My Daughter-In-Law Made Me Leave Gordon’s Watch on the Dresser

Lucy Evans

The dish towel caught on my wedding ring. I pulled it free, careful with the towel, as though that was the thing in danger of coming apart.

It was Saturday night in November, six days after Gordon died at sixty-nine in his recliner with the Browns game playing. About 140 people attended his funeral. Most came afterward to our four-bedroom colonial in Upper Arlington.

By 8:30, the visitors were gone. At about nine, I was washing eighty-one-year-old Mrs. Kubiak’s dish when Tricia came into the kitchen.

“Pack what you need. You’re not sleeping here tonight.”

Kevin, her husband and my stepson, studied the floor. Brent and his wife, Holly, occupied the doorway. Five people, and apparently I was the only one without a vote.

I’d married Gordon in 1995, the year after his first wife died. Kevin was ten; Brent was seven. Thirty-one years later, Tricia told me Gordon’s blood mattered more than his second wife.

I surrendered the brass key Gordon chipped in 2009.

Upstairs, she supervised my suitcase and garment bag. I packed my mother’s rosary, reading glasses, and our Put-in-Bay photograph. She stopped me reaching for his Seiko.

“The watch stays. That was HIS.”

At 4:50 Sunday morning, after sitting awake in my coat, I left. Both sons’ cars remained outside.

At about 5:50, I paid $79 cash at a chain motel off Route 33, registering as Petrak, my maiden name.

At 8:05, Gordon’s attorney, Phil Navarro, answered before the second ring.

“Mrs. Haskins. I wondered when you’d call.”

I requested the whole will, with all four present.

They knew nothing about the $26 million already titled to me. Or the deed Gordon signed in April, seven months earlier.

My name alone owned that house.

Monday would be their first opportunity to read it.

The April Deed

Phil asked where I was.

When I told him, he stopped shuffling whatever papers were near his phone.

“Darlene, you can go home now.”

“I know.”

“Do you want me to meet you there?”

I rubbed the motel blanket between my fingers. It had the texture of something intended to survive a small industrial accident.

“Tomorrow. I want you there tomorrow.”

He agreed to meet us at the house at ten Monday morning. Before hanging up, I asked him to tell them not to remove anything.

Then I paid for another night. Another $79, this time by card. I was sixty-three, a retired school bookkeeper, and perfectly capable of understanding that a woman with money could afford somewhere nicer.

I wanted somewhere nobody would expect me to answer the door.

On Monday, I arrived behind Phil. Kevin opened the front door before either of us knocked.

“Darlene. Where have you been?”

He put his arms forward, then let them fall when I stayed beside Phil.

“Somewhere with a vacancy.”

Inside, Tricia sat on the sofa. Brent and Holly shared the chairs near the fireplace. The folding chairs from the reception were still open in the den.

Nobody had put them away. Apparently the new management didn’t handle furniture.

Phil set his case down. There were six of us in the living room.

Tricia reached for a folder before he opened it.

“We’ve been trying to work out the house first. Obviously the boys need to know what they can do with it.”

Phil kept his hand on the folder.

“Then we’ll start there.”

He laid the April deed in front of her.

“This property belongs to Darlene Haskins.”

Tricia bent toward the page.

“For her lifetime?”

“No. Outright. Since April.”

Kevin came around the sofa. Brent leaned forward with his hands between his knees.

“The house isn’t part of Gordon’s estate,” Phil said. “Neither son inherited it. Neither of you has authority to exclude its owner.”

Tricia’s mouth opened, but Phil turned another page.

“The brokerage and bank accounts Darlene has discussed with me, totaling twenty-six million dollars, are hers as well. They are not funds available for division between you.”

Kevin sat on the arm of the sofa and missed it slightly.

Then Phil opened the will.

Gordon had provided separately for both sons through trusts. I was named trustee of each. Their money was to be managed under Gordon’s written terms, not handed over because somebody had arrived carrying a calculator and an opinion.

I knew about the trusts. I hadn’t known what Gordon had left with the will.

Phil took out a signed letter.

“Gordon asked that this be read to the family.”

Tricia looked at Kevin.

“Is that necessary? We can read our own copies.”

“I’d like to hear it,” I said.

Phil read Gordon’s explanation. At Easter, Gordon had heard Tricia call me “the help.” Kevin had been beside her and let it pass. Gordon wrote that he couldn’t trust his sons to protect my place in the family once he was gone.

He wanted them provided for. He also wanted the person who had managed the household through his illness to manage what he left them.

Phil lowered the letter.

Kevin pressed both hands over his mouth.

I stared at Gordon’s signature. Even at the bottom of that page, he made his G too big.

“That was a joke,” Tricia said. “It was Easter. Everybody was tired. Darlene likes doing things in the kitchen.”

Nobody answered.

“She does. Ask her. She never sits down.”

I wanted to tell her how often I had wanted someone to take the serving spoon out of my hand. Instead, I asked Phil for the letter.

The paper shook when he gave it to me.

Gordon had heard her. All those months, he had known.

