Our Dead President Left One Decision to a Dog

Daniel Foster

Our sister Delphine Rourke died of an aneurysm at the age of sixty on a Wednesday evening in April of last year. Her will, which her attorney carried out to our roadhouse the following Sunday, held three instructions. Burn her cut. Scatter her ashes along one specific bend of Route 41. And let her nine-year-old Cane Corso Anvil select his next owner from among the thirteen full-patch members of our chapter. We arranged folding chairs in a circle that next Sunday. We let the dog walk into the center. We waited.

Her name was Delphine.

She was sixty years old. Five foot eleven. Two hundred and ten pounds. A thick black braid shot through with grey that she had worn the same way since she was thirty-two. A raised scar running from her left eyebrow down across her cheek from a chain that had snapped loose in 1993. Knuckle tattoos that spelled DUST on one hand and BONE on the other – the name of the small custom chopper shop she had owned and run in Little Rock for twenty-four years.

She had been a member of the Ash Widows Motorcycle Club, Little Rock chapter, for twenty-six years.

She had been our chapter president for fourteen of those years.

She had been my closest friend for eighteen.

I’m Junie Aldercott. I’m fifty-five. I am the current vice president of the Ash Widows Little Rock chapter. I have been Delphine’s second since I patched in to this club in 2006. I am writing this with the direct permission of every member named in it. Several of them sat with me while I worked through the drafts. Every one of us has read every paragraph.

Anvil is a nine-year-old Cane Corso. One hundred and four pounds. A grey-brindle Corso with a broad square skull, a thin crescent of white fur across his throat, three dark paws and one that came out pale, and a right ear that folds forward at the tip no matter how many times you smooth it back. His coat is the color of wet asphalt – slate grey with faint charcoal striping. His eyes are the color of weak tea. There is a shallow groove above his right eye from a bracket he clipped in Delphine’s shop at eighteen months old.

Delphine took Anvil in as a seven-week-old puppy in 2016 from a small rescue outside Conway, Arkansas. Anvil went everywhere she went. He had his own bolted platform on the back of Delphine’s 1998 Harley-Davidson Road King – a matte-black bagger she had stripped and rebuilt herself in her shop in 1998 and ridden nearly every day for twenty-six years.

Anvil had covered, by Delphine’s own tally, somewhere past one hundred and sixty thousand miles across seventeen states.

Delphine went down in the front office of her shop on a Wednesday evening at 7:14 p.m. She was four months past her sixtieth birthday. The coroner said a ruptured brain aneurysm. She almost certainly never knew it was happening.

Anvil had been lying across the doorway about eight feet away. He had not made a sound. He had crossed the room to where Delphine lay on the tile and lowered himself down against her side. He had stayed there close to four hours, until our shop lead Marcelina came back from picking up a shipment, found them, and started making calls.

Delphine’s funeral was that Saturday at the small Catholic church on Asher Avenue where her grandmother had taken her every week as a girl. Forty-seven riders came.

The following Sunday, Delphine’s attorney, a soft-spoken deliberate woman named Ruthann Peale who had handled her affairs for nineteen years, drove out to our roadhouse on Roosevelt Road. She sat down at our long pine table in the back room. She unfastened her briefcase. She removed a single sheet of paper.

Ruthann Read the Part Twice

She put on her glasses.

“These instructions are to be read aloud to the members of the Little Rock chapter of the Ash Widows Motorcycle Club, all thirteen full-patch members present.”

Nobody moved.

Ruthann looked up. “She was very clear about the number.”

Tessa Burke, our treasurer, said, “We heard you.”

Ruthann read.

“First: My cut is to be burned by my sisters, without ceremony, before sunset.”

Tessa made a small sound through her nose. Delphine’s vest was hanging in the office on a wooden peg. The leather had softened where her shoulders had pressed it for years. Her patch was still sewn across the back. ASH WIDOWS in a white crescent. LITTLE ROCK underneath. The skull in the center had one red thread through its left eye, put there by Delphine because she said perfect work made her suspicious.

