My Dad Brought His Soulmate to Booth Six at My Diner

Rachel Kim

The pie case at Rooney’s hums. It has hummed since I was hired, a low noise like a fridge thinking about something, and in eight months I had learned to stand next to it on slow afternoons and let it think for me.

I was thinking about a woman I had never met.

She started at our kitchen table on a Sunday in March, over Mom’s pot roast. Dad sat with his food going cold and rubbed his palms together like he was trying to start a fire with them. Then he told the four of us, Mom, Dawson, me and the gravy boat, “I’ve met someone.”

He called her his soulmate. I laughed, because it sounded like Mom’s afternoon soaps. Nobody joined me.

Mom didn’t throw anything. She looked at the gravy boat like it was about to say something smart.

When I asked who, Dad said, “That’s not something you need.”

Three weeks later he was in a one-bedroom in Kingston with his recliner, his boots and half the towels. Dawson, sixteen and furious, quit reading his texts. Dad skipped Easter, showed up at Dawson’s birthday with a Weis sheet cake and that tight, sorry smile, and came alone.

So I built her myself. Acrylic nails. A laugh like a car alarm. Somebody from billing at the water authority.

Then, the second Saturday in November, Stacey pushed through the kitchen door with her keys still in her hand and said Dad was in booth six, and he wasn’t by himself. I dumped a tray of coleslaw on the floor and walked out holding my order pad.

He was in a red flannel I’d never seen. He was laughing with his head back.

Across from him sat Xavier. Third grade, Yuengling cooler, every Penn State Saturday of my life.

“You left Mom for XAVIER?” I said, loud enough for the whole counter.

Dad smiled up at me and said, “Xavier’s known since we were nine years old.”

The red flannel

“Known WHAT?” I said.

Mr. Hanrahan had his cup halfway to his mouth and left it there. I’m pretty sure it stayed there through the rest of this, like a man holding a toast nobody was going to give.

Dad looked at Xavier. Xavier looked at the ketchup.

“Sit down, Bee,” Dad said.

“I’m working.”

“Then take our order and sit down.”

That was such a Dad thing to say that I almost did it. I clicked my pen instead. Click. Click. Like a kid in detention.

“Is he your soulmate?” I said. “Just say it. I’ve had eight months. I can take it.”

Xavier made a noise. I thought for one awful second he was crying, and then I realized he was trying not to laugh, which was worse.

“Honey,” Xavier said. “God, no. I snore. Ask your father, we went to Hershey Park in ’79.”

“Then who IS it?”

Dad put both hands flat on the table. Same move as the pot roast. My stomach knew it before I did.

“Me,” he said.

I waited for the rest of the sentence. There wasn’t any.

“You,” I said.

“I met me.” He said it right to me, not to the table. “I know how that sounds.”

“It sounds like a refrigerator magnet, Dad.”

“I know.”

“It sounds like something you’d buy at the Christmas Tree Shop.”

“Bee, I know.”

Behind me Stacey had come out of the kitchen and was pretending to wipe booth five, which was clean, which she knew, because she’s Stacey and wipes everything twice.

I sat down. Not because he told me to. Because my knees went.

Xavier slid over to make room and I ended up next to him with my order pad on my lap, and the three of us sat there like the world’s worst double date.

“You were nine,” I said.

“We were nine,” Dad said. “Third grade. Mrs. Kowalski’s class… no, that’s not right. Doesn’t matter.” He rubbed his face. “I told Xavier once, out behind the church after my First Communion, that I didn’t want to be any of it. I wanted to run away and fix boats in Florida. Nine years old.”

“He had a whole plan,” Xavier said. “He had a map.”

“I had a map from a cereal box.”

“And then?” I said.

Dad shrugged. “Then my dad got hurt and I worked. Then I married your mother because everybody said that’s who I’d marry. Then I took the job my uncle got me. Then you. Then Dawson. And I loved you, Bee, every single day, I want that clear. But I was sixty-one and I’d never once picked anything. Not a shirt.” He pulled at the flannel. “Your mother bought my shirts for twenty-nine years. My mother bought them before that.”

“So you bought a flannel.”

“I bought a flannel.”

“You blew up the family for a FLANNEL.”

The counter heard that too. Somebody coughed into a pancake.

Here is what I wanted to do. I wanted to stand up and dump the creamer on his head, slow, the way you’d water a plant you hated.

Here is what I did. I said, “Why didn’t you just say it?”

And that was the question he couldn’t sit through. He looked out the window at the parking lot, at his truck, the same truck that wouldn’t start in January.

“Because ‘I met someone’ sounded like a reason,” he said. “‘I need to leave’ sounded like I was sick in the head.”

“So you lied.”

“I didn’t lie. I said I met someone—”

“You let us hate a woman who doesn’t EXIST.” My voice went up and cracked like a fourteen-year-old boy’s. “Do you know what I named her? In my head? Brandi. With an I. I hated Brandi with an I for eight months. I hated her at Easter. I hated her by the cake.”

