Our Pastor Put My Son’s Face on a Pancake Flyer

Rachel Kim

Zion keeps a drawing of Pepper folded in his backpack’s front pocket. It’s a black dog with six legs, because he ran out of room for a tail and gave her extra legs instead. He’d been carrying it to Wednesday club for a month, waiting for the right minute to show Miss Trisha.

The right minute never came.

He’s eight. He has Down syndrome, and he knows all the dogs on our street. We’ve belonged to Cedar Hill Community Church for five years, since his father left; it’s in Sedalia, Missouri. Cedar Hill was our family, as far as we had one.

In early October Zion started coming home with new words. Coat room. Watch. Trisha Seidel told me it was a liability thing, and I nodded like an idiot. Pastor Scott answered my three careful paragraphs with two lines. Then Diamond stopped me in the cereal aisle. Her Hana sat on my couch with a juice box and told me about the chair moved back by the cubbies, and the two boys chanting BABY while Miss Trisha poured the snack.

So I built a folder. Nine parents, all recorded. The inclusion policy off the church’s own website. The budget page with $5,200 sitting on it, untouched since May’s pancake breakfast. On top went the flyer: Zion with syrup on his chin and a fork in the air, under Help Us Build A Buddy Program. I’d picked that picture myself.

Three weeks after the coat room, at 7:45 pickup, Pastor Scott told me Zion would do better “in a program built for kids like him.” Zion was holding my hand. He asked me, “Am I in trouble, Mama?”

On Sunday I stood up in front of about two hundred people with the folder under my arm. Trisha headed for the side door. Justine grabbed her husband’s sleeve.

And Diamond stood up in the fourth row with her phone and said, “Lizbeth, wait.”

The fourth row

Two hundred heads went back and forth between us like a tennis match at the county fair.

Diamond didn’t wait for permission. She came down the side aisle in her church flats, phone out in front of her like a candle, and stopped at the end of my pew. Her hand was shaking so hard the screen kept going dark.

“I do the bulletin,” she said, to me and to everyone. “I have the office login. I was looking for last year’s Christmas template.”

“Diamond,” Pastor Scott said from up front. “This isn’t the time.”

“It’s the only time,” she said.

She turned the phone around.

The first thing was a page of meeting notes. Leadership, the second Tuesday in October. That was the week between the coat room and nobody picking him. Four lines, and the third one said Z. transition out of Wed club. Scott to speak with mom. Suggest Warrensburg.

Z. They couldn’t even spend the other four letters on him.

She swiped.

The second thing was a flyer.

It was the same pancake breakfast, with Spring Pancake Breakfast across the top and a new date in April. Same friendly letters. Same words: Help Us Build A Buddy Program.

Same picture. Zion, grinning, syrup on his chin, fork in the air.

I looked at the little line along the bottom where the computer tells you when somebody last saved a thing. It was eight days after the meeting where they’d agreed to move him out.

They’d decided my son was too much for Wednesday nights. Then, a week later, somebody sat at the church computer and put his face back on the flyer so they could raise money in his name again.

I’d come in thinking they forgot about the $5,200. Forgetting I could have yelled at. This was a plan.

My ears were ringing. I wanted to throw the folder at the stained glass. I wanted to take Diamond’s phone and walk it up to the pulpit and hold it under Scott’s nose until he went cross-eyed.

What I did was say, “Can you put it on the screen?”

Diamond looked at the big screen behind the pulpit, where the song words go. Then she looked at the sound booth in the back, where a teenager named Paolo was sitting with his mouth open.

“I can,” she said.

“Diamond,” Justine said. It was the first word Justine had said out loud in that sanctuary in five years that wasn’t amen.

Diamond walked to the back anyway.

The screen

Paolo slid out of the chair like the chair had gotten hot. Diamond sat down, plugged her phone into something, and typed with two fingers.

The words to “Great Is Thy Faithfulness” went away.

Zion came up instead, twelve feet tall, syrup and all.

A sound went through that room I’d only ever heard at a funeral, when the casket opens. Half a breath, two hundred times.

Trisha had stopped at the side door. She was holding the handle. She didn’t go out.

“Trisha,” I said. “Come sit down. You’ll want to hear this.”

She came back. I’ll give her that. She sat on the end of the front pew next to Justine, and Justine moved her purse to the other side like Trisha might be catching.

I opened my folder. I didn’t make a speech. I held up the May flyer, the real one, next to the giant one on the screen.

