you how to stand up for yourself without ever raising their voice.
When a child needs someone to speak up, the stakes can feel enormous – read My Daughter Said Our Danger Word With Her Dad Standing Right There. For more family confrontations that turn a gathering upside down, see My Uncle Priced Grandma’s House Two Seats From Her and My Father Took Clippers to Me in the Suite He Paid For.