Xavier put his hand on the table near mine. Not on it. Near it.

“I told him,” Xavier said. “In April. I said, Walt, those kids are going to make somebody up.”

“And you drove him,” I said. It just came out. I don’t know how I knew.

Xavier didn’t deny it. “To the lawyer. To the apartment. I helped him carry the recliner up two flights and he sat in it in an empty room and cried for an hour, and then he asked me how you make rice.”

“You don’t know how to make rice?” I said to my father.

“I know now.”

Something in me wanted to laugh again and I hated that more than anything, because it was the pot roast laugh, the one nobody joined.

“Does Mom know?” I said. “That it’s—you?”

Dad’s face did a thing I didn’t have a name for.

“Your mother,” he said, “knew before I did.”

I looked at him. He looked at his coffee.

Stacey stopped wiping.

“Bee,” Dad said, “you should ask her about Thursday nights.”

Thursday nights

I didn’t ask her. I brought him.

That’s the part I’m proud of, and also the part where I probably committed some kind of crime, because what I did was take his truck keys off the table, put them in my apron, and say, “Tomorrow. Two o’clock. You’re coming to the house, and you’re saying it to Dawson’s face, or I’m giving these to Chun.”

Chun, through the pass window, raised his spatula like a man accepting a sacred duty.

“That’s my truck,” Dad said.

“That was my family.”

Xavier drove him home that night. Of course he did.

Sunday I didn’t sleep. I lay in my apartment, the one Xavier helped me move into, and stared at the water stain on the ceiling that looks like Ohio, and wondered what Thursday nights meant. I came up with a boyfriend. I came up with church. I came up with gambling, which was the funniest, because Mom won’t even buy a scratch-off at the Turkey Hill.

At one-fifty I pulled into the driveway. Xavier’s car was already there, which meant he had driven Dad and was waiting in it with the radio on. The keys were still in my apron. I’d slept with the apron on the chair like a hostage.

Mom opened the door before I knocked. She had lipstick on.

My mother does not wear lipstick on a Sunday.

“He called you,” I said.

“He called me.” She let me in. “Bethany. Before he says anything—”

“No. He goes first.”

Dawson was on the couch with his phone face down on his knee, which is how he holds it now, like it might bite. He looked at me. “Why is HE here?”

“Because he’s got something to tell you.”

Dad was standing in the kitchen. Not sitting. Standing by the table where the pot roast happened, hands in the pockets of the red flannel, the price tag nub still sticking out of the collar because the man has never in his life removed a price tag.

“Dawson,” he said. “Come in here, bud.”

“I’m good.”

“Please.”

Dawson came, slow, the way he walks to the dentist.

And then my father, who never in my life said a hard thing straight, said it straight.

“There’s no woman. There was never a woman. I told you I met somebody because I was a coward. I left because I couldn’t be what I was anymore and I didn’t know how to say that to my kids. So I made up a person to blame. That’s on me. You hated her, and she was me.”

Dawson stared at him.

“So who’s the soulmate,” Dawson said.

“Nobody, bud. I said a stupid thing at dinner.”

“You said it at DINNER.” Dawson’s voice went high. “I was eating. You made me—Mom didn’t even—” He turned on her. “Did you know?”

Mom took a breath. She sat down at the table. She put her hands in her lap, folded, and for one second I saw March all over again and I wanted to scream.

Then she unfolded them and put them on the tablecloth.

“I knew he was unhappy,” she said. “For about six years. I knew it the way you know a cough isn’t going away.”

“Six YEARS?” I said.

“He’d sit in the truck in the driveway after work. Twenty minutes. With the engine off. I used to time it on the stove clock.”

Dad looked at the floor. That one landed. I watched it land.

“So in 2021,” Mom said, “I signed up for a bookkeeping class at the community college. Thursday nights. I told you girls’ night with Pam.”

“There’s no Pam,” Dawson said.

“There’s no Pam,” Mom said. “I finished in 2023. I’ve been doing the books for the vet clinic on Market Street since August. Part-time. I didn’t tell anybody because I didn’t want it to look like I was getting ready.”

“Were you?” I said.

She looked right at Dad. “I was getting ready.”

Nobody said anything. The fridge hummed. Every machine in my life hums.

“So when he said ‘I’ve met someone,'” Mom said, “I looked at the gravy boat because if I looked at him I would’ve said, ‘Thank God, Walt, one of us finally said something.’ And then I’d have to explain that to you two, at dinner.”

“You let me hate a fake lady,” I said. “BOTH of you did.”

“Yes,” Mom said.

“For eight months.”

“I thought he’d tell you in a week. Then a month.” Her chin went. “Then it was Easter, and I set his plate anyway, and I took it away at one o’clock.”

