My Mother’s Church Friend Heard Her Own Laugh Come Out Of My TV

Daniel Foster

My mother fed nineteen church friends a catered Thanksgiving in my house on the $11,600 I’d wired her to look after my wife, sixteen days out of spine surgery, and put my wife in the back bedroom with a sleeve of saltines. “She can’t sit at a table anyway,” Mom told them. She had no idea my flight got in three days early.

Two discs fused in Lan’s lower back, a nine-year-old who still needed rides to school, and me welding pipe in West Texas until the middle of December.

That’s why I sent it.

Mom offered before I even asked. She packed a suitcase and moved into our guest room the day Lan came home with the walker.

“Send it to me, I’ll handle groceries and gas,” she said on the phone. “You just work, honey.”

So I did. $1,450 every Friday for eight weeks.

Our crew finished a section early. I paid $640 for a seat out of Midland and told nobody, because I needed to see Delaney’s face when I came through the door.

There were eleven cars on our street in Waterville when the cab let me out.

One was parked on my lawn.

Inside it smelled like turkey and somebody else’s perfume. A football game was on my television. Folding chairs I’d never seen lined both sides of our dining table, and both leaves were in it.

A man I’d never met was asleep in my recliner holding a can of ginger ale.

My mother sat at the head in a new burgundy sweater. My sister Skylar was carving. Her husband Pawel had his socks up on my coffee table.

Mom saw me first. Her smile stayed. Her eyes didn’t.

“Kareem. You said Sunday.”

“Where’s Lan?”

“Resting. She’s not up for company.” She turned to the table. “My son. Works in oil. Sends money home like clockwork.”

A lady named Ernestine squeezed my arm and said I must be so proud of my mother.

I went looking.

Delaney was in the laundry room, at the card table we keep for puzzles, wedged between the washer and the water heater. A paper plate. Two rolls and some corn.

ALONE.

“Daddy?”

She didn’t run at me. She checked the hallway first.

“Grandma said the big table is for grown-ups,” she said. “Aunt Skylar said I’d spill.”

“Where’s Mom?”

“Sleeping. She sleeps a lot.” She pushed a roll around the plate. “We had cereal for dinner Tuesday and Wednesday. Grandma said the store didn’t deliver.”

The groceries come every Monday. I set that order up myself from a motel in Odessa. $310 a week.

The thermostat in our bedroom said 61.

Lan was on top of the covers in my old hoodie, lying on her side the way the surgeon told her to.

On the nightstand sat a sleeve of saltines, half gone, a gallon jug of tap water, and her pain pill bottle with the cap off.

Empty.

“You’re early,” she said. She started to push up on one elbow and her face went white.

“Don’t. Stay down.”

“Don’t be mad at her. Please. She’s been cooking since six.”

“For who?”

“Her church.” She closed her eyes. “Skylar said the walker would make people uncomfortable.”

“When did you last eat something hot?”

She had to think about it.

That was the answer.

“Lan, where’s the food from Monday?”

“I never see it come in. I asked for soup Tuesday and Skylar said they were out of soup.”

“Out of soup.”

“That’s what she said. And your mom said the pharmacy needed your okay for my refill.”

The pharmacy has never needed my okay for anything.

I didn’t go back out there yelling. I sat on the edge of the bed and opened the doorbell camera app.

Monday, 9:14 in the morning. The delivery driver sets six bags on the porch. Skylar carries them out two at a time, right past our door, to the back of her car.

The Monday before that. Same thing.

Seven Mondays. SEVEN.

Then a clip from Saturday afternoon. Mom on the porch with Ernestine, a pie box between them.

“She milks that back for everything,” my mother said out of my phone’s speaker. “Kareem pays for it all anyway. Why shouldn’t I get one nice holiday?”

Ernestine laughed.

Lan heard it. She turned her face into the pillow and didn’t say a word.

I tucked the blanket over her feet, plugged her phone in where she could reach it, and walked back to the dining room.

They were holding hands for grace. Mom had her head down.

“Lord, thank you for this family and this beautiful table, and for my son, who—”

“Before anybody eats,” I said, “I want everybody to see something.”

I found the clip and tapped the little screen icon.

The football game went black.

My mother’s head came up with her mouth still shaped for grace.

“Kareem, honey. Not in front of people.”

“EVERY DOLLAR ON THIS TABLE came from me, Mom. I sent it for my wife. And my wife is in the back eating CRACKERS.”

Skylar set the carving fork down very slowly.

