Am I wrong for showing a student’s drawing to child protective services?

Sofia Rossi

I’ve taught second grade for nineteen years. This one drawing didn’t feel like the others.

I have Marcus (7) in my class this year. Quiet kid, always tired, wears long sleeves even in September heat. His mom Denise (34) volunteers at every school event, brings homemade cupcakes, the whole “involved parent” package.

Two weeks ago we did a family unit. Draw your house, draw your family, whatever they wanted. Most kids drew stick figures and suns with faces. Marcus drew his dad standing over his mom with his hand raised, and Marcus in the corner, small, facing away.

I asked him about it during recess, kept my voice light. “Tell me about your picture, buddy.”

He wouldn’t look up from his shoe. “That’s just how Daddy stands sometimes.”

I brought it to our school counselor, Mrs. Pruitt, who agreed it needed a closer look. She set up a meeting with the family therapist the school works with, Dr. Alvarez, and asked me to sit in since Marcus trusts me. Denise showed up alone, said her husband Todd “had work,” and when Dr. Alvarez brought up the drawing, Denise laughed.

“Kids draw weird stuff, that doesn’t mean anything happened.”

Then Marcus, sitting between us, said something so quiet I almost missed it. He looked at his mom and said, “You told me not to tell.”

Denise’s face went white.

“Marcus, sweetheart, that’s not – ” she started, and Dr. Alvarez raised a hand, gentle but firm, and said, “Let him finish.”

Marcus opened his backpack. Underneath his lunch box was another drawing, one he hadn’t shown anyone, folded into quarters so it wouldn’t get seen.

Dr. Alvarez reached over and unfolded it on the table.

For more stories about people standing up for what’s right, check out I Read the Denial Letter Out Loud in Court, Staring at the Man Who Wrote It and The Off-Duty Cop Next Door Thought My 11-Year-Old Was Casing Houses. You might also appreciate I Found My Nurse On a Termination List the Night My Mother Almost Died for another intense read.