A Senior Crushed the Hearing Aid My Mom Still Owes On

Maya Lin

The mud on my left sneaker was still from Tuesday, and I remember thinking I should have cleaned it, because that’s the kind of thing your brain does when it has nothing useful to offer.

Thursday, 3:06, bus loop. I had Erik on the phone. My aids stream calls into both ears, which is the one cool thing about them. I’d asked him to pick me up to spare Mom another early departure from work, and he’d answered, “Yeah, give me a sec,” when Ryder stepped in front of me.

I put the phone in my hoodie pocket. I kept the call connected. I wanted somebody to know.

Ryder is the baseball captain at Mount Ellis High, seventeen, a senior, and the size of two of me stacked. He walked me under the home bleachers and pinned me to a steel post with his forearm. Four teammates behind him. His girlfriend off to the side, filming sideways. Six of them, one of me.

My crime was sitting in the top row at practice. Her row. Twice.

He made me say sorry, then told me it wasn’t enough, I had to be sorry I existed. I didn’t say anything. So he backhanded my right aid out of my ear. My lip split. The right side of the world shut off like a fridge.

“Go on, call your brother,” he said. “What’s he gonna do, sign at me?”

He flicked my empty ear. The tall one stood on my aid and leaned until the shell cracked. I watched it. I didn’t hear it.

Then Erik, low, in my left ear: “Paisley. I’m on my way. Stay on your feet.”

Ryder found the phone. 14:22 on the timer. He put it on speaker, called me deaf and stupid to my brother, and threw it in the dirt. He did cartoon sign language at my face while his girlfriend laughed.

At 3:24 the ground started to buzz. Eleven motorcycles. Erik in a vest that said PROSPECT. Bruce with his gray braid and reading glasses telling Ryder to say it again slower so I could read his lips. Ryder on his knees in his letter jacket. The broken aid folded into his fist.

“Get up,” Erik said. “You’re walking us to the office.”

The vest

Ryder got up. It took him two tries, because his knees were wet and his legs didn’t want to be legs anymore.

Erik turned to me before anybody moved. He shrugged the vest off his shoulders and held it out. I didn’t understand what he wanted, so he just put it on me himself, over my hoodie, over the blood line on the front, the way Mom used to put my coat on me in kindergarten when I took too long.

It was heavy. It smelled like gas and the inside of his truck. It came down to the middle of my thighs.

“So nobody stares at your shirt,” he said.

“Everybody’s going to stare at the VEST, Erik.”

“Good. Let them look at that.”

So that’s how we walked across campus at 3:31 on a Thursday. Ryder in front, holding his own fist shut like there was a bird in it. Erik behind him. Me next to Erik in a motorcycle vest that said PROSPECT across my butt. Bruce behind us with his glasses swinging on the cord. And Ryder’s girlfriend, because Bruce had looked at her phone, then looked at her, and she’d just started walking.

The other nine riders stayed with the bikes. I could feel them watching us go the way you feel a porch light.

Mr. Halvorsen was in the front office signing something for the attendance lady. He looked up and saw Ryder, then the vest, then Bruce, then my lip. He put the pen down very gently, like it might go off.

“Into my office,” he said. “All of you.”

Erik did the talking. He said it like a repair estimate. Time, place, what was hit, what was broken. He put the phone on the desk with the call log open: 18 minutes, 3:06 to 3:24.

“I heard all of it,” he said. “Every word. I can tell it to you, or she can show you.”

He meant the girlfriend.

She was holding her phone against her stomach with both hands. Mr. Halvorsen held out his palm. She didn’t move.

“You filmed it to post it,” Bruce said. Not mean. Grandpa at the bake sale. “So it was for people to see. He’s people.”

She gave it over.

I’ve been on the other side of a lot of videos. Kids record you when you ask “what?” twice. This one was different, because I could finally hear it. Halvorsen turned it up all the way and tilted it so I could read the captions that her phone made automatically, which was the funniest part, honestly. The phone had captioned the whole thing. “Sorry you exist here.” “What’s he gonna do, sign at me.” And under the tall one’s sneaker coming down: [laughter].

Halvorsen watched it twice. The second time he watched Ryder instead of the screen.

Then he sat back and said, “Ryder. You’re done as captain. As of right now.” He picked up his desk phone. “And I’m calling Coach Arellano, and then I’m calling Pacific Lutheran, because they asked me for a character letter last month, and I owe them an honest one.”

Ryder made a sound like a door with no oil.

“It was a bit.”

“Your hand is in the video,” Halvorsen said.

Then he looked at Erik’s vest on me, and at Bruce, and something on his face went careful.

“Bruce,” he said. “I didn’t know you’d come in person.”

“Wasn’t planning on it.”

I looked between them. “You know each other?”

Halvorsen cleared his throat. “Your brother’s club has been our biggest athletic donor for six years, Paisley. The batting cages. Fuel for every away game. Anonymous, at their request.”

Bruce shrugged. “We like baseball.”

But Erik wasn’t looking at Halvorsen. He was looking at the floor, which is what Erik does when he’s about to say a true thing and hates it.

“That’s why I asked them,” he said. “Back in February. I knew they gave to this school. I figured if I was one of them, and anybody here ever messed with you, somebody would pick up when I called.”

Mom thought he’d joined a club to be a cowboy. He’d joined it for me.

I didn’t cry. I picked at the vest’s stitching with my thumbnail until I could talk again.

“You could’ve just told me,” I said.

“You’d have told me I was being dramatic.”

“You ARE being dramatic. You brought eleven motorcycles.”

Halvorsen’s phone was already ringing. Ryder’s dad, calling back.

Mr. Navarro

Ryder’s dad arrived at 4:20, and Mom got there at 4:22, so for two minutes it looked like they might arrive at the same door and have to decide who went first.

He went first. Of course he did.

Damon Navarro was a smaller version of Ryder plus a fleece vest and a car key he kept spinning. He walked in already talking. “This is going to be handled, Mr. Halvorsen, I just want it on the record that he’s seventeen, and kids roughhouse, and the scholarship—”

Then Mom came through the door in her work scrubs with her lanyard still on and stopped dead.

She saw my lip. Then she saw the vest. Then she saw Erik. I watched her decide which of those three she was going to be angry about first.

“Mom,” Erik said. “Sit down a sec.”

She didn’t. She came straight to me and turned my face toward the window like she was checking a melon, and put her thumb under my lip, and then her eyes went to my right ear and she just made a noise. A small one.

“Where is it?”

I pointed at Ryder.

Ryder opened his hand. The two halves sat in his palm, sweaty, a little dirt still in the crack.

Mom didn’t take them. She looked at them for a long time.

“Twenty-four payments,” she said. To nobody. “Twenty-four.”

Mr. Navarro was still spinning the key. “Ma’am, we’ll obviously cover the device—”

“It’s not a device. It’s my daughter’s ear.”

He stopped spinning.

Halvorsen played the video again. I didn’t need to see it, so I watched Mr. Navarro instead, because I’m petty and because I could. He leaned in for the first part. The “sorry you exist” part he leaned back. When his son’s hand came up across the side of my head, he looked at the ceiling.

When the speaker part played, “Hey, