The lilies on Quinn’s casket were the wrong kind. I’d asked for white tulips because he hated how lilies smelled, and his mother had overruled me by phone, so the whole front of St. Agnes church in Lake Forest smelled like a hotel lobby.
That’s what I was thinking about when Roberta came up the aisle.
Six days since his car went off the overpass on the Edens. Me at 33 weeks with his son, one palm resting on my stomach and the other around the gold locket with our first ultrasound tucked inside. Roberta in black heels and a manila envelope. A hundred and forty people behind her: partners from his firm, relatives, a client from Denver, the alderman seated in row three.
She held up the pages and said the baby wasn’t his. She said I’d never been his wife, so the house, the cars, the firm and the eleven million went back to his family. She said the accounts were frozen. Then she laid the envelope on the casket, on the lilies, over his chest.
“Get out of my son’s house tonight, incubator.”
Destiny, his twin, came around her and grabbed my left hand. She twisted his grandmother’s sapphire until it came over the knuckle with skin on it.
“I shared a womb with him,” she said. “You just borrowed his bed.”
I bled on my own black dress. The baby kicked like he wanted out to settle it himself.
Quinn had told me once, keys in his hand at the door, to call Imran before anyone. I’d called twice. Voicemail. Roberta lifted two fingers and her hired guards came for my elbow.
Then the doors hit the walls, and Imran Caldwell walked up the aisle with a projector and a screen and said nobody was leaving for the cemetery until this had played to the end.
Roberta smiled. She thought it was a tribute.
And on the screen, Quinn said Destiny was holding my ring.
The chipped mug
“Hold it up, Des,” Quinn said on the screen. “Go on. Everybody’s already looking.”
Destiny didn’t move. Her fist stayed shut against her hip.
I’d never seen her with nothing to say. In three years I’d seen her with a drink in her hand, with a phone in her hand, with my name in her mouth and that little laugh after it. Never this.
On the screen Quinn picked up the chipped mug, looked into it, and put it down without drinking. He did that when he was stalling. He did it the night he proposed, too, standing at the counter for so long I thought he was going to tell me he’d wrecked the car.
“I’m recording this in October,” he said. “Lizette’s asleep upstairs. She’s twenty-eight weeks and she snores now, which I’m not allowed to mention, so if she’s watching, honey, I didn’t mention it.”
A man in the second pew laughed and then looked horrified at himself.
I laughed too. It came out of me like a hiccup. Roberta turned her head and looked at me like I’d spat on the floor.
“Mom,” Quinn said. “I know you. You’re going to bring a paper. You told me in March you’d never let her near the firm without proof, and I said fine, and you said you’d get it yourself if I didn’t.”
Roberta’s mouth opened. Nothing came out.
“So I got it,” Quinn said. “At ten weeks. Before the high-risk stuff, before anything. A prenatal test, the blood one, at Northwestern. Me and Lizette in the same room. Imran has the original. Ninety-nine point nine. He’s mine, Mom. He’s been mine the whole time.”
The sound the church made then was different from the first one. The first one was breathing in. This one was a hundred and forty people deciding who they’d been wrong about.
I remembered that day. The needle, the little Band-Aid with the cartoon bee, and Quinn telling the nurse it was for insurance purposes, because he sold insurance and that was his joke for everything. I thought it was a routine screening. He bought me a hot chocolate after and let me pick the radio station the whole way home, which he never did.
He’d done it for her. And then he’d kept it in a drawer so I’d never know she asked.
“I didn’t tell you, Liz,” he said on the screen, like he’d heard me. “Because you’d have been hurt, and you weren’t allowed to be hurt. Doctor’s orders.”
Imran stepped to the casket. He picked Roberta’s envelope off the lilies with two fingers, the way you’d pick up something the dog brought in, and set it on the front pew beside her.
“There’s more,” Quinn said. “The house isn’t mine anymore. I signed it over in August. The house, my shares in the firm, the accounts, all of it. It’s in a trust for Lizette and the baby. Imran runs it. Nobody froze anything, Mom, because there’s nothing in my name to freeze.”
Roberta sat down. Not on purpose. Her knees just quit and the pew caught her.
“And the ring,” Quinn said. “Grandma Eva left it to me, not to the family. It’s in my will, in writing, page four. It goes to Lizette. It doesn’t come back to anybody.”
He leaned toward the camera.
“Des. I know about the three hundred and forty thousand.”
Destiny’s face went the color of the lilies.
Page four
The video paused. Imran had a little remote, and he’d stopped it on Quinn mid-blink, which was unfair, because Quinn hated pictures of himself mid-blink.
“Before we go on,” Imran said, “Mr. Schaefer asked me to stop here and give Ms. Schaefer the chance to return the ring.”
He meant Destiny. He held out his hand, palm up.
