The ribbon on our cake knife kept slipping beneath my thumb. I remember trying to straighten it so it would look nice in the photograph. That was the problem occupying me seconds before my husband put his hand behind my head.
We were in a banquet hall in Erie, Pennsylvania, with 118 guests. At 4:00 p.m., my mother, Lorraine, had smiled from the front row while my sister, Denise, stood beside me and Wade waited at the altar.
I was thirty-two. Wade was thirty-five. I thought we had plenty of time to get good at being married.
At 7:20, with his best man’s phone already recording, Wade pushed my face into the top tier of our lemon cake.
Cream-cheese frosting filled my nose. My tulle veil pulled loose from its pearl comb, and cake slid down the bodice of my gown. Wade bent over laughing, collected frosting from my cheek, and tasted it.
“Not bad.”
His side laughed. Across the room, my family sat still. A few other guests gave uncertain laughs, and a boy near the cake asked whether this belonged in the celebration.
I stood holding the knife.
“Relax, babe, it’s tradition.”
Then Denise’s chair scraped.
My sister was thirty-eight, six years older than me. Since Dad died when I was nine, she and Mom had been my people. Denise checked out boyfriends and once drove three hours through an ice storm to sit with me after a breakup.
Both of them approved of Wade.
The last time Denise rose like that, I was twenty-one and a stranger at a bowling alley wouldn’t release my elbow. She removed his hand herself.
Now she passed Wade with the phone that had buzzed during our rehearsal dinner. Mom called her name, but Denise went to the DJ.
“Plug this in,” she said. “NOW.”
The Phone Beside the Microphone
The DJ reached for a cable, then stopped with it hanging between his fingers.
Denise pointed at the microphone. He handed it over.
“Colleen,” she said through the speakers. “Do you want everybody to hear what he said about this last night?”
Wade stopped laughing.
That did more to clear my head than the napkin Mom was pressing into my hand. Until then, some foolish part of me had still been waiting for him to become the man from the ceremony. To look at my face and understand what he’d done.
“What did he say?”
“There’s a video.”
“Denise, don’t,” Wade said.
She kept her eyes on me.
“Play it,” I said.
The DJ connected her phone. A scrape came through the speakers, followed by men’s voices and the sound of a glass being set down.
Then Wade.
“Twenty says I can get her right into the cake.”
Someone laughed. Another voice asked whether he wanted his marriage to last longer than the reception.
“She’ll laugh,” Wade said. “Put a camera on her. She’s not going to make herself look bad at her own wedding.”
I lowered the napkin.
On the recording, someone asked, “What if she gets upset?”
“Her sister will get her settled down. That’s what Denise does.”
I could hear a man laughing close to the phone. Wade kept talking.
“Get the whole thing, though. Start before we cut it.”
The best man lowered his phone at last.
Denise stopped the recording. Nobody needed a second showing. Wade had excellent diction when he was explaining how easily I could be managed.
A groomsman stood beside the head table.
“I sent it to her,” he said.
Wade turned toward him.
“It was a joke.”
“I thought she’d put a stop to it.”
Denise held the microphone down against her dress.
“I tried.”
The two words landed hard enough that I turned away from Wade.
“You knew?”
She nodded.
“I took him aside after the rehearsal dinner. I told him you hated that stuff. I told him there would be no shoving, no grabbing, none of it.”
“You didn’t tell me?”
“He said he was showing off. He promised me.”
Wade reached for the microphone. Denise moved it behind her back.
“Give me that. This is getting ridiculous.”
Mom stepped between us so quickly that the napkin fell from my hand. At sixty-three, she still had the knees to move when she needed to.
“Don’t reach across my daughter.”
“I was reaching for the microphone.”
“Then walk around.”
For a moment he looked genuinely offended by the inconvenience.
I set the silver knife on the cake stand. My hand had cramped around its handle. There was a smear of frosting on the ribbon I’d been fussing over, and I wanted to laugh at myself for caring about a bow.
Instead, I began to cry.
Not nicely. Not the little tear that can be dabbed away without disturbing anything. My face hurt, my scalp stung, and I couldn’t stop wiping beneath my nose.
Wade moved toward me.
“Come on. Let’s get you cleaned up.”
I backed into the edge of the cake stand.
“Don’t touch me.”
He looked around before he answered.
That small turn of his head made my stomach go cold. He was checking who could hear.
“You’re upset. I get it. But we don’t need to do this in front of everybody.”
I pointed toward the best man’s phone.
“You did.”
Denise put the microphone back on its stand and came toward me. I held up my hand to her too.
She stopped.
“Give me a minute.”
“Okay.”
Her face crumpled, but she stayed where she was. She didn’t tell me she’d meant well. I was grateful for that much. I couldn’t have carried her intentions along with everything dripping down my dress.
The groomsman remained standing.
“I should have told you myself,” he said.
“Yes.”
He sat down.
Wade rubbed the back of his neck.