“Second: My ashes are to be scattered at Mile Marker 83 on Route 41, at the sharp left bend before the old quarry road.”

That was where Delphine had crashed her first bike. Not badly. Bad enough to break her collarbone and spend two nights in county hospital. She’d been twenty-seven.

Ruthann lowered the page.

“Third: Anvil is to select his next owner from the thirteen full-patch members of this chapter. No member may call him, command him, touch him, offer food, or block another member from approaching him. His choice is final.”

The old refrigerator in the corner kicked on.

That was the first debt paid. We had the actual words.

Then Ruthann reached into the briefcase again and pulled out a smaller envelope. It was cream-colored, sealed with black wax. Delphine’s handwriting sat across the front.

For Junie. Open only after the first reading.

My name looked wrong in her hand.

Not because she had written it wrong. Delphine’s J always leaned forward like it wanted to leave the page. This one was careful. Slow.

I opened it with a butter knife from the kitchen because nobody could find the letter opener.

Inside was a single index card.

Don’t let them turn this into a vote.

Under that, she had written:

You know what happens when twelve people want to be right.

That was all.

I looked at Tessa. She stared at the card.

Our road captain, Beverly Sloan, leaned back in her chair. “We aren’t voting.”

“Not yet,” I said.

The Vest Went First

At 4:38 that afternoon, we took Delphine’s cut outside.

The rain had stopped, but the parking lot was black with it. Somebody had dragged an old steel wash tub beside the burn barrel. We put the vest inside. Nobody said a prayer. Delphine would have hated that. She once walked out of a memorial service because the pastor called motorcycles “machines of reckless temptation.”

Marcelina held the match.

She was thirty-eight, the youngest full-patch member, and had worked at DUST & BONE for eleven years. Her brown hair was clipped short on one side because a belt sander had caught it in 2019. She still had a pale line at her temple from that day.

“Me?” she asked.

I nodded.

The leather caught slowly. The back patch curled. Delphine’s name went last.

Anvil sat beside the rear door and watched the smoke come up. He didn’t whine. He didn’t turn away.

When the skull patch blackened, he stood.

Every woman in the lot looked at him.

He walked to the empty spot where Delphine’s Road King had been parked, put his nose against the concrete, and stayed there.

Nobody had moved the bike.

It was at DUST & BONE, covered with a grey tarp. We had not been able to decide what to do with it. Delphine had left the keys in the ignition when she died. Marcelina had taken them out and put them on the desk. They were still there.

That night, we argued until 11:17.

Not about whether the will was legal. Ruthann had already explained that the language had been checked three times, witnessed, and filed. Not about whether a dog could understand ownership. Nobody in that room believed Anvil understood contracts.

We argued about what Delphine meant by “select.”

Tessa wanted a supervised walk.

“That gives him room,” she said. “We line up, he walks, he stops.”

Beverly wanted each member to spend ten minutes alone with him.

“He knows all of us,” Beverly said. “That’s the problem. We can’t make it a sniff test in a room.”

“I can tell you who he’ll pick,” said Karen Doyle from the end of the table.

Nobody asked her who.

She said, “The person who feeds him.”

That was aimed at me.

I had fed Anvil every Thursday for six years when Delphine worked late. I knew he hated bananas, tolerated chicken, and would steal a whole loaf of bread if you turned your back. I had never once called myself his person.

“Don’t be stupid,” I said.

Karen shrugged. “You asked for thoughts.”

“We didn’t.”

“Then don’t look at me.”

Anvil was lying under the table with his head on his paws. He opened one eye.

Delphine Had Already Seen the Fight

The next morning, Ruthann called me from her office.

“There are two more documents,” she said. “They aren’t part of the will.”

“What kind of documents?”

“A letter and a video.”

I drove to her office on Markham Street. The sign out front said PEALE LAW, though the P in Peale had lost half its paint. Ruthann gave me coffee in a mug shaped like a frog. I didn’t drink it.

The letter was dated January 12.

“She wrote this before her birthday,” Ruthann said. “She came in alone.”

I read it at her desk.

Junie,

If you’re reading this, either I’m dead or you finally got tired of asking me what I keep in the blue file.

Don’t be dramatic. You were always dramatic about locked drawers.

The chapter has been safe because I made the hard calls before anybody else had to. That’s not the same as saying the chapter is strong. A house can stand for a long time with a bad post in it.

I don’t want a vote. Votes make people count favors. I don’t want the loudest woman in the room. I don’t want the one who has been waiting longest.

Anvil knows who comes back after the room empties.

Give him the room.

There was more.

And Junie, if he doesn’t choose you, don’t make him pay for your pride.

I read that line twice.

Then I folded the paper along its old crease.

“What is in the blue file?” I asked.

Ruthann’s mouth pulled to one side. “That comes after the video.”

The video showed Delphine in her office at DUST & BONE. She was wearing a grey T-shirt and safety glasses pushed up on her head. Anvil was asleep beneath the desk.

She had set the camera on a shelf. Her face filled most of the frame.

“I don’t like recording myself,” she said. “I look like somebody trying to sell a timeshare.”

Off camera, a woman’s voice said, “You could start over.”

“That would be cheating.”

It was Marcelina.

Delphine glanced toward her. “No. It’s planning.”

“You still haven’t told them.”

“They don’t need to know yet.”

“Junie does.”

“Junie knows too much already.”

Marcelina went quiet.

Delphine rubbed the scar over her eye. “The dog isn’t magic. Don’t let them make him magic. He knows routines. He knows fear. He knows who stands outside my office after an argument instead of going home.”

“That’s not a test.”

“No. It’s a dog.”

The video ended there.

I sat with Ruthann’s frog mug between my hands.

“What were they talking about?” I asked.

She opened a drawer and took out a blue accordion folder.

“About the property.”

The Blue File Had Teeth

DUST & BONE sat on three lots near the railroad tracks. The building had been a tire warehouse before Delphine bought it. She put in two lifts, a parts room, a front office, and a bathroom with a door that never closed all the way.

The land was worth more than the business.

A developer named Cormac Hale had been trying to buy it for eighteen months. He wanted to put up storage units. Delphine had refused him each time, including the time he brought a bottle of expensive bourbon and called her “sweetheart.”

The blue file held tax papers, inspection reports, and a purchase offer for $1.8 million.

It also held three letters from Hale’s attorney.

The last one said the offer would be withdrawn on May 1.

That was twelve days away.

Delphine had signed a separate paper leaving DUST & BONE to the chapter, with the condition that it remain a working shop for at least ten years. The money in her personal accounts would cover the mortgage, payroll, and taxes for two years. After that, whoever ran the shop would have to make it work.

Ruthann pointed to a paragraph.

“She wanted the chapter to own the building. The president would manage the operation, but not sell it.”

I looked at the purchase offer again.

“So this is why she chose a dog.”

“She chose a dog because she knew thirteen people would be sitting in a room with money on the table.”

“She knew that before the aneurysm?”

“She had high blood pressure. She was not careless about it.”

I hated that sentence. It made death sound like a missed appointment.

There was one more page in the file. A list of every member and the date she had joined.

Beside some names, Delphine had written notes.

Tessa: good with numbers, hates being questioned.

Beverly: brave when moving, uncertain when stopped.

Karen: loyal to whoever spoke last.

Beside my name, there was only this:

Junie: will carry the whole thing until her knees give out.

I closed the folder.

“Who knew about the sale?”

“Marcelina did,” Ruthann said. “She was helping Delphine inspect the roof.”

“Anyone else?”

“Not from anything Delphine told me.”

That wasn’t true.

There was a copy of the offer in the folder with Tessa’s initials on the bottom corner.

Thirteen Chairs, One Open Door

We held the selection the following Sunday at 2 p.m.

The chairs went in a circle in the back room of the roadhouse. We left the door to the parking lot open. The old jukebox was unplugged. Somebody had swept cigarette ash into a crooked pile near the wall.

The thirteen members sat down.

Tessa wore her treasurer’s patch and a yellow work shirt. Beverly had her boots unlaced. Karen kept rubbing the edge of her left cuff. Pam Fisher brought a bottle of water and forgot where she set it. Joyce Pruitt sat with both hands flat on her knees.

Marcelina stood by the open door.

She had asked not to sit.

“You’re one of the thirteen,” I told her.

“I know.”

“Then sit.”

She did.

Ruthann placed Anvil’s leash on the floor in front of her. He wore no collar. Delphine had hated collars with dangling tags because they caught on machinery.

I read the rules again.

“No calling him. No touching him. No food. No blocking.”

Karen raised her hand.

“This isn’t school,” Beverly said.

Karen ignored her. “What if he picks nobody?”

“Then we wait,” I said.

Anvil entered from the hall.

He looked at each of us once. His nails clicked on the concrete. He went to Tessa first and sniffed the toe of her boot. Tessa’s face stayed still, but her fingers curled against her thighs.

He moved to Beverly.

She started to say his name.

I shook my head.

Beverly shut her mouth.

Anvil went around the circle. Pam. Joyce. Karen. The others. He paused beside me long enough to smell the hem of my jeans, then kept moving.

At the door, he stopped.

Marcelina was crying.

Not loudly. A single line had run down from the corner of her nose and dropped onto her shirt. She wiped it with the back of her hand and looked angry about the evidence.

Anvil walked past her.

He went out into the parking lot.

Every chair scraped at once.

“Nobody follow him,” I said.

He crossed to the far side of the building, where Delphine’s Road King sat under its tarp. The wind lifted one corner. Anvil put his nose beneath it.

Then he looked back at the door.

At me.

At Marcelina.

He walked back inside.

Straight to Marcelina.

She had both hands over her mouth.

Anvil sat on her boots.

The Thing Marcelina Hadn’t Told Us

Nobody spoke for nearly a minute.

Then Tessa stood.

“That isn’t a selection.”

Anvil didn’t move.

Tessa pointed at Marcelina. “She works at the shop. Of course he knows her.”

“All of us know her,” Beverly said.

“Not like that.”

Marcelina took her hands away from her face. “Say what you mean.”

“You knew about Hale’s offer.”

Marcelina looked at me.

That was enough.

I stood. “How long?”

She swallowed. “Since February.”

Tessa pushed her chair back. “You were going to sell it.”

“No.”

“You signed the copy.”

“Because Delphine told me to.”

Nobody looked at Anvil now.

Marcelina reached into her jacket and took out a folded paper. She held it toward me.

It was a letter from Delphine, dated March 3.

Marce,

If they ask, tell them the offer is real. Let Tessa see it if she snoops. She will. Don’t stop her.

I need to know who starts counting money before the funeral flowers are dead.

The property isn’t for sale. The shop is staying open. If I die before I finish this, Junie has the file and Anvil has the room.

You have the keys. Keep them until the choice is made.

I read the letter aloud.

Tessa’s face changed at the line about snooping.

“I didn’t snoop,” she said.

“Your initials are on the offer.”

“I was checking the figures.”

“Why?” Beverly asked.

Tessa looked around the circle. Her chair had left a grey mark on the floor. “Because the chapter is broke.”

Nobody answered.

She kept going, faster now. “We owe thirty-two thousand in back taxes. The roof needs twenty grand. The insurance went up again. Delphine knew all of it and kept saying the shop would turn around. What was I supposed to do, clap?”

“You were supposed to tell us,” I said.

“I did. She told me to stop counting things that didn’t belong to me.”

That sounded like Delphine.

It also sounded cruel.

Marcelina wiped her face. “She wasn’t testing who wanted the money.”

“Then what was she testing?” Karen asked.

Marcelina looked down at Anvil.

“Who’d stay.”

The Last Room

Ruthann had one final envelope.

She took it from the briefcase and placed it on the table. This one was addressed to the chapter.

The seal broke under her thumb.

“Junie,” she said, “you read it.”

I didn’t want to.

That was my first thought. Not I can’t. Not I should. I simply wanted Ruthann to keep holding the paper so the next thing would remain next.

I opened it.

My sisters,

If Anvil has chosen, then you already know more than I can tell you.