“It’s not what it looks like,” she said.

“Then you won’t mind if they watch.”

Mom reached for the remote on the sideboard.

I got there first.

Nineteen faces turned toward the screen, and Pawel finally took his feet off my coffee table.

I pressed play.

Monday, 9:14

The first thing on the screen was my sister’s back.

Sixty-five inches of it. A puffy green vest, a grocery bag in each hand, going down my porch steps and across my lawn to the back of a gray Equinox. The same Equinox that was sitting in my flower bed right now with its hazards off.

The white numbers in the corner said MON 9:14 AM.

Nobody at the table said a word. A man near the end had a roll halfway to his mouth and he left it there.

I let it run out and tapped the next one. Then the next. Seven Mondays. She wore the same vest in four of them.

Then Saturday. The porch. The pie box.

“She milks that back for everything,” my mother said, out of both speakers, loud enough to hear in the kitchen. “Kareem pays for it all anyway. Why shouldn’t I get one nice holiday?”

Then Ernestine’s laugh, big and clear, while Ernestine sat four chairs down holding her napkin in both hands like it might get away.

I kept the remote. I held it down by my leg, on the side away from the sideboard.

The man in the recliner woke up, looked at the TV, and set his ginger ale on the floor.

Mom stood. She smoothed the front of the burgundy sweater with both palms. There was a little plastic tag thread still sticking out of one cuff.

“Okay,” she said to the table, bright, the voice she uses on the phone with the gas company. “Everybody eat before it gets cold. Kareem’s been on a plane all day. He’s tired.”

She came around the table and took my elbow, the way she used to take it in the Kroger parking lot when I was six.

“Kitchen,” she said in my ear. “You don’t even know the arrangement.”

The walker

The walker came home with Lan on a Tuesday in early October, folded in the trunk with the yellow tennis balls already on its feet.

Delaney drew faces on all four of those balls with a Sharpie that night. One had a mustache.

Mom was on our porch before we got Lan out of the car. One rolling suitcase. Pawel came up behind her carrying her cedar chest, the one from the foot of her bed on Secor Road, and Mom said it was for her winter things, because it was going to be a long fall.

I didn’t think about the chest. I was holding Lan under both arms.

My mother is the woman at church who shows up. Funerals, new babies, the man with the bad hip who needs a ride to dialysis, she’s there with a casserole and a sign-up sheet. People in that building have been telling me how lucky I am since I was in Cub Scouts.

She raised Skylar and me on a school cafeteria paycheck after Dad left. I owed her, and she never once let me forget it, and I never once minded.

Skylar was always the one who needed something. A car, a deposit, a lawyer that one time. Mom always found it. I was the one who sent it.

That first week, Mom and I talked every night while I sat in the truck outside the motel in Odessa.

She kept her receipts in a brown accordion folder, always had. A receipt for a pack of gum went in the folder. She’d read me the Kroger total every night like a weather report.

“And they want another hundred and forty a month on Secor at renewal,” she said one night. “Halloween. At my age.”

“Move in with us,” I said. I was joking. Mostly.

She laughed. “Don’t tempt me.”

Then she asked how many rooms a girl Delaney’s age really needed, and laughed at that too, and I laughed with her, because I was eleven hundred miles away and my mother was taking care of everything.

Warren, my foreman, had us flying back Sunday night for the last section. Three more weeks of twelve-hour days, then home for good by the middle of December.

That was the deal I’d made with Lan. Three weeks.

Mom pushed the swinging door open with her back, still holding my elbow.

On the counter sat four aluminum catering trays with the lids peeled back. Taped to the top one was a pink receipt.

Ronald’s Catering. Barakat, 19 guests. PAID IN FULL, cash. $1,380.

The purse

“Don’t look at me like that,” Mom said. “I’m sixty-six years old. You know what it costs to feed nineteen people?”

“I do now.”

“That’s not even your money. That’s the house money. You said groceries and gas. A turkey is groceries.”

“Mom. Lan’s pill bottle is empty.”

“She takes too many.” She picked up a serving spoon and put it down again. “You give a woman in that kind of pain a full bottle, you’re asking for it. Somebody has to keep track.”

The door swung. Skylar came in wiping her hands on a dish towel. Pawel stood in the doorway behind her with his socks on the tile.

“You can’t just come in here and do that,” Skylar said. “Those are Mom’s friends.”

“You carried six bags a week to your car.”

“Because we NEEDED it. Do you know what Pawel’s hours are like? You’re in Texas making whatever you make. We’re the ones who are here.”