“So everybody’s going to pretend they never made a stupid bet? Nobody here ever messed up?”
Nobody answered.
He looked toward his side of the room, the people who’d been laughing seconds earlier. A woman put her napkin beside her plate. Someone pushed a chair back.
“Seriously?” Wade said. “You’re all taking this that far?”
His best man put the phone in his pocket.
“She told you not to.”
“Denise isn’t my wife.”
“No,” I said. “I am.”
He turned back toward me with something close to relief.
“Exactly. So let’s talk.”
“I want everyone to stay for a minute.”
The woman with her napkin down settled back into her chair. Denise stood beside Mom. The DJ stepped away from his equipment.
I had spent months worrying about whether people would enjoy themselves at my wedding.
They could be uncomfortable for five more minutes.
“Take your phone back out,” I told the best man.
The Camera He Asked For
He pulled it from his pocket but kept the screen facing his leg.
I almost let him. I had been trained by a lifetime of family photographs to smooth the awkwardness, stand where someone pointed, and give them something pleasant to take home.
“Is it still recording?” I asked.
“No.”
“Send me what you recorded.”
Wade laughed once.
“Oh, now you want the video?”
“I want a copy.”
“What for?”
I held out my hand toward the best man. He opened the recording, and I gave him my number. He sent it while I stood there.
Only after my phone buzzed inside Denise’s clutch did I turn back to my husband.
He had chosen a dark suit because he said he’d get more use from it. I remembered standing outside the fitting room, telling him he looked handsome. I wanted to reach backward and take that afternoon away from him.
“Did you mean what you said last night?”
“Which part? There were people drinking. Everybody was talking.”
“The part where you said I wouldn’t make myself look bad.”
He let out a breath.
“I meant you have a sense of humor.”
“Did you?”
“Colleen, come on.”
“Answer her,” Mom said.
He stared at her.
“Lorraine, you know me.”
“I thought I did.”
That hurt him. His mouth opened, then shut. Mom had fussed over him all morning, found somebody to fix his crooked boutonniere, made certain he ate before the ceremony. He’d enjoyed being her new son.
Now she wouldn’t even step aside to let him near me.
“I didn’t think she’d take it like this,” he said.
Denise pressed her lips together.
“I told you exactly how she’d take it.”
“And I said I was sorry.”
“You haven’t said that to me,” I said.
He spread his hands.
“Fine. I’m sorry.”
The best man looked down.
Wade turned on him.
“Don’t do that. You were laughing harder than anybody.”
“I was wrong.”
“That’s convenient.”
“Yes,” I said. “It is. But he managed three words without blaming me.”
Wade pulled out a chair and sat. Then he stood again. He seemed unable to decide which position made him look more reasonable.
“You want me to say I ruined the wedding? Is that what fixes this? Fine. I ruined the wedding.”
I took the pearl comb from where it hung in my hair. Two of its teeth were bent, a torn scrap of tulle still caught in them, and Mom gathered the rest of my veil before it reached the floor.
That was when Wade began to sound frightened.
“Don’t start taking everything off.”
I slid my wedding ring over my knuckle.
He stepped forward. Mom raised one hand, and he stopped.
“Colleen. Please. We just got married.”
“I remember.”
“It’s cake.”
“You held my head down.”
“For a second.”
“Long enough.”
He looked at Denise.
“Say something to her.”
She was crying now. She didn’t try to hide it.
“You heard her.”
“You’ve been in our business since we met. You picked the flowers. You helped with the invitations. You practically planned this whole thing, and now you’re going to stand there while she throws it away?”
“I chose the flowers,” I said.
He waved a hand.
“You know what I mean.”
I did. For once, he had made himself perfectly clear.
A chair moved on his side of the room. Then another.
His best man came around the head table.
“Wade, I’ll wait outside if you need a ride.”
“I’m not leaving.”
The woman who had first put down her napkin stood again. Others followed her toward the doors. Wade called after them, asking where they were going, but nobody came back to reassure him.
His side of the room began emptying.
They left their favors beside the place settings. Little wrapped pieces of cake we’d ordered for people to take home. I’d tied those ribbons too, sitting on my living-room floor with Denise until our fingers hurt.
Wade stood in the space between the cake and the head table, watching people leave a party he’d expected to make him famous among his friends.
Then he turned toward me.
“We can still fix this.”
I put the ring on a clean napkin.
He stared at it.
“Not like this,” he said. “Don’t humiliate me like this.”
My sister made a sound I had never heard from her before.
I put my hand out, and this time she took it.
“You need to leave,” I told him.
“This is my reception too.”
“Then decide how much more of it you want recorded.”
He glanced at the best man. The phone remained in his pocket, but Wade didn’t seem certain of that anymore.
For the first time all evening, he lowered his voice.
“Can I at least speak to you alone?”
“No.”
“Five minutes.”
“No.”