Destiny looked at it. Then at her mother. Roberta was sitting on the front pew with her own envelope beside her like a casserole nobody would touch.
“Mom,” Destiny said.
“It’s a recording,” Roberta said. Her voice had come back. It had come back louder. “He was grieving his father, he was under stress, he was being manipulated by a woman who changes bedpans for a living.”
“I was a preschool aide,” I said.
“Same thing.”
A woman in the fourth row, a partner’s wife who’d once told me my lasagna was “brave”, said, “Roberta, sit down.”
Roberta did not sit down. She stood up, which was worse.
“That girl’s paper and my paper,” she said, turning to the pews again, the way she’d turned when she first came in. “That’s all this is. Two papers. And I’m his mother. You know me. You’ve known me thirty years.”
She held up her report again. Northbrook, the letterhead said. Some lab I’d never heard of.
I’d never read it. I hadn’t been allowed to. It had been on his chest, and then it had been in her hand, and then it had been in Imran’s two fingers.
“Can I see that?” I said.
She laughed. “So you can tear it up?”
“So I can read it. You read it out loud to the alderman.”
The alderman, to his credit, looked at his shoes.
Imran took it from her before she decided anything and gave it to me. My knuckle was still bleeding. I got a thumbprint on the corner of it, rust brown.
It had my name spelled right. It had Quinn’s. It said the mother’s sample was collected at the Northbrook clinic on Thursday, at 2:40 in the afternoon.
I read it twice. Then I looked up at her.
“Thursday at 2:40,” I said, “I was at Dempsey’s Funeral Home picking his casket.”
Roberta blinked.
“With you,” I said. “You told me oak was tacky. You said mahogany or you’d pay for it yourself. You had your hand on my arm so I wouldn’t fall over. You were holding my arm at 2:40, Roberta. The funeral director wrote the time on the receipt because you made him.”
“That’s—” she said.
“I can’t be in two places. I’m barely in one. Look at me.”
The funeral director from Dempsey’s was there. Of course he was, he was driving the hearse. He was standing at the side door in his gray gloves, and every head turned to him like he was a referee.
He said, “Two-forty. Mrs. Schaefer asked me to put it on the slip.”
Roberta’s hand went to her hairspray, like her hair was the thing that had come loose.
On the screen, Quinn sat frozen mid-blink in his gray sweater.
Imran pressed the remote.
“Des,” Quinn said. “I know about the three hundred and forty thousand. I found it in April. You moved it out of the firm in pieces, with invoices from a consulting company that’s a P.O. box in Skokie.”
Destiny turned around and walked toward the side aisle.
The guard her mother had hired stepped in front of her.
Bennett and Bennett
The guards were named Kareem and Filip. I know because Roberta had paid them, and Roberta said their names like she was paging them at an airport.
“Kareem. Move.”
Kareem didn’t move. He looked at Imran.
Here’s a thing about hired men: they figure out who’s paying them about two seconds after everybody else does. Roberta had paid them with money she’d thought was coming. Everybody in that church had just heard there wasn’t any coming.
“Ma’am,” Kareem said to Destiny, “I think he wants you to hear the rest.”
So she heard the rest. We all did.
“I covered it, Des,” Quinn said. “I put back every dollar out of my own pocket so the partners wouldn’t find out, and I didn’t tell Mom, because I wanted to be the brother you thought I wasn’t. I hoped you’d stop. You didn’t stop. You came at Lizette at her shower and asked her how much she’d charge to go away. Right in front of her friends. She told me it was a joke so I wouldn’t get upset.”
He looked tired then. I’d forgotten how tired he’d looked in October.
“So here’s the deal,” Quinn said. “The paperwork’s in Imran’s safe. If you give the ring back and you leave Lizette alone, the paperwork stays in the safe. If you fight the will, or you go near the house, Imran hands it to the partners. They’re in the second row, Des. Wave.”
Two men in the second row did not wave. One of them, Gordon, who’d been at our engagement party and danced with me badly to Earth, Wind and Fire, had both hands flat on his knees like he was holding the pew down.
“Is that true?” Gordon said. Not to the screen. To Destiny.
“He’s dead,” Destiny said. “He doesn’t get to talk.”
“He’s talking,” Gordon said.
Destiny’s mouth worked. Then she turned on me, because I was the nearest thing that couldn’t fire her.
“You did this. You got in his head. Thirty-eight years I was his sister and you got three and you got everything.”
“I got a Band-Aid with a bee on it,” I said. “And a locket.”
I hadn’t planned that. It just came out.
Destiny held out her hand. Not to me. To Imran. She opened her fist and the sapphire was sitting in her palm with my blood dried brown in the setting.
Imran didn’t take it.
“Mr. Schaefer was specific,” he said. “To her.”