“This one raised $5,200,” I said. “One hundred forty plates at twenty dollars. And $2,400 in envelopes from people who couldn’t come. Some of you are in this room. Mrs. Kimiko, you sent sixty dollars and a note that said for our Zion.”

Kimiko, three rows up, put her hand over her mouth.

“That money is on the church’s own budget page.” I held up the printout. “Not one dollar spent. No buddy program. What there was instead was a coat room.”

Somebody near the back said, “A what?”

So I said it. The coat room during games. Just watch. The chair by the cubbies. Needs his own space. Two boys and the word BABY, over and over, while the snack got handed out.

I kept my voice at grocery-store level. I knew if it went up I’d cry, and if I cried they’d make it about my crying.

“Then on Wednesday night, with Zion holding my hand, Pastor Scott told me my son would do better in a program built for kids like him.”

I pointed at the screen.

“And a week before that, somebody in this building made this. For April.”

Nobody moved. A baby somewhere fussed and got shushed.

Up front, Scott put both hands on the pulpit. He had a face I’d seen on him once before, the Sunday the air conditioning died in July. He was calculating how long he could keep smiling.

“Lizbeth,” he said. “I think we’re all very emotional.”

“I’m not,” I said. “I’m tired. There’s a difference.”

Gray suit

He talked, of course. That’s his job.

He came down the two steps from the platform so he’d be on our level, which is a trick, and he used his counseling voice, which is a softer trick.

“Nobody in leadership ever wanted Zion to feel unwelcome,” he said. “We love that boy. Every one of us. But love sometimes means admitting what we can’t do. Trisha has eleven kids on a Wednesday and one pair of hands. We don’t have trained people. We prayed on it, and we felt Zion deserved better than we could give him.”

“Then why is he on the flyer?” a man said.

It was Ernesto Sayegh, the head elder, a retired mail carrier with forearms like canned hams. He wasn’t looking at me. He was looking at Scott.

“That file,” Scott said, “is a draft. Templates get reused. Somebody copied the old one forward. I’d have caught it.”

“Who made it?” Ernesto said.

“I don’t know offhand.”

Diamond said from the sound booth, without a microphone, “It says. Right under the date.”

Every head in the place turned toward the screen. Paolo, God bless him, zoomed in.

Last saved by: svinson.

Scott looked at it for a long time.

“I was going to change the picture,” he said.

There it was. He hadn’t said he didn’t make it. He’d said he was going to change the picture, like Zion’s face was a typo.

“You were going to change the picture,” I said, “because by April he’d be gone. That’s what the meeting notes say. Z. transition out.”

“That isn’t fair.”

“He asked me if he was in trouble,” I said. “Standing right next to you. You walked back to your office.”

Scott opened his mouth. And Justine stood up.

She still had her Bible. She held it against her chest with both arms, the way Zion holds a stuffed animal at the doctor’s.

“You told me she asked,” Justine said.

Scott turned around. “Jus.”

“You came home Wednesday and you told me Lizbeth asked about Warrensburg. You said she was relieved. You said she cried because she was grateful.” Her voice was going up and she let it. “I made a casserole. I was going to bring it to her.”

I had no idea what to do with that. Somewhere in Sedalia there was a grateful-mother casserole with my name on it.

“I said she’d be relieved eventually,” Scott said.

“No, you didn’t.” Justine looked at the screen, at Zion with his fork. “You put a little boy on a pancake flyer twice and you lied to me in my own kitchen.”

She walked out the middle aisle. Not the side door. The middle, past every pew, with two hundred people watching her go. The big doors at the back swung shut behind her, and the sound was like a gavel.

The bell rope

That was when it broke open.

The dad from the Walmart lot stood up. His name was Angelo. He was still in his work jacket because he’d come straight from a night shift.

“I told Lizbeth I didn’t want to be that guy,” he said. “I’m that guy now. My boy Chun said Miss Trisha told them not to pick Zion because he’d slow the team down. He’s seven. He thought it was a rule.”

Trisha started crying on the front pew. Loud, honest crying, nose and everything.

“I didn’t know what to do with him,” she said. “I asked for help. I asked for a buddy. I asked in August. Scott said the money was for the roof if the roof went.”

The roof fund. He’d been announcing the roof fund when I stood up.

Ernesto turned around to face the room. Elders at Cedar Hill don’t do this. They pass plates and sit up front and nod.

“The board is in this room,” he said. “All five of us. I’m calling a vote right now, and I don’t care if it’s in the bylaws.”

Rosemary Swanson, eighty-one, who still played organ when Paolo’s mother had the flu, said, “Second,” before he’d even said what the vote was.

