My Husband Left His Mother’s Chair Empty

Lucy Evans

The spoon was still in the applesauce when I started calling.

At a quarter past twelve that Tuesday, I stood beside Arlene’s rented bed and dialed her son. The hospice nurse had given us hours. Curtis had given his mother eleven minutes the previous Wednesday, his only visit since hospice began.

Thursday morning, he’d left for a packaging contract in Omaha. Five days later, a little after one, somebody answered my twenty-seventh call.

A woman. Music and splashing behind her. She knew my name.

“He’s in the pool. We’re celebrating in Cabo. Stop calling. He doesn’t want to hear from you.”

I told her Arlene was dying. She answered with a bored question, then said Curtis thought his mother wouldn’t know whether he came.

Arlene heard. A tear slid toward her ear.

After the woman hung up, my mother-in-law shaped two words her stroke and failing heart wouldn’t let her say.

“I know,” I said for her.

Then she unfastened the chain I’d seen throughout nineteen years of marriage. I’d mistaken what hung beneath her nightgown for a cross. She placed a brass key in my hand and directed me toward her sewing basket.

Under the yarn lay an envelope addressed to Howard Ames, the attorney who’d handled her and Albert’s papers.

“I promise,” I told her.

Around 2:10, Rosanne Haskins came from the kitchen, listened to Arlene’s chest, and offered the apology nurses can never make large enough.

I left her house in Knoxville carrying her blue cardigan, pocketbook, and envelope. Curtis hadn’t called back. The chair I’d put beside his mother’s bed remained empty.

Home was eighteen minutes to the left. I drove right.

Outside Howard’s two-story brick office, beside the dentist, I parked crooked on the gravel. Her envelope rested on my passenger seat.

I opened my fist.

The key had pressed its shape into my palm.

The envelope on Howard’s desk

I carried everything inside because putting Arlene’s cardigan in the trunk felt like leaving her somewhere.

Howard came out before I reached the reception counter. He was about seventy, with his glasses hanging from a cord. He took one look at the cardigan and put his hand against the wall.

“Today?”

I nodded.

He led me into his office and closed the door. I sat with the sweater across my knees. There was a loose button near the bottom. I’d meant to sew it back on.

Of all the things to think about.

“She wanted you to have this.”

I pushed the envelope across his desk, then set the key beside it.

Howard didn’t ask where I’d found them. He opened the envelope, read the page inside, and sat back.

“That opens her safe-deposit box,” he said. “I’m authorized to access it as her trustee. She wanted you with me.”

“What trustee?”

He pulled a folder from his cabinet.

“After Albert died, Arlene put the house and her savings into a trust. She kept control during her lifetime. At her death, after expenses, they go to you.”

I put both hands over the cardigan.

Nine years since Albert’s funeral. Nine years of Curtis talking about what he’d do with his mother’s house someday.

“All of it?”

“The house and the remaining savings, yes.”

“What does Curtis get?”

Howard took his glasses off.

“Nothing under the trust. There’s also money we need to recover from him.”

I stared at the key. I’d expected something small enough to fit in a box. A letter, perhaps. Some family shame that could be folded away again.

Howard turned Arlene’s page toward me.

Her handwriting leaned across the paper. She’d written it before the stroke last spring.

Show Denise the statements. Don’t let him tell her I gave it to him.

I read that line twice.

“What’s he taken?”

“We’ll examine the records before we put a number to it.”

Howard poured me water from a bottle. I drank because he waited, which was apparently what it took to get me to do ordinary things.

“The trust wasn’t made today, Denise. This isn’t something she decided because of a phone call.”

I told him about Cabo.

Not gracefully. I got as far as the swimming pool and began crying so hard he pushed the wastebasket toward me in case I was sick.

At forty-seven, I was sitting in a lawyer’s office clutching a dead woman’s sweater while my fifty-year-old husband enjoyed a holiday somebody else might have paid for.

I wished I’d left the sandwich out of his bag.

That thought made me laugh, once, which came out worse than the crying.

Howard waited.

Then he asked whether I wanted him to notify Curtis.

“No. I’ll do that.”

I sent a message stating when his mother died. I told him arrangements would follow. I didn’t mention the key.

My thumb hovered over the place where I could add that she’d waited for him.

I’d already said it to the woman by the pool. I wouldn’t beg him to understand it twice.

The next morning, Wednesday, Howard met me at the bank. We completed the access requirements, and a bank employee took us to a private room with the box.

The little key turned.

Inside were statements bundled by year, copies of checks, and a notebook with Arlene’s writing on the first pages. Later entries were shakier. The final pages were blank.

Howard laid everything out.

Curtis had been helping pay her bills. He’d used that access to move money to himself.

Some transfers sat beside genuine expenses. Electricity. Insurance. Then money sent to Curtis, with no bill attached.

Arlene had underlined those.

One entry in her notebook read, Asked him again. Said he’d replace it Friday.

There were several Fridays.

Howard placed a recent statement in front of me. A travel charge appeared beside a transfer into Curtis’s account. In the envelope with it was a printed booking confirmation for Cabo.