So Destiny Schaefer, who’d shared a womb with the only man I ever loved, walked the three steps to me with a hundred and forty people watching, and put her late brother’s grandmother’s ring in my hand, and I could see her hating every inch of those three steps.
I closed my fingers over it.
On the screen Quinn said, “Thank you, Des. I mean that.”
That broke her. She folded at the middle like a lawn chair and sat on the stone floor of St. Agnes, crying with her mouth open, her mascara going. Nobody went to her. Not her mother.
Roberta was looking at the screen.
“Mom,” Quinn said. “Last thing. Lizette’s going to let you see him. I know she will, because she’s better than both of us. You don’t get to make her. You ask. Nicely. And if you can’t do nicely, you don’t see him. That’s in the trust too. Imran knows.”
He picked up the mug again, looked in it, put it down.
“I love you. I’m sorry I’m making you do this in public. You started it in public, I’m guessing.”
He grinned at the camera. That stupid grin.
“Liz. Tell him about deep dish.”
The screen went blue.
Two fingers
Nobody said anything for a long time.
Then the priest closed his book. He’d been holding it open the whole while, with his thumb in it, like he might need the place.
“Mrs. Schaefer,” Imran said. “The report you brought is going to the state’s attorney this afternoon along with the funeral home’s receipt. The Northbrook lab can tell them who paid for it.”
“I’m his mother,” Roberta said.
She said it the way you’d show a badge.
“Then you’ll want to walk behind the hearse,” Imran said. “Not in front of it.”
The partners started standing. Gordon first. He went down the side aisle and out without looking at Destiny on the floor, and the other one followed him, and that was the firm. Her name had been on the letterhead as a consultant for six years. I found out later the board met that Thursday. She was off it by Friday, and the P.O. box in Skokie stayed in Imran’s safe only because she never went near me again. Quinn’s deal held. Quinn’s deals always held.
The client from Denver left. Then the cousins.
Roberta looked around at the pews emptying, the people she’d turned to twice, and found the alderman, the last one she knew by name.
“Bill,” she said.
He put on his coat.
Roberta picked up her envelope off the pew. She didn’t know what else to pick up. She held it against her chest like she’d hold a purse in a bad neighborhood.
Then she lifted two fingers toward the back of the church.
Kareem and Filip came. Kareem took Destiny under the arm and stood her up off the floor. Filip offered Roberta his elbow.
She didn’t want it. She took it anyway, because her heels were too high for the stone and her knees were done.
That’s how they went out. The two of them, walked up the center aisle of St. Agnes by the men she’d hired to walk me out, past the lilies, past the hearse idling at the curb, in the order I was supposed to go.
At the doors, Roberta stopped and turned around.
I thought she was going to say something. One last word, the little aide from Waukegan, anything.
She looked at my stomach.
Then she went out.
Deep dish
We buried him at 3:15. Imran’s hour ran over, and then some, because I made the priest read the part he’d skipped, the part about the many rooms.
It was me, Imran, his two assistants, Kareem, who stayed without being paid, the funeral director in his gray gloves, and a woman from the fourth row named Carmela, who held my arm on the wet grass the way Roberta had held it on Thursday, except she meant it.
I put the tulips on the casket myself. White. Carmela had sent her husband to a grocery store in Highwood for them. The lilies went in the trash can by the gate.
That night I went home. My home. Imran drove me and walked me to the front door like a prom date and handed me a folder with page four on top.
“He came to see me eleven times about this,” Imran said. “I told him it was overkill.”
“He sold insurance,” I said.
“That’s what he said.”
He left. The house was quiet, the kind of quiet a house gets when one shoe is missing from the mat.
I washed the blood out of the setting with dish soap and an old toothbrush, at the kitchen sink, in the kitchen where he’d gone down on one knee because restaurants were for people who weren’t sure. It took a while. My knuckle was swollen and the ring wouldn’t go back on, so I opened the locket and threaded it onto the chain beside the ultrasound, and the two of them clicked together when I moved.
Then I went into the den.
His chair. His desk. The chipped mug, which I finally understood was not stupid at all. I sat down in the gray sweater, which I’d taken off the back of the chair, and it smelled like him and a little like coffee.
The baby was awake. He’s always awake at night, like his father.
I pulled up the sweater and put my mouth near my belly button, which looks like a phone line if you’ve loved a man long enough.
“Hey,” I said. “It’s your mom. Your dad wanted me to tell you something.”
He kicked once. Like a hello.
“Giordano’s,” I said. “That’s real deep dish. Everything else is lying.”
If this one got to you, send it to somebody who’s ever had to stand still in a room full of people and wait for the truth to walk in.
For more family drama and hard-won boundaries, read about a daughter’s graduation seat card torn up by her ex’s girlfriend and a mother who let a twin’s wife move into someone else’s home. And when family conflict ends up in court, there’s the brother-in-law who swore his pregnant sister-in-law was drowning in debt.