“The $5,200 is frozen,” Ernesto said. “It doesn’t go to the roof or the furnace or anything else. It goes where the flyer said. A buddy program, by Wednesday after next, with trained people, and Lizbeth sees every receipt.”

Five hands went up.

“Trisha,” Ernesto said, more gently, “you’re done with Wednesday club. You can help in the nursery if you want to. Not with the big kids.”

She nodded and kept crying.

Then he looked at Scott. Fifty-two years old, gray suit, standing on the carpet in front of the platform he’d preached from for eleven years.

“Scott, the board is asking you to step down. Today. We’ll pay you through the end of the month. We’ll need the office keys and the login.”

“You can’t do this in front of the congregation,” Scott said.

“You did it in front of an eight-year-old,” Ernesto said.

Scott looked at me. For a second I thought he’d say sorry and I’d have to decide what to do with it.

“I gave this church eleven years,” he said. “One mother with a folder doesn’t get to undo that.”

“Nine parents,” I said. “And your wife.”

He took his keys out of his pocket. A big ring, maybe thirty keys, with a little brass cross on it. He put them on the communion table. They made a flat, ugly clank. Then he went out the side door Trisha hadn’t used.

Nobody sang. Rosemary went to the organ anyway and played the closing hymn with no words on the screen, because Zion was still up there twelve feet tall with his fork, and nobody, not one person, asked Paolo to take him down.

Six more sleeps

Thursday morning, at breakfast, Zion said, “Six more sleeps.”

I’d told him Wednesday night was going to be a little different. I hadn’t told him why. He’s never been good at pretending, and I didn’t want him walking in carrying anything he didn’t have to.

Friday it was five. Saturday four. By Monday he was reporting the countdown to dogs. I heard him tell Moose through the fence, “Three more sleeps, Moose,” and Moose, who is fourteen, wagged once to be polite.

The receipts came to my email on Tuesday, all of them, from Ernesto, who types with one finger and signs every message E. Sayegh, Elder like it’s a telegram. There were two buddy volunteers, background-checked. One was Menachem, a special-ed aide from the middle school who’d been coming to Cedar Hill for a year without anybody asking what he did for work. There was training for six more people. A rug for the circle, big enough for everybody. Balls that are soft, for games where nobody needs to watch.

The total was $5,200.00. Ernesto had attached the budget page, and the line now read zero.

Diamond texted me a picture of the new spring flyer. It said Spring Pancake Breakfast, and under it was a drawing of a pancake with a face, done by Hana. No children anywhere on it.

Better? she wrote.

It has six legs, I wrote back, because it did, and then I had to sit down in my kitchen for a minute, and the dish towel was in my hand again.

Wednesday, at 6:25, Zion was dressed by 4:30. He made me check the front pocket of his backpack twice.

The church parking lot was fuller than a Wednesday has any right to be. Parents were standing around like it was a ballgame. Angelo was there with Chun. Kimiko was there with no kids at all, just there.

Menachem met us at the door. He crouched down to Zion’s height and said, “I’m Menachem. Do you have a dog?”

Zion stared at him. Nobody at that church had ever asked him first.

“No,” Zion said. “But I know Pepper.”

“Tell me about Pepper.”

Zion unzipped the front pocket, took out the folded drawing, and opened it up. Six black legs.

“She has extra,” he said.

“I can see that,” Menachem said. “Can we hang her up in the room?”

They went down the hall together, and Zion didn’t look back once. That’s how I knew.

I stood in the doorway for the first game. They’d put the new rug in the middle. Hana picked Zion first. She didn’t even make a show of it, just pointed at him like it was obvious, and he ran over and hit her in the hip with both arms the way he hits me, and they both fell down laughing on the soft ball.

The drawing of Pepper was taped to the wall by the cubbies, right where his chair used to be.

At 7:45 I was back in the hall for pickup. Scott was there.

He’d come for a box from the office. He was in jeans and a polo shirt, holding a cardboard box with a lamp sticking out of it, and he stopped when he saw the doorway, where you could see the circle, and Zion in the middle of it, telling a story about Biscuit with his whole body.

“He looks happy,” Scott said.

“He is,” I said, and walked past him to get my son.

Zion ran down the hall and hit me in the hip with both arms.

“Mama,” he said, into my good blue sweater. “Seven more sleeps.”

For more stories about families standing up when loved ones are treated unfairly, read what happened when a soldier came home from Poland and the slushie poured on a young athlete’s score notebook. There’s also the empty envelope at a son’s graduation party, a small gesture with a big sting.