My Cousin Made My Army Service His Mom’s Birthday Entertainment

William Turner

The seat belt alarm stopped when I buckled in the pudding. Apparently my car had more concern for Aunt Bev’s dessert than for my judgment.

Nine days earlier, she’d called about turning seventy-eight and not knowing how many birthdays remained. So on Saturday, September 5, I drove two and a half hours from Lawton to Broken Arrow with banana pudding in the chipped glass dish she’d given me before basic.

I arrived at three. By 3:20, her son Corey was entertaining the yard at my expense.

My pension, my hospital scheduling job, whether I carried a pistol, whether Army women did anything besides paperwork. The bass-boat salesman from outside Tulsa had questions. Answers weren’t required.

I kept drinking lemonade. His wife, Kelsey, offered an apologetic face. Bev touched the chip in her dish.

At 5:15, Kelsey’s father arrived in a gray pickup. Howard wore pressed clothes despite the ninety-four-degree heat. Corey paraded his thirty-year Marine veteran around as evidence of what service should look like.

Howard paused when we shook hands. Later, from beside the smoker, he kept looking across the patio at me.

At 7:40, Corey gathered seven spectators and asked what I’d done during twenty years in uniform. He worked his way from shooting to punching, demonstrating a jab nobody had requested.

I answered about close quarters and knives.

Then his finger came toward my face.

“Let me guess, they called you Cupcake?”

I gave him the call sign I hadn’t spoken around civilians in seventeen years.

“Widowmaker.”

Howard’s mason jar broke against the concrete. Sweet tea spread between the pavers.

He crossed through the glass, pale, and stopped Corey’s next joke with one raised hand.

“Lord have mercy… you’re Widowmaker.”

The Man Beside the Smoker

I stood and moved my lemonade before somebody knocked that over too.

“Don’t move your feet,” I said to Howard. “There’s glass.”

He looked down as though the patio had appeared beneath him without warning. Kelsey caught his elbow. One of the children started toward the pieces, and I held out my palm.

“Stay on the grass, honey.”

Howard looked back at me.

“Helmand. Two thousand nine.”

My hand stayed in the air.

“The valley,” he said. “You were on the ridge.”

There was a chair behind his knees. Kelsey pulled it forward, and he sat without taking his eyes off me.

“Yes,” I said.

He pressed both hands together. One palm was red from touching the smoker earlier.

“We couldn’t move. Every time somebody tried, they opened up again. Then an Army sniper team got above us.”

Corey shifted beside me.

Howard continued, looking at his daughter now.

“We had their call sign on the radio. Widowmaker. They stayed up there for hours, watching every bit of ground we had to cross. They covered us until the last man was out.”

Kelsey bent at the waist, her hand still around his arm.

“You were there?”

“I was leading that patrol.”

His eyes came back to mine.

“And she was on that team.”

Bev set her plate down. The seven spectators remained around the patio, but nobody reached for a drink or spoke.

I’d spent the afternoon wanting everyone to stop looking at me. Now I wanted exactly the same thing for a different reason.

“We had help,” I said. “You know that.”

“I know what you did.”

He rubbed his mouth.

“I’ve been trying to find you for seventeen years.”

That one got through.

I sat on the edge of my chair, beside the lemonade.

Howard explained in pieces. He’d asked after the team before leaving Afghanistan. Later he’d asked men he served with, followed leads that ended with somebody transferred or somebody knowing only the call sign. He’d retired in 2011. He had a face glimpsed afterward, a voice from a radio, and a name that belonged to a team.

No wonder he’d studied me when we shook hands.

At forty-one, with my hair down and a purse at my feet, I didn’t much resemble the twenty-four-year-old he’d met after that valley. Some mornings I barely resembled the woman on my hospital badge.

“You came over afterward,” I said.

He nodded hard.

“You asked about your men before you asked for water.”

His mouth pulled sideways.

“Sounds like something stupid I’d do.”

“It was.”

He laughed once. Then he bent forward with his elbows on his knees and cried.

Kelsey knelt beside him. She didn’t ask him to stop.

I put my lemonade on the ground and reached across the space between our chairs. He caught my hand with both of his.

For a little while, that was all.

I could feel every person waiting for me to say something fit for the occasion. My supply of speeches was exhausted. I had used most of it at work explaining why an appointment couldn’t happen yesterday.

“All of you got out?” I said.

He lifted his head.

“Every one.”

I’d known they’d cleared the valley. Hearing it from the man sitting in front of me, seventeen years later, did something my own memory never quite managed.

“Good,” I said.

Howard squeezed my hand.

“I got to come home to her.”

Kelsey put her forehead against his shoulder.

Corey cleared his throat.

“Well, hell. You should’ve said something, Tara.”

Howard released my hand slowly.

I looked at my cousin. He had both hands on his hips, standing in the middle of the space he’d cleared for his little demonstration. His beer remained on Bev’s table.

“What should I have said?”