“Here eating my groceries.”

“Here taking care of your wife.”

Pawel said, “She’s not wrong,” and then nothing else.

I took my phone out and called the Walgreens on Monroe Street, the twenty-four-hour one, because it was Thanksgiving and I wanted to hear it from somebody who wasn’t related to me.

A woman picked up on the fourth ring. I gave her Lan’s name and birthday.

“That one’s been filled,” she said. “Picked up last Wednesday, the nineteenth. Signature on file is Mavis Barakat.”

“Did anybody call you about needing my okay?”

“Sir, nobody needs your okay. She’s the patient.”

I hung up. Mom already had her purse off the hook by the back door. She opened it on the counter and took out a full orange bottle like she’d been waiting to.

“Thirty,” she said. “Count them. I give her one when she needs it. Nobody’s stealing anything.”

“She’s had none since this morning.”

“She was asleep.”

I took the bottle out of her hand. It was easy. She let me.

Skylar threw the towel on the counter.

“Mom, just tell him about the room. He’s going to find out anyway.”

Delaney’s closet

I didn’t ask what room. I got a bowl of the mashed potatoes from the tray, put one pill in my shirt pocket, filled a glass, and went down the hall.

Behind me Mom said, “Skylar, honestly,” and the swinging door thumped twice.

Lan took the pill and half the bowl. Her hand shook on the spoon. I held the bowl.

“Is it bad out there?” she said.

“Eat.”

Delaney came to the bedroom door in her socks. She’d brought her paper plate with her. The corn was gone.

“Can I sleep in here tonight?” she said.

“Yeah. Go get your pajamas.”

She didn’t go. She stood there.

“I can’t get to them,” she said. “Grandma’s stuff is in my closet.”

I went with her.

Her room looked the way it always does, the glow stars on the ceiling, the bed, the bean bag with the split seam. The closet door wouldn’t slide all the way open.

Boxes. Floor to the shelf. Brown moving boxes from U-Haul, taped and labeled in my mother’s block capitals. KITCHEN. WINTER COATS. BATHROOM. CHURCH. PICTURES, FRONT ROOM.

Delaney’s clothes were in two laundry baskets on the closet floor under them.

“When did these come?”

“After Halloween. Uncle Pawel brought them in his truck.” She pulled a pajama top out of a basket by its sleeve. “Grandma said after Christmas you’re going to fix up the laundry room for me. Because I’m small and she needs a closet.”

“Grandma said I said that?”

“She said you said yes on the phone.”

I pulled the top box down. It was heavy. Picture frames, wrapped in our dish towels. Mom and Dad’s wedding. My Cub Scout photo. Skylar in her cap and gown.

These weren’t winter things. You don’t pack your wedding picture for a long fall.

Under the frames was a plastic sign with a suction cup, the kind you hang on a door, that Mom has had on every front door she’s ever had.

It said Welcome to Mavis’s.

Unit 2B

The guest room door was shut. Mom never shuts doors.

The bed was made tight. The cedar chest was at the foot of it. On the dresser, square to the edge, sat the brown accordion folder.

I opened it standing up.

The front pocket was receipts, the way it always was. Kroger, Meijer, the Shell station on Alexis. Behind those, a pocket of my own wire confirmations, printed, all eight, $1,450 each, the Friday dates in a row.

Clipped to each one was a sticky note in her writing.

Sky deposit, 1,450.

U-Haul + Pawel gas, 610. Sky, 840.

Sky, 1,450.

Caterer down payment, 700. Sweater.

I turned to the back pocket. There was a letter on Secor Road Apartments stationery.

Re: Unit 2B. This confirms assignment of the lease from Mavis Barakat to Skylar and Pawel Berglund, effective November 1. Security deposit to transfer with the unit.

Under it, a yellow card from the post office. Change of address, permanent, not temporary. Mavis Barakat. From Unit 2B, Secor Road. To my house. My street. My number.

Effective October 6. The Monday after Lan came home.

So that’s where the groceries went. Six bags a week to Unit 2B, to stock my sister’s new kitchen in my mother’s old apartment.

And my mother didn’t come to take care of my wife. She came to live in my house.

Every Friday I’d been paying her to move.

Behind me the floor creaked. Skylar was in the doorway with the dish towel back in her hand.

“Those are Mom’s private papers, Kareem.”

The Tuesday circle

I walked past her with the folder.

