My Girlfriend’s Son Babysat My Daughter Every Other Saturday Night

Daniel Foster

The flashlight was the size of a lipstick, purple, and it hung off my daughter’s backpack zipper on a little plastic clip. In September I warned her to keep the beam off the neighbor’s dog. That was the whole conversation I had about it.

I’d walked out on Teri, my wife of eleven years, fourteen months before. By January I had moved in with Stacey, into her place in Fort Wayne. Her son Hunter, 23, had the basement. I paid Teri $1,150 every month without missing one and figured that settled what kind of father I was.

Isabella is eight. We had her on alternating weekends, from the end of the school day Friday until 5 on Sunday. On the Saturday nights, Stacey and I went to dinner from about 8 to 11, and Hunter, who was home anyway, “watched” her. In February Stacey put me on the app for the camera mounted above the stairs down to the basement so the house would feel like mine. I never tapped it.

In August the Friday crying started. Only our Fridays. Teri called with Isabella wailing behind her, and I told her, “Kids adjust.” That night Stacey kept slicing limes while I repeated it.

“She’s being coached, Karim. You make her come anyway.”

I did.

Then on Friday, November 13, at 2:50, I was signing a pallet count when Mrs. Hwang, her third-grade teacher, called.

“Mr. Pan, she wants to know if Hunter is going to be home tonight.”

Isabella had locked herself in the classroom bathroom. Twelve minutes later I was on the floor beside a door with a paper turkey on it, and my daughter was asking through it about the basement man, about the dark, about how long she’d knocked while I was out. The flashlight blinked under the door. Mrs. Hwang showed me three worry notes from October. Saturday, all three. The last one, torn by the pencil, was about a dark room. Hunter had told her that if she talked, I’d leave her like I left her mother.

In my truck I opened the app. Last Saturday, 8:02 to 10:47, was gone.

Clips removed Sunday, 7:15 a.m. From Stacey’s phone.

Recently Deleted

My first thought, and I promised myself I’d tell this straight, was that she’d hit something by accident. My kid was on a bathroom floor and I was in a parking lot shopping for excuses for the woman I lived with. That’s who I’d gotten to be in fourteen months.

There was a menu in the corner. Inside the menu there was a folder.

Recently Deleted. Kept 30 days.

Eleven clips from November 7. More from October 24, and from October 10. I didn’t count those. I couldn’t.

I tapped 8:02.

The camera sits up high, so you get the top step, the long drop of the stairs, and at the bottom, two doors. One is Hunter’s. The other is the little one under the stairs where Stacey keeps the Christmas tubs. It has a slide bolt on the outside. I put that bolt on in March because the door kept swinging open, and I remember feeling handy.

Hunter comes down with Isabella by the wrist. She has her purple flashlight in her other hand.

The camera has sound. Nobody told me that either.

“In you go. The guys are on at eight.”

“Can I have the big light?”

“There’s no light in there. It’s like camping.”

“I don’t want to.”

He crouches and his voice goes nice, which was worse than if he’d yelled.

“Your dad left your mom ’cause she was a pain. You be a pain, he leaves you too. Okay?”

She goes in. The door shuts. The bolt slides. My bolt.

Then through his own door you hear his headset game, him yelling at somebody named Beckett to cover left. And under that, every couple of minutes, a little knock. Wait. Knock.

At 9:30 a thin line of purple light shows under the storage door. It goes on. Off. On. She’d asked her mother three times for that flashlight. She’d been bringing her own light to my house because I wouldn’t.

At 10:41 he pulls the bolt. “Go brush your teeth. They’re almost home. You were good.”

She comes out with her hand over her eyes.

I threw up next to my front tire. A crossing guard walking first graders to the buses looked at me and kept walking, and I’d have done the same.

Teri’s Corolla pulled in at 3:20. She got out in her clinic scrubs with her keys in her fist like she was going to need them on me. Fourteen months had taught her to come out swinging.

“Is she okay?”

“She’s inside with Mrs. Hwang.” I held out the phone. “Watch this. Then say whatever you want.”

She watched it against her chest so the sound wouldn’t carry across the lot. When the bolt slid she put her free hand flat on my hood. When it ended she gave me the phone back and slapped me, open hand, not hard. She looked more surprised than I did.

“I told you.”

“You did.”

“August. I called you four times in September. She quit eating on Thursdays at my house, Karim. Thursdays. Because Friday was next.”

There was nothing I could say that deserved air, so I didn’t.

Inside, Teri knelt by the turkey door. “Bella. It’s Mommy. Hunter won’t be anywhere you are. Not tonight. Not ever.”

She looked up at me on “ever.” I nodded. That promise was hers to make now. I’d spent mine.

The lock clicked. Isabella came out and went straight into her mother and looked at me over Teri’s shoulder, flashlight in her fist.

“Are you going out tonight?”

“No, baby. I’m going to Stacey’s to get my stuff.”

“Is the dark room still there?”

“Not for long.”

Walking to my truck I called the one person I thought might know if I was crazy. Rena. Stacey’s sister. I’d met her twice. At Easter she’d kept her two boys on her side of the yard all afternoon and wouldn’t let them near the basement, and I’d decided she was a snob.

She picked up on the second ring. “Karim? Is Stacey okay?”

“Rena. Why won’t you let Hunter babysit your boys?”

A long quiet. Then: “Where are you?”

“Going to her house.”

“Don’t go in without me.”

The Limes

Stacey’s place is a split-level on Calhoun with a basketball hoop nobody uses. I parked behind her Highlander at 4:05. Rena’s Buick came around the corner two minutes later, and she got out still wearing her bank name badge.

She stood on the sidewalk and didn’t let me past.

“I’m telling you before we go in, because she won’t. Three years ago Hunter watched my boys on a Saturday. Jaden was six. After that he wouldn’t stay in any room with the door shut. A month later it came out. Hunter shut them in the laundry room all night so he could play his games. Told them their daddy would get sent away if they said a word.”

“And Stacey knew.”

“I told her that week. I said he’d never be alone with a child of mine again. She said I was overreacting and didn’t speak to me till Thanksgiving.” Rena looked at the house. “When you moved in with a little girl, I called her. I said, don’t you leave that child with him. She said, ‘Karim’s girl is fine. She’s tough.'”

Tough. Eight years old and bringing her own flashlight.

I wanted to put my fist through the Highlander window. I opened the front door instead.

Stacey was at the kitchen counter. Of course she was. A cutting board, a bowl of limes, the good knife. She smiled when she saw me, and then she saw Rena behind me and the smile went somewhere else.

“You’re early. Where’s Isabella?”

“With her mother.”

“It’s your weekend.”

I went to the basement door and opened it. The little white camera was right over my head. I looked at it a second. Then I yelled down the stairs.

“Hunter. Kitchen. Now.”

He came up in a hoodie and slides with his headset around his neck, like somebody had called him to supper. “What’s the deal, man?”

He saw Rena in the doorway, arms crossed, and his shoulders changed.

I set my phone on the cutting board next to the limes and turned the volume all the way up and pressed play.

Your dad left your mom ’cause she was a pain.

Stacey reached for the phone. I put my hand on it.

“No. You’ve seen it. You saw it Sunday at 7:15 with your coffee. Now you can hear it in your kitchen.”

The bolt slid in the clip. The knocking started. Little and patient. And over it, Hunter’s real voice yelling at Beckett.

Hunter talked first. The guilty ones always do.

“Okay, that makes it sound way worse than it is. It’s a storage room. There’s nothing in there that hurts. She was so annoying, she kept touching my controller, and Mom said—”

“Hunter,” Stacey said.

“No, you said! You said keep her out of the way till you got back. Like a hundred times.” He turned to me. “She knew, man. She watched them. She told me quit saying the thing about you leaving because it’d ‘get back.’ That was her only problem with it.”

Stacey stood up. The stool scraped the tile.

“You want to do this in front of my sister? Fine.” Her voice went high and loud. “Yes. I deleted them. I watched it Sunday morning and I knew if you ever saw it you’d walk out that door. You walked out on your wife. I’m not stupid, Karim, I know what you do when it gets hard. So yes. I deleted it.”

“You told me she was being coached.”

“She was being dramatic! Kids are dramatic! Two hours in a closet, people did a lot worse to me—”

“It’s been every one of her Saturdays since August, Stace,” Rena said. “And before that it was my boys in a laundry room.”

“Get out of my house.”

“I’m in the doorway.”

I’d rehearsed lines all twelve minutes of the drive. What I did instead was walk down the stairs and slide back my bolt and look.

Four feet wide. The Christmas tubs. A box fan. No bulb in the socket; somebody had unscrewed it. On the floor against the wall was a gum wrapper folded small, then smaller, into a hard little square. The way Isabella folds them. The way she folds her worry notes.

I put it in my shirt pocket and went back up.

Hunter was crying. Twenty-three, over six feet, crying with his hands in his hoodie pocket like a little boy.

“I’m sorry, okay? Can we not make it a thing?”

“It’s a thing. I called the police from the school lot. They’ll be on Calhoun in ten minutes. I’m giving them every clip in that folder.” I looked at Rena. “And she’s giving them Jaden.”

Rena nodded once.

Stacey made a noise I’d never heard out of her. The sound of a woman who just watched the room leave her.

“You’d do that to my son?”

“He did it to my daughter.”

“I took you in. When you had nothing. When you were sleeping in your truck in the Menards lot—”

“I wasn’t sleeping in my truck. I was sleeping on your couch. And I’m done with it.”

Upstairs I got my green duffel out of the closet and packed it in four minutes. I’ve done it before, God help me. Work clothes. My dad’s Colts blanket. The drawing Isabella made me in first grade, which Stacey had moved to the hall closet in February “so it wouldn’t fade.”