I wished he’d told me. I wished we’d had the ugly conversation while there were still two of us to have it.

Tricia turned toward me.

“So you knew all this while you let us worry?”

I folded the letter along its crease.

“What were you worried about?”

“Everything. The property. Expenses. What was going to happen to you.”

“Where did you think I slept Saturday night?”

She picked up the deed again.

“We couldn’t have known you would go to some motel.”

“I didn’t tell you where I went.”

Kevin raised his head.

“She said it yesterday. She said you probably went to a motel to make a point.”

Tricia put the deed down.

“Kevin.”

For the first time since Gordon died, my stepson looked directly at his wife.

“You said she’d come back when she calmed down.”

I held out my hand.

Tricia stared at it.

“My key,” I said.

The Chipped Brass Key

She searched her handbag without taking it off her lap. A tissue came out, then her phone. She moved both onto the sofa beside her, buying seconds with the energy she hadn’t spent finding me somewhere to sleep.

Finally, she placed the key on Phil’s folder.

“Nobody stole anything. You handed it to me.”

“Put it in my hand.”

Her cheeks went red.

“Darlene, don’t do this.”

I kept my palm open.

Kevin stood up.

“Give it to her, Tricia.”

She dropped the key into my hand. The chip rested against my thumb, exactly where it always had.

For one foolish second, that almost undid me. Thirty-one years of reaching for the same key, and here I was needing witnesses to get it back.

Tricia folded her arms.

“Fine. You own the house. We understand. There’s no need to treat us like criminals.”

I put the key on my ring.

“You’ll pack your overnight things and leave today.”

“We’re here because Gordon died.”

“So am I.”

Brent rubbed his forehead. Holly started crying without making a sound.

Tricia pointed toward Phil.

“Can she just do that? We’re family. We’ve been staying here for the funeral.”

“You have your own homes,” Phil said. “You came as guests. Darlene is asking you to leave.”

“Well, nobody is trying to live here.”

“Then packing won’t take long,” I said.

She stood so quickly her phone slid into the cushion.

“This is unbelievable. We lost Gordon too. Kevin lost his father, and now you’re using money to humiliate him in front of his brother.”

Kevin didn’t move.

“Say something,” she said to him.

He looked at me.

“You asked me to stop her.”

I hadn’t said the words in the kitchen. He knew anyway.

“Yes.”

“I thought if I let her finish, she’d settle down. I thought we’d talk in the morning.”

Tricia threw up her hands.

“Don’t make this all mine. You agreed we needed to get things sorted.”

Kevin turned back to her.

“I agreed we’d help.”

“You didn’t object.”

“No,” he said. “I didn’t.”

He pulled a dining chair into the living room and sat facing me. No sofa arm, no wife standing between us.

“I let her put you out.”

His face crumpled. I nearly went to him.

Ten-year-old Kevin had cried with both fists against his eyes after his mother died. Forty-one-year-old Kevin did it differently, but my body didn’t much care about the distinction.

I held the key ring instead.

Brent got up from his chair.

“So did I.”

Holly reached for his sleeve, then let go.

“I could have walked into that kitchen,” Brent said. “I stayed in the doorway.”

“You were in the kitchen enough to hear,” I said.

He nodded.

Tricia looked from one brother to the other.

“Oh, now everybody’s sorry. Now that she’s got the money.”

It was the ugliest thing she said that morning because nobody could neatly deny it.

Kevin flinched.

“I deserve that,” he said.

I didn’t rescue him from it.

Phil closed the folder containing the deed. He left the will open.

“The trusts don’t change because this conversation is difficult. Darlene has duties to both beneficiaries. She can’t use their funds as her own or ignore the terms Gordon set.”

“So she can’t punish us,” Tricia said.

“She must administer the trusts properly.”

I leaned forward.

“I won’t buy an apology from either son. And I won’t pay you to be pleasant to me.”

Tricia picked her phone out of the cushion.

“What are we supposed to do, then?”

“Go home.”

She stared at Kevin, waiting for him to get up beside her.

He stayed seated.

I took the motel receipts from my purse and put them on the folder.

“$158. Two nights.”

Tricia made a sound close to a laugh.

“You have twenty-six million dollars.”

“And you cost me $158.”

Phil said nothing. A good bookkeeper knows when to stop talking and leave the total where people can see it.

Kevin took out his phone.

“I’ll send it now.”

“From yours,” Tricia said.

He looked at her for a long moment.

“Yes. From mine.”

My phone sounded. I checked the transfer before putting it away.

The money didn’t repair Saturday. It did establish that Saturday had happened, right there in front of everyone who preferred calling it something else.

Tricia lifted her handbag.

“I suppose you’ll tell everybody.”

“I’ll answer anybody who asks.”

“After everything we’ve done together, you would damage this family over one bad night?”

Kevin stood then.

“Stop asking her to cover for us.”

Tricia’s eyes filled. She turned toward the hallway, but I spoke before she reached it.

“Gordon’s watch.”

Her shoulders tightened.

“It’s upstairs.”

“Where?”

“On the dresser.”

“Leave it there.”