I picked him because none of you would accept a person I named. You’d say I favored her. You’d say I feared another one. You’d be right on both counts.

He has no vote. He has a nose, a memory, and a terrible habit of sitting on the feet of people who are trying to leave.

A few women made a broken laugh.

The letter continued.

The person he chose has been in my shop every morning at 6:10 for eleven years. She opens the bay doors. She checks the heat. She cleans the coffee pot even when nobody thanks her. When I was too proud to ask for help, she put the help in front of me anyway.

She thinks this is about the building. It isn’t. The building is cinder block and a roof that leaks over the parts room.

The shop is the promise.

Keep it open. Pay people on Fridays. Don’t let Hale buy the ground from under you. Don’t let my name turn into a sign while everybody else collects a check.

Junie, you are not allowed to hand this back because you think I meant you.

I stopped reading.

Marcelina whispered, “Keep going.”

I did.

I meant Marcelina.

Her hand went to Anvil’s head. She stopped before touching him, remembering the rule even after the choice was made.

She will say she isn’t ready. She will say she only knows the work. That’s exactly why.

Junie, stand beside her. Not in front.

The page ended with Delphine’s signature.

Under it, in smaller writing:

And somebody please fix the bathroom door.

Nobody laughed that time.

I sat down.

Marcelina was staring at the floor. “I can’t run a chapter.”

“You can run a shop,” I said.

“I can’t run a shop either.”

“You’ve been doing it while Delphine took naps in the office.”

“She was checking invoices.”

“She was asleep.”

“She had one eye open.”

That was true. Delphine could sleep through a thunderstorm and wake up when somebody touched her socket set.

Anvil leaned against Marcelina’s legs.

She finally put both hands on his head.

He closed his eyes.

Mile Marker 83

We went to Route 41 before sunset.

Nine motorcycles. One pickup carrying the urn. Ruthann followed in her little blue Honda, which Delphine used to call the church car.

The bend before the old quarry road was sharper than I remembered. Tall weeds grew through the broken shoulder. Somebody had nailed a green street sign to a pine tree years ago, though there was no street behind it.

We parked in the gravel.

Marcelina carried the urn. Anvil walked beside her without a leash.

The wind came hard from the south. It pushed our jackets against our backs and sent grit across the road.

Delphine’s ashes were heavier than I expected.

I had held her hand in the hospital after they brought her in. I had held her helmet at the funeral. The urn was different. The whole of her fit inside something that could go under one arm.

Marcelina unscrewed the lid.

Nobody said anything.

She scattered the ashes at the edge of the bend, not into the road. The white dust caught on the weeds, settled over the red dirt, and disappeared in pieces.

Anvil walked to the spot.

He sniffed once.

Then he lifted his pale paw and set it down in the ashes.

Marcelina made a sound that wasn’t a word.

I reached for her shoulder, but she caught my wrist first.

“Don’t,” she said.

So I didn’t.

We stood there while the traffic went by. A silver sedan slowed. The driver stared at nine women in leather beside a giant dog and then thought better of stopping.

Back at the shop, Marcelina unlocked the front door.

The keys had been in her pocket since February.

She turned on the lights. The first bulb over the parts counter buzzed and failed. The bathroom door swung open by itself and stayed that way.

Anvil crossed the floor to Delphine’s old office.

He lay down in the doorway.

Marcelina looked at him, then at the rows of motorcycles waiting under their covers.

“Tomorrow at 6:10?” she asked.

“Tomorrow at 6:10,” I said.

She nodded.

Then she picked up Delphine’s red shop rag from the desk and went to clean the coffee pot.

Would you have trusted Anvil’s choice? Tell me, and pass this story along to someone who knows what a promise costs.

If you’re looking for more incredible animal stories, you won’t want to miss My Rescue Dog Pressed Against the Spot Where Cancer Was Growing or the heartwarming tale of I Cut the Cable Off a German Shepherd Who Had Never Left Her Circle. And for a completely different kind of mystery, check out My Son Walked Into the Forest and Came Back With Someone Else.