Dawson made a sound I hadn’t heard since he was small. He sat down hard in the chair he’d shoved into the wall in March. There’s still a dent. Nobody’s patched it.

“You missed my birthday,” he said to Dad.

“I came to your birthday.”

“You stood in the DOORWAY. Like UPS.” He was crying now, angry, the kind where your nose runs and you don’t care. “I read every text. Did you know that? I flipped it over and then I read them in the bathroom. ‘Proud of you, bud.’ ‘Good game.’ I read them all and I didn’t answer because I figured she was reading them over your shoulder. I figured you were laughing about us.”

Dad’s face broke.

That’s the only word. It went the way old paint goes. He put his hand on the back of Dawson’s chair and then, slowly, the way he gets down to look under the truck, he got down on his knees on the kitchen linoleum.

“Nobody was reading them,” he said. “I was alone in a room with a recliner. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry, Dawson.”

Dawson didn’t touch him. Not yet.

Mom stood up.

“Walt,” she said. “Get up off my floor. And then we’re going to talk about the house.”

Booth six

Here is what my father lost, because I counted.

He signed the house over to Mom on the Tuesday before Thanksgiving, at the lawyer’s on Franklin Street, with Xavier waiting in the truck. All of it. Twenty-nine years of mortgage, the dented wall, the gravy boat. He’d wanted to sell and split. He didn’t get to want that.

He gave Dawson the truck. Not now, at seventeen, next July. Until then it sits in Kingston and Dad takes the bus to work like a man in a movie about regret, except he swears the bus is “honestly fine,” which is how I know it isn’t.

He paid for Dawson’s driving lessons. Four hundred and twelve dollars. He showed me the receipt like a kid with a report card. I told him the twelve dollars was the best part.

And he lost being the guy at the head of the table. Mom’s got the vet clinic full-time in January. She bought herself a car. A blue one. She picked it.

What he gained, he says, is rice.

The Saturday after Thanksgiving, I was working a double. Stacey’s grandkid had another thing. Stacey came in for dinner rush anyway.

She pushed through the swinging door at five-forty with her keys in her hand.

“Booth six,” she said.

I put the coleslaw down. Very carefully this time.

“He alone?”

“Go see.”

Chun looked at me through the pass window and held up the spatula like a question.

I walked out with my order pad.

Dad was in booth six, facing the door, in the red flannel. Price tag nub still in the collar. Xavier was across from him with a bag of chips he’d brought from home and wasn’t going to open, because no diner on earth lets you do that, and he knows it, and he brings them anyway.

And next to Xavier, sliding in last, unzipping his coat, was my brother.

Dawson looked at the menu like he’d never seen one. He orders the same burger every time.

The whole counter turned on their stools. Mr. Hanrahan put his cup down.

“Hey, Bee,” Dad said.

He smiled. The real one.

I didn’t smile back. Not yet. I clicked my pen.

“What can I get you,” I said.

“Coffee,” Dad said. “And whatever he’s having.” He nodded at Dawson.

“He’s having the cheeseburger, no onions, and he’s going to ask for onions on the side and then eat them, because he’s sixteen and makes no sense.”

Dawson rolled his eyes so hard I heard it. “Onions on the side,” he said.

I wrote it down.

Xavier cleared his throat. “Bethany. I’ll have the—”

“Meatloaf. I know, Xavier. I’ve known you my whole life.”

He grinned at the ketchup.

I went to put the order in. When I came back with the coffee, Dad had his phone out on the table and Dawson was showing him something. A text thread. I could see it upside down from the coffee pot. Dad. Dad. Dad. And under every one, gray little bubbles from Dawson, dated this week.

k

ok

u coming sat?

I poured. Dad looked up at me.

“Your mother says you two are doing Christmas at the house,” he said. “I wondered if I could bring a pie.”

“From the Weis?”

“I was going to make it.”

“You can’t make a pie. You just learned rice.”

“Xavier’s teaching me.”

“Xavier can’t make a pie,” I said.

“I absolutely can,” Xavier said. “I have a map.”

Dawson snorted coffee he didn’t even have yet.

I stood there at the end of booth six with my stupid order pad. Same spot. Same pie case humming over my shoulder. Eight months ago I’d have given my left arm to see who sat across from him. Now I could see. It was my brother, eating onions on the side, and an old man with chips, and my dad in a shirt he picked.

“You sounded happy,” I said to him. “When I came out. Before you saw me.”

“I was.”

“I know,” I said, and reached over and yanked the price tag nub out of his collar, and went to get the onions.

If this one got to you, send it to somebody whose dad was always the quiet one at the table.

Family secrets have a way of turning everything upside down – especially when the people closest to you are involved. Read about a stepson moving into the house his stepmother helped pay for, a husband hiding what’s on his phone, and a father dismissing his daughter over her wedding gift.