The dining room was quiet in the way a room is when people have been talking and stopped. Somebody had turned the TV off at the wall. Two women had their coats on their laps.

There was a poinsettia on the sideboard, next to where the remote had been, with a little white card on a plastic fork. I hadn’t looked at it the first time.

I pulled the card off and read it.

Welcome home, Mavis! With love from the Tuesday circle.

I set the folder on the table in front of my mother’s plate and put the card on top of it.

“Whose home, Mom?”

“Oh, for heaven’s sake.” She looked down the table and laughed, and nobody laughed with her. “He’s upset. He’s been gone two months and he walks in on a holiday. Kareem. Sit down. You’re making a scene in front of Pastor’s people.”

“You gave your apartment to Skylar.”

“I gave my apartment to my daughter, who needed it. That’s what a mother does. And then I came here and I took care of your house. Somebody had to. You think Lan’s going to be right after this? Two discs? I watched your Aunt Delia go through it and she never stood up straight again. You were going to need me here. You were going to need me forever, honey, and I was going to be here, and that’s the thanks, a slideshow.”

“You told Delaney I said yes.”

“You said it! On the phone! ‘Move in with us.’ I’ve got a memory, Kareem, even if you don’t.”

“I was joking.”

“Well, I wasn’t.”

At the far end, Ernestine put her napkin on her plate.

“Mavis,” she said. “You told us he begged you.”

Mom turned. “Ernestine, this is family.”

“You stood on that porch and told me she was putting it on. The walker. You said she was lazy and he was too soft to see it.” Ernestine looked at me. Her chin was going. “And I laughed. You heard me. I’m seventy years old and I laughed at a woman with her back cut open. I put twenty dollars in for that poinsettia.”

She stood up and took her coat off the back of the chair. The woman next to her stood too. Then the man from the recliner, who picked his ginger ale up off the floor first.

Nobody said goodbye to my mother. A couple of them said it to me.

The front door opened and shut eleven times. I counted the cars starting.

When it was the four of us, Mom said, “Well. You happy?”

“Pack your suitcase,” I said. “You’re going with Skylar tonight.”

Mom looked at Skylar. Skylar looked at the carving fork.

“We don’t have room,” Skylar said. “It’s a one-bedroom, Mom. You know it’s a one-bedroom. You said this was permanent. You said he’d never make you leave.”

“Skylar Ann.”

“I’m not putting you on my couch. Pawel works nights.”

Pawel had his shoes on now. He said, “It’s a small couch, Mavis.”

My mother looked at the two of them for a long time. Then she looked at the folder with all her sticky notes, every dollar in her own writing, and she didn’t touch it.

“Your father,” she said to me, “would never have talked to me like this.”

“Dad left, Mom. You told us that every day.”

That was all I said for the rest of it.

I went to the guest room and packed the rolling suitcase myself. Her robe, her Bible, her pill organizer, the burgundy sweater’s tags out of the trash can. I wheeled it out to the porch. Pawel and I carried the cedar chest down the steps together, and neither of us said a word about it.

Skylar cried the whole time she was loading the car. Not for Mom. Because the boxes had to go too, and her trunk was full of something already.

It was a case of Lan’s Ensure. From the Monday order. Still in the plastic.

I took it out and carried it back inside.

Skylar backed the Equinox off my lawn with Mom in the passenger seat, holding the poinsettia.

Monday

Sunday night, at the hour my flight would’ve left Midland, Warren texted me.

Need a yes or no on December, K. That’s three weeks. Seven grand you’re leaving on the table.

I wrote back No and put the phone face down.

The ruts from the Equinox are still in the front yard. I’ll reseed in April.

Monday morning I set the thermostat to 70 and moved the card table out of the laundry room and back into the den, where it goes. Delaney started a thousand-piece barn on it before school. She found two edges.

At 9:12 the doorbell camera pinged. The same driver, the same six bags on the porch.

Delaney beat me to the door. She carried them in two at a time, just like her aunt, except she brought them inside.

Lan was at the dining table. Both leaves still in, because I hadn’t gotten to them yet, and she was sitting at the head of it on the good cushion with the walker parked beside her. The mustache ball was facing out.

“Did they bring soup?” she said.

Delaney held up a can in each hand.

If someone you love is laid up right now, go see what’s on their nightstand yourself.

For more stories of family members crossing lines, read about the granddaughter whose pills were dismissed as nerves and the mother whose property taxes her son-in-law paid for years. There’s also the story of a stepmother who claimed credit for tuition earned through 612 overnight shifts.