His eyes filled. I don’t know whether he was crying for our marriage or for the people leaving through the doors. I didn’t have room to investigate.
He reached for the ring, missed it, and picked it up on the second try.
Denise squeezed my hand.
Wade waited for me to stop him. I could tell because he moved slowly, straightening his jacket, checking his pocket, taking one step and then looking back.
At the doors he said, “I thought you trusted me.”
“I did.”
Then I turned away.
The Pearl Comb
Mom put an arm around me, and the three of us walked out through the side door toward the dressing room.
Behind us, Wade left through the main entrance alone. His best man had gone ahead, but Wade didn’t accept the ride. Through the dressing-room window, I saw him cross the parking lot with his jacket folded over his arm.
Nobody followed him.
Denise shut the dressing-room door and stood beside it.
Mom turned on the faucet. She tested the water with her wrist the way she’d done when I was little, then wet a washcloth.
“Chin up, honey.”
I lifted it.
She cleaned beneath my eyes first. Every time she rinsed the cloth, yellow crumbs collected in the sink.
“I can’t get it out of my nose,” I said.
“We’ll get it.”
“I keep tasting it.”
“I know.”
Denise opened the bag with my going-home clothes. She placed them on the chair without asking whether I was sure. That made me cry harder.
“I liked my dress.”
Mom stopped wiping.
“Oh, Colleen.”
“I know it’s stupid.”
“No,” she said. “You liked your dress.”
She let me say it again. She let me cry over the skirt I’d tried on three times, over the picture I wanted for my hallway, over the fact that I had woken that morning excited to see Wade.
Denise knelt to unfasten my shoes.
“I should have told you last night,” she said.
“Yes.”
“I thought I’d handled it.”
I looked down at the top of her head.
“You keep doing that.”
Her fingers stopped at the buckle.
“Handling things?”
“Deciding what I need to know.”
She sat back on her heels.
“I thought I was saving your wedding.”
I wanted to say something cruel. Something about how well that had worked. She would have taken it, which made the temptation worse.
Instead, I said, “You can’t approve a man for me and then keep the bad part to yourself.”
“I know.”
“You didn’t last night.”
“No.”
Mom handed me the washcloth and went to help with the zipper on my gown. Denise stayed on the floor until I touched her shoulder.
“I need you,” I said. “But I need you telling me things.”
She nodded, crying so hard she couldn’t answer.
“Also, I need my foot out of this shoe.”
That got a wet little laugh from all three of us.
My dress went into its bag. I put on trousers and the sweater I’d packed for the drive to our hotel. Denise wrapped the comb in a clean tissue and put it in my purse.
Outside the dressing room, the reception had stopped pretending to be a reception. No music played. My family waited, and nobody asked me to go back for photographs.
Mom collected our things. Denise brought the car around.
I went home with them.
Wade called that night. I let it ring. His messages moved from apology to explanation and back again, with occasional stops to ask whether Denise was still there.
I saved them.
The next morning, I sat beside Mom on her couch while Denise forwarded the rehearsal video to me. Then I made the calls myself.
I asked about ending the marriage. I sent both recordings when I was asked for them. I wrote down what happened without changing “pushed” to “got carried away,” though my hand hovered over those words for a while.
By the end of the week, the marriage was annulled.
Wade didn’t get a wife who would laugh for the camera. He got his ring back and an ending he couldn’t talk me out of.
He also paid $286.40 to have my gown cleaned. The bill arrived while Denise was helping me straighten the bent teeth of the pearl comb. I sent him a photograph of it.
He transferred the exact amount.
Then came a message: Could we please stop making this about one mistake?
I typed a paragraph. Deleted it. Typed another.
Finally, I sent two words.
“We have.”
I blocked his number after the necessary arrangements were finished.
That evening, Mom came over carrying a small paper bag. Denise was already there, sitting on my hallway floor with the frame I’d bought before the wedding.
We had found a different photograph for it.
The photographer took it before the ceremony: Mom reaching up to fix my veil, Denise holding the comb, and me laughing because neither of them could agree where it belonged.
Wade wasn’t in it. Nobody needed cropping out.
Denise held the frame against the wall.
“Here?”
“A little left.”
She moved it.
“Here?”
“Now it’s too far.”
Mom opened her bag and took out three lemon bars.
I stared at them.
“I can take them away,” she said.
Dad used to steal lemon bars at church suppers. Mom had remembered that, even though I’d spent the week promising never to eat anything yellow again.
I took one.
A little sugar fell on the floor. Denise looked down at it, then up at me.
“That better not be how you measure whether this is straight.”
I laughed with my mouth full.
She set the frame on its hook and stepped back beside Mom. I wiped the sugar from my fingers, reached between them, and nudged the photograph straight.
For more family moments that turn unsettling fast, read “My Son-In-Law Held the Door While I Carried My Suitcases”, “My Sister Wore My Coat While I Answered the Doctor”, and “My Husband Took Dad’s Spare Key on His Business Trip”.