She went up without answering. Brent and Holly followed to collect their things.

Kevin remained beside the chair.

“Can I bring your bags in?”

I took my car key off the ring and gave it to him.

“Those bags. Nothing else.”

He accepted it with both hands.

The Watch on My Wrist

Phil stayed while Kevin carried my suitcase and garment bag upstairs. I stood at the bottom, listening to the wheels bump each step.

Saturday night, I had struggled with that suitcase while two men I raised slept down the hall. Monday morning, the older one carried it past his own packed bag.

It was a beginning small enough that I could bear to look at it.

Tricia came down holding her handbag against her ribs.

“I’ve packed ours. Kevin can bring them.”

She stopped in front of me.

“I shouldn’t have said what I said about being his second wife.”

I waited.

“I was upset. Everybody was upset. You know how these things get.”

“Which thing?”

She glanced at Phil.

“Darlene.”

“Taking my key? Standing in my bedroom? Telling me I couldn’t touch my husband’s watch?”

Her eyes went toward the stairs.

“All of it,” she said.

There was no pleasant way to receive that answer. I wasn’t going to provide one just because she looked uncomfortable.

“You won’t come back without an invitation.”

She pulled her coat closed.

“I understand.”

Kevin came down with their bags. He set them by the door and gave me my car key.

“I’ll call before I come.”

“You’ll wait for me to answer.”

He nodded.

Brent appeared next, carrying his bag. Holly followed him. She had wiped her face, but her eyes were swollen.

“I’m sorry,” she said. “I kept thinking it wasn’t my place.”

I looked at the doorway where she’d stood Saturday night.

“It was mine.”

She covered her mouth and nodded.

Brent stopped beside me.

“Can I hug you?”

“Not today.”

He put his hand back at his side. That cost me more than asking for the key. I had spent most of my adult life smoothing over the moment before somebody else’s feelings got hurt.

Phil walked with them to the porch while I stayed inside.

Tricia paused at the threshold.

“We really did think you needed help.”

“I needed Kevin to speak.”

She looked at her husband. He didn’t lower his eyes this time.

Then they left.

I shut my front door and turned the lock. The chipped key was still warm from my hand.

Phil waited until their cars pulled away before gathering his papers.

“Do you want company for a while?”

“Yes,” I said, surprising myself. “But I don’t want to talk about the will.”

He took off his coat again.

We folded the reception chairs.

He pinched his finger in the second one and said something Gordon would have approved of. I laughed, one sudden bark of a laugh that hurt my throat.

Then I cried.

Phil stood holding the folded chair while I cried against the sleeve of my own sweater. He didn’t tell me I was strong. He didn’t tell me Gordon would want me happy.

After a while, he handed me a tissue from the box beside the recliner.

I sat down on the arm of Gordon’s chair.

“I was married for thirty-one years,” I said. “I’ve forgotten how to have an ordinary Monday by myself.”

“Start with this one.”

We finished the chairs. Before Phil left, he put the deed and Gordon’s letter in my hands. I carried them upstairs myself.

My suitcase stood beside the bed. The garment bag hung from the closet door. Gordon’s watch lay on the dresser where I’d set it down under Tricia’s supervision.

I picked it up.

The band was too big for me. I fastened it anyway, and it slid toward my hand.

Our Put-in-Bay photograph came out of the suitcase next. Gordon was squinting in the sun. I had one hand pressed against his shirt, keeping my hat from blowing away with the other.

I put the photograph back beside the watch’s empty spot.

Then I unpacked my nightgown and hung my coat in the closet. I took my shoes off before sitting on the bed.

Those were such little things to cry over.

Downstairs, Mrs. Kubiak’s dish was still beside the sink. I dried it again, wrapped it in the towel, and carried it next door.

She answered in slippers.

“There you are,” she said. “I’ve been looking for your car.”

I held out the dish.

“I’m sorry I kept this.”

She didn’t take it.

“Darlene Haskins, if you apologize for returning a casserole dish the Monday after burying your husband, I’m going to throw the thing in the bushes.”

I laughed. Then my face folded again.

She took the dish with one hand and caught my sleeve with the other.

“Oh, honey.”

I told her enough. The kitchen. The key. The motel.

Her fingers tightened on my sleeve.

“Come sit.”

“Would you come to mine instead?”

She put the dish inside her door and reached for her coat.

Back home, she settled on the sofa while I put the kettle on. She didn’t ask about the accounts or what the house was worth. She asked whether I’d slept.

“Not properly.”

“Then I’ll stay until you’re tired.”

I brought her tea. Gordon’s Seiko slipped down my wrist as I set the cup beside her.

She touched its band.

“That’s his.”

“Yes.”

She shifted over, making room.

I sat beside her, drew my feet up under me, and let her tuck the blanket around my knees.

For another family showdown over who gets to call a house home, read “My Daughter-in-Law Left Eleven Boxes Outside My Bedroom”. Or see how one Thanksgiving dinner turned into an unexpected job offer in “My Twin Offered Me Reception Work Over Thanksgiving Turkey”.