“You know what I mean. If you’d told us you did all that, nobody would’ve been giving you a hard time.”

Kelsey stood.

“Nobody?”

Corey looked toward the seven people he’d gathered. None volunteered to join him.

“I mean me. Obviously I mean me. I was just trying to get her talking. She’s been sitting over here all day like she doesn’t want anything to do with us.”

Bev started to rise. Her chair caught behind her calves, and I moved it back for her.

She put a hand on my wrist.

“Did you want to leave?”

There it was. The question I’d spent the afternoon avoiding.

“At four,” I said.

Her fingers tightened.

Corey made a noise through his nose.

“Come on. You stayed, didn’t you? We’re family. We tease each other.”

I nearly let that pass. It was Bev’s birthday. The children were still close enough to hear. Howard had just cried in front of strangers.

There were plenty of reasons to make myself convenient again.

Instead, I turned my chair to face Corey.

“You asked in front of everybody,” I said. “Stay here for the answer.”

Corey’s Empty Hands

He reached for his beer.

Kelsey moved between him and the table, and his hand dropped.

“Really?” he said to her. “Now you’re doing it too?”

“I’m standing here.”

“You’re looking at me like I committed a crime.”

“You asked her if she’d killed someone. In front of the kids.”

“I ask your dad things. He doesn’t take offense every time.”

Howard sat back. His face was wet, and he made no effort to hide it.

“You asked me to tell stories after I told you to stop.”

Corey spread his hands.

“Because I’m proud of you. That’s all. I wanted people to know who you are. Thirty years, Master Gunnery Sergeant, all that you did. I thought you’d appreciate it.”

Howard took his handkerchief from his pocket.

“You introduced her with quote marks.”

Corey glanced at me.

“That was a joke.”

“You said supposedly.”

“Because she never tells us anything.”

I stood beside Bev. She hadn’t released my wrist.

Corey looked from her to Kelsey, trying doors.

“Mom, you know me. Was I trying to hurt her? Be honest. You know how I talk.”

Bev’s eyes filled.

“Yes,” she said. “I do.”

That slowed him down.

“I told you to stop,” she continued. “Then I let you start again.”

“Well, thank you. That’s great. Everybody pile on.”

Bev let go of me and straightened.

“You made my niece want to leave my birthday.”

For the first time that evening, Corey looked directly at his mother without preparing his next line.

She was seventy-eight. He was thirty-eight. Somehow he managed to look fourteen, standing there waiting for her to fix the trouble he’d made.

“I didn’t know about Afghanistan,” he said.

I let him finish. It took work.

“I didn’t know she knew Howard. I didn’t know any of this. You’re all acting like I sat down and planned to insult somebody who saved his life. How was I supposed to know?”

“You weren’t,” I said.

He stared at me.

“I could’ve spent twenty years ordering printer paper. You still don’t get to treat me that way.”

Howard nodded, but I kept my eyes on Corey.

My cousin rubbed his neck.

“Okay. Fine. I’m sorry, then.”

“For?”

He looked toward the house.

“Tara.”

“For what?”

“I’ve said I’m sorry. What else do you want me to do, get on my knees?”

I wanted to tell him his knees were safe. His mouth was the part that needed supervision.

Instead, I waited.

One of the children pulled at an adult’s sleeve. The seven spectators had become very interested in giving Corey room. Nobody moved out of hearing.

Kelsey crossed her arms.

“You were pleased when they laughed.”

“People laugh at cookouts.”

“At her.”

He swallowed.

“I got carried away.”

Bev reached for the back of her chair but didn’t sit.

Corey looked at Howard.

“Help me out here.”

Howard folded his handkerchief.

“No.”

That single word cost Corey more than anything I could have said. This was the man he’d brought to impress us. His display model, polished up and parked beside the smoker.

Now Howard wouldn’t even lend him a sentence.

Corey’s eyes went red. He rubbed them with his knuckles, angry at the wetness.

“I was trying to be funny,” he said. “Everybody was just sitting around, and I was trying to make it a good afternoon.”

I waited again.

“And yes, I kept going because people laughed.”

Kelsey lowered her arms.

He turned toward me.

“I called your service fake. I made those cracks about women doing paperwork. I asked things I shouldn’t have asked.”

His jaw worked.

“I made you the joke.”

“Yes.”

“I’m sorry.”

This time he didn’t add anything.

I could have rescued him then. A hug, a laugh, an assurance that he was still my favorite nuisance. Everybody could have breathed and returned to the ribs.

But I’d driven two and a half hours with a pudding strapped in like a toddler. I hadn’t come to give a grown man a prize for describing his own behavior.

“I heard you,” I said.

He nodded, looking down.

Then he tried one last bargain.

“So we’re okay?”

“No.”

His head came up.

“We can be at the same birthday,” I said. “That’s what you get tonight.”

Bev pulled her chair closer to mine and sat. Kelsey took the seat on my other side.

Corey stayed standing.