When I came down there was a cruiser at the curb and two officers in the kitchen. The one with the notepad, Officer Yeager, had the face of a man who’s stood in a lot of kitchens.

Stacey was explaining. She said “misunderstanding” twice before I put my phone in front of Yeager and said, “Recently Deleted. November 7. 8:02.”

He watched it with the phone by his ear all the way through. Then he looked at Hunter.

“Son, you want to come sit in the living room with me?”

Stacey’s hand came down on the cutting board, right on a lime. Juice ran off the edge onto her socks.

At the front door I stopped, because I owed her one sentence and I’d only get the one.

“You were right,” I said. “I walk out. Watch me.”

The Hall Light

The rest came fast, and I’ll give it to you the way it came.

Friday night I slept at a Red Roof Inn off Coliseum. Room 114. $71.40 a night. I sat on the end of the bed and never turned the TV on.

Saturday at noon Yeager called. They’d pulled every clip off the company’s server, October and November both, plus the deletion log with Stacey’s phone on it. Hunter was charged with criminal confinement of a child. Rena’s statement about Jaden went in the file that afternoon. Hunter was out of his mother’s basement by Sunday, sleeping on a friend’s floor, his headset in a trash bag.

Monday morning I signed Teri’s emergency motion on the hood of her Corolla in the clinic lot. Her lawyer, a tired man named Douglas, said he’d never had a father sign one against himself. Judge Stein stopped every overnight at Stacey’s address and gave me supervised days until I had a place of my own. I didn’t fight a word of it.

Stacey called nineteen times in three days. The twentieth was a voicemail. The camera was down, Rena wasn’t speaking to her, her son was gone, and she hoped I was happy.

I didn’t call back. Somebody had asked me if I was going to leave. It wasn’t her.

By the next Friday, November 20, I had a one-bedroom on the second floor of a brick building on Spring Street. $1,240 a month and a crack in the tub shaped like Ohio. I bought a mattress, a lamp, and a nightlight shaped like a moon. I put the moon in the hall.

Teri let me pick Isabella up from school that afternoon. Supervised, she said, meaning her, sitting in the Corolla. I’d have said yes to anything.

Mrs. Hwang walked Isabella out at 3:05, holding her hand. The flashlight was still on the zipper.

“He’s not taking you to that house,” Mrs. Hwang told her. Then to me: “Right, Mr. Pan?”

“Right.”

“She put one in the jar this morning. She said it’s yours.”

It was folded small as gum. I opened it on the curb.

IS DAD SCARED ON SATURDAY NOW

I laughed and it came out half wrong. Mrs. Hwang took a sudden interest in the buses.

Isabella didn’t run to me. She stood on the curb and looked me over with her mother’s eyes, like I was a used car. I’d paid for that look every other Friday since August.

So I crouched down and took the wrapper out of my shirt pocket. The hard little square.

“I found this at Stacey’s. It’s the only thing I went back for.”

She looked at it a long time, then took it.

“You went in there?”

“I went in there.”

“It’s dark.”

“Real dark. I hated it.”

“You’re big.”

“Hated it anyway.”

Teri got out and leaned on her door and didn’t say a thing.

At my apartment Isabella walked through it like a building inspector. Closets. Under the bed. She opened the bathroom door, shut it, opened it again.

“Is there a basement?”

“No basement. Second floor.”

“Who’s downstairs?”

“Mrs. Mendoza. She has a cat named Pickles who hates me.”

Half a smile. Half beat the zero I’d been living on since August.

Supper was boxed mac and cheese, because I’m a man in a new apartment. Teri stood at the door with her keys at a quarter to nine.

“Nine o’clock she sleeps at my house. That’s the deal.”

“That’s the deal.”

“You did right, Karim. In the end.”

“Three months late.”

“Fourteen months late,” she said, and went down to warm up the car.

I had one thing planned. I’d planned it all week like a fool planning a proposal.

“Bella. Come here.”

I walked her to the hall and showed her the moon. Plugged in, on all night. I’d tried three at Walmart to find the brightest.

She stood under it with the purple flashlight in her fist.

“Do you leave it on even when I’m not here?”

“Every night.”

“Why? You’re big.”

I thought about the knocking. How patient it was.

“So I can see you coming.”

She unclipped the flashlight from her zipper. She clicked it once, on, and pointed it at the moon. Then she clicked it off and held it out to me.

“You keep it,” she said. “For your Saturdays.”

If this one stayed with you, send it to somebody who’s still being told the kid will adjust.

Family tensions can leave everyone scrambling, whether it’s a parent facing an unexpected money crisis in “I Sold My Guitar for $140 After My Wife Emptied Our Coffee Can” or a family trying to show up for a child in “My Oldest Son Hung Up on His Brother While My Granddaughter Listened”. For another story about a parent navigating a difficult moment with their child, read “The Assistant Principal Wanted My Signature on My Son’s Suspension by 3:15”.