Two adults.

I pressed my finger against the second fare.

There were earlier trips too. Statements paired with travel receipts, little packets Arlene had assembled while her son kept promising to settle up.

“She was collecting proof,” I said.

“Yes.”

“Why didn’t she tell me?”

Howard didn’t give me a speech about mothers.

“She asked me to demand repayment. Then she asked me to wait. More than once.”

I could picture her hand going to that chain when Curtis entered the room.

I pulled the notebook closer.

“Don’t wait anymore.”

Howard looked at me before making a note.

“That will mean pursuing your husband.”

“Yes.”

My phone rang against the bank’s desk.

Curtis, finally.

He’d texted overnight that he was finding a flight. Now he wanted to know whether I’d picked clothes for his mother.

Then, without a pause, he asked if I’d found her bank papers.

I looked at the open box.

“Howard and I have them.”

“What are you doing with Howard?”

“Finishing something your mother asked me to do.”

“Denise, don’t sign anything. You’re upset.”

He’d ignored twenty-seven calls while I was upset. Apparently I became fragile only when I got near a pen.

“I’m coming home tonight,” he said. “We need to handle this as a family.”

I turned Arlene’s notebook to the next page.

“You should have come yesterday.”

The chair beside the recliner

Curtis arrived at Arlene’s house Wednesday evening while Howard and I were going through copies of the statements.

Rosanne was there too. At fifty-six, she’d spent enough years in other people’s hardest rooms to enter without making anybody feel inspected. She’d returned to check on me and coordinate the remaining hospice equipment collection.

The bed was still beneath the window.

Curtis stopped just inside the front door. His roller bag bumped the threshold behind him.

He looked sunburned.

I hated that most at first. His mother’s skin had become almost transparent, and he’d come home pink from a swimming pool.

He put his bag down.

“Where is she?”

I told him the funeral home had taken her Tuesday afternoon.

He nodded, then opened his arms toward me.

I stepped behind the recliner.

“Denise.”

Howard closed his folder without putting it away.

Curtis looked from him to Rosanne.

“Can my wife and I have a minute?”

“No,” I said.

He rubbed his face.

“I’ve been traveling all day. I haven’t slept. I came straight here.”

Rosanne folded the blanket she’d been holding.

“Your mother died with Denise beside her,” she said. “She wasn’t alone.”

“I know that.”

“No,” he said a moment later, looking at me. “I didn’t know it would be that fast.”

I pulled out the folding chair I’d set beside the bed for him.

“Sit down.”

He didn’t.

“What did that woman tell you?”

“Enough.”

“She had no business answering my phone. I’d left it beside the towels. I didn’t know you were calling that much.”

“The screen would have told you.”

“I was going to call.”

Howard opened the folder again.

Curtis’s eyes went straight to it.

“Look, whatever Mom said, she got confused. You both know that. She’d get worked up over things and then forget we’d talked.”

Rosanne stopped folding.

“Her difficulty speaking did not mean she couldn’t understand.”

“I’m not saying it did.”

“You just did,” I said.

Curtis pulled the chair away from the bed and sat. He kept his coat on.

Howard set a copy of the trust in his hands.

“Your mother signed this nine years ago. The house is held in it. Denise is the beneficiary.”

Curtis read the first page, then skipped ahead.

“No. There’s got to be something else.”

Howard waited.

“I’m her son.”

“Yes.”

“This is the house I grew up in.”

“Yes.”

Curtis looked at me.

“You knew about this?”

“Since yesterday.”

“Then fix it. Tell him you don’t want it. We can work out what’s fair without dragging everybody into our business.”

I nearly apologized.

The words rose with that old awful ease. Sorry for upsetting you. Sorry your mother made her own choices. Sorry the room contains witnesses.

I gripped the recliner until they passed.

Howard put the repayment records on top of the trust.

“The transfers and personal purchases we’ve documented total $48,612.37. That’s the amount the estate will seek to recover, subject to the full accounting.”

Curtis pushed the papers away.

“She let me use that account.”

“To pay her expenses,” Howard said.

“She helped us. That’s what parents do.”

I moved the Cabo confirmation toward him.

“Did she come with you?”

He glanced at Rosanne.

“Can she please leave? This has nothing to do with hospice.”

Rosanne picked up her bag, but stayed beside the door.

“I’ll go when Denise wants me to.”

I shook my head.

Curtis leaned forward, elbows on his knees.

“Some of that was loans. Some was gifts. Mom never kept any of it straight.”

Howard opened the notebook to a page and turned it around.

Curtis went quiet.

His own note was tucked there, attached to one of the statements. He’d written that he’d repay the money he used for travel.

Howard put a finger beside the signature.

“You can have your own attorney review everything.”

“I don’t need an attorney to talk to my wife.”

“You need one to argue with your mother’s records,” I said.

He stood so abruptly the chair scraped the floor.

“She was going to leave it to me anyway.”

The room went still.

Curtis looked toward the bed. Then back at us.

“I mean, that was what I understood. I wasn’t taking it from strangers. I was going to sort it out when the house sold.”

There it was. He’d planned to repay his mother with the money he expected to inherit from her.

Arlene’s house had paid for his future in his head long before she stopped breathing.

“You won’t be selling this house,” I said.

His mouth opened, then shut.

He tried Howard again.

“What if Denise and I agree to deduct it from whatever she receives? There doesn’t have to be a fight.”

“No,” I said.

“You’re my wife.”

“I’m filing for divorce.”

He sat down hard.

For the first time since he walked in, he looked directly at me without looking past me for something he could use.

“After nineteen years?”

I could barely get the next words out.

“I called you twenty-seven times.”

He bent over, hands pressed against his eyes.

Nobody moved toward him.

Then he reached for the notebook, and Howard kept a hand on it.

“Copies,” Howard said. “You can have copies.”

The blue cardigan

Curtis let go of the page.

“Keep the house, then,” he said. “I’m not going to fight you over her house.”

Howard slid the folder back into his bag.

“You don’t have it to give.”

That landed. Curtis looked at the bare place on the wall where the bed had forced us to move a picture, then at his roller bag by the door.

I stood beside Arlene’s recliner with my arms wrapped around myself. I’d wanted him home so badly the day before. Now the sound of him breathing in her room made me want to open every window.

“Can I at least talk to you alone?” he said.

“No.”

“You’ll let him take everything I’ve worked for?”

“The demand is for your mother’s money.”

“I can’t just write a check for that.”

“Then you’ll have to work something out,” Howard said.

Curtis looked at Rosanne again. She’d seen him for eleven minutes while his mother was alive. Now he seemed unable to bear that she might leave with an accurate opinion of him.

“I loved my mother.”

Rosanne said nothing.

He turned to me.

“You know I did.”

I picked up his roller bag and moved it onto the porch. It was heavier than I expected. He came after me, reaching for the handle.

For a second we both held it.

“She asked about me?” he said.

“Until she couldn’t.”

He began crying then. He covered his mouth, shoulders shaking, and I felt the old pull to put my arms around him.

My hands stayed on the bag.

There would be a funeral. There would be papers and arguments and mornings when nineteen years reached for me before I remembered.

But I wasn’t going to comfort him through what he’d done to her.

“Denise, please.”

I released the handle.

“You heard me.”

Then I went back inside.

Howard remained while Curtis drove away. Rosanne helped me fold the chair.

That was when I cried again.

Not over the trip, or the bank statements, or even the divorce. I cried because the chair folded so easily. I’d dragged it out and wiped it down and angled it so Arlene could see her son’s face without turning her head.

Rosanne held one side while I closed the other.

“She squeezed my hand,” I said. “At the end. Hard.”

“I remember.”

“She hadn’t managed her own spoon in three weeks.”

Rosanne put the folded chair against the wall.

“You kept your promise.”

I couldn’t answer. She stayed until I could breathe without counting.

The funeral was Saturday. Curtis attended. I didn’t keep him from his mother’s burial, and I didn’t stand beside him pretending we were all right.

Afterward, he asked whether we could wait to deal with the money until things were less raw.

Howard had sent the records to Curtis’s attorney by then.

“No,” I said.

The accounting took weeks. So did the settlement. There was nothing magical about a key. It opened a box, and then people had to do the work.

I did mine.

I answered questions. I kept copies. I paid for my own divorce lawyer and sat through meetings when I would rather have crawled under Arlene’s quilt.

Curtis sold his boat. He sold the pickup and bought an older car. The rest came from his savings.

The repayment check was for $48,612.37.

Howard put a copy in front of me when the funds cleared.

I ran my finger down the amount.

Every one of Arlene’s underlined entries was accounted for. Curtis received no share of her house or the savings she left. The money he returned went back where it belonged before the final distribution.

He’d wanted me to forgive the debt as part of separating.

I refused.

Months later, when the divorce was final, I walked through Arlene’s front door carrying the last box of my things.

The house was mine. So were the savings remaining after her bills and expenses. I could pay for repairs without asking Curtis whether they were necessary. I could sleep without wondering whose holiday I was helping finance.

I left the recliner by the window.

The rented bed was gone, but I couldn’t move that chair. Arlene had spent years there correcting the television weather forecast as if the meteorologist could hear her.

On my first evening living there, I took her sewing basket down from the shelf.

The old cat-food coupon was still inside. So was the tomato pincushion, bristling with needles. I found blue thread, held it up against the cardigan, and decided close enough would have to do.

Arlene would’ve had opinions. I gave her a minute to express them.

Then I sewed the button on.

Afterward, I threaded the brass key back onto its chain and fastened it around my neck. The box had been emptied and closed. I kept the key anyway.

I put on the cardigan and settled into the recliner with the western we’d never finished.

My thumb found our place.

“All right, Arlene,” I said. “Let’s get this fool off his horse.”

I turned the page.

For more family secrets and hard-won reckonings, read “My Stepson Planned My Move While I Carried His Deed” and “My Husband Packed His Duffel Three Days Before Our Twins’ Birthday”. And for a different kind of family betrayal, there’s “My Sister Laughed While Her Fiancé Made Me His Punchline”.