He’d wanted the center of that patio all afternoon. He had it now, and couldn’t find a thing to do with it.

Howard looked toward the broken jar.

“There’s a broom by the back door.”

Corey opened his mouth, then shut it.

“I’ll get it.”

Nobody congratulated him.

The Chip in the Rim

He returned with the broom and a dustpan and crouched beside the smoker. Kelsey kept the children on the grass while he worked glass out of the cracks.

I sat with Bev’s hand tucked around mine.

The porch light came on. Someone moved the plates away from the tea, and the seven spectators began talking among themselves again, carefully at first.

Howard drew his chair nearer.

“I owe you an apology too,” he said.

“You dropped a jar. Bev’s got approximately a thousand.”

Bev squeezed my fingers.

“Nine hundred now.”

Howard smiled, but only for a moment.

“I should have stopped him sooner. Before I knew.”

I looked at the man folding and unfolding his handkerchief. He’d spent the afternoon trying to refuse his son-in-law without making a scene at somebody else’s birthday.

I understood that particular mistake.

“Next time,” I said, “make him hear you.”

“I will.”

He didn’t ask for details about the ridge. He didn’t ask what else I’d done, or how many times, or whether I still thought about it at night.

Instead he asked whether I liked the hospital.

“Most days.”

“What do you do there?”

“Scheduling. Forty hours a week convincing people that Tuesday is not a personal attack.”

Bev laughed beside me.

Howard asked another question, and I answered it. A normal question about a normal job. I hadn’t known how badly I wanted one until he gave it to me.

Corey carried the dustpan toward the trash. When he returned, he checked under the smoker with the porch light on his phone. Then he wiped up the tea.

He didn’t turn the cleanup into a performance.

That was a start. A small one. I wasn’t going to frame it.

Kelsey sat beside her father and asked whether he wanted to leave.

“Not yet,” he said. “If that’s all right with our birthday girl.”

Bev leaned forward.

“I haven’t opened my pudding.”

“That sounds like a medical emergency,” I said.

She patted my knee.

“Come help me.”

In the kitchen, she pulled the glass dish from the refrigerator. The pudding had set properly. I was grateful for one thing that evening having followed instructions.

Bev put it on the counter and stood with both hands on the edges.

“I shouldn’t have made you feel you had to come.”

“You didn’t make him behave that way.”

“I know. But I saw you sitting by the fence. I kept thinking you’d move over when you wanted company.”

I took a spoon from the drawer.

“I wanted company.”

She covered her mouth.

That hurt worse than Corey’s questions. I could withstand my cousin being a fool. My aunt crying beside a banana pudding was above my pay grade.

I put the spoon down and held her.

“I’m here,” I said.

She gripped the back of my shirt.

“I missed you.”

“I missed you too.”

We stayed like that until she pulled away and wiped her cheeks with the heel of her hand.

“Well,” she said, “now I look seventy-nine.”

I laughed into my own wet face.

She gave me the spoon and took the dish outside.

Nobody asked for another war story. Howard ate his pudding standing beside his daughter. Bev made sure the children got some before the adults could finish it.

Corey waited until she served herself.

Then he approached me, without the beer.

“Would it help if I told everybody again? That I was wrong?”

“They heard.”

He nodded.

“I won’t bring it up at the next one. The name. Any of it.”

“Good.”

“And I won’t let somebody else do it.”

I studied him for a moment.

He kept his hands at his sides.

“Start with yourself,” I said.

“I will.”

He walked back to his mother and asked where she wanted the folding chairs when people were done. She pointed toward the shed.

The party loosened around us. A child asked Howard whether Marines had to make their beds every day, and he said yes, which caused considerable concern on the grass.

Before he left, Howard came to me with his phone.

“May I have your number?”

I entered it and sent myself a message so I’d have his.

He held out his hand, then stopped.

“Could I hug you?”

“Yes.”

His arms came around me carefully. He was shaking a little.

“Thank you for staying up there,” he said.

I held on.

“Thank you for telling me you got home.”

When he stepped away, Kelsey hugged me too. Corey waited beside her, holding the empty serving plates. For once, he let someone else finish saying goodbye.

Later, Bev washed the glass dish while I dried it. Her thumb found the chip again.

“I ought to buy you a new one.”

“This one works.”

“It looked bigger when I gave it to you.”

“I was eighteen.”

She smiled at that. In 2003 she’d handed me a dish I couldn’t possibly use in basic training. I had kept it through twenty years of service anyway. Practicality had never been the whole point of Bev.

At the car, she waited while I put it on the passenger seat.

Then she opened her arms again.

I bent down into her hug, and this time I didn’t count the hours until I could leave.

“Come back without an occasion,” she said.

“I can do that.”

She leaned into the car, pulled the seat belt across the empty dish, and clicked it into place.

Family gatherings have a way of bringing old slights to the surface – like in the story of a sister who put her own brother beside the coat rack. For another tale of relatives crossing a line, read about a mother who spent her granddaughter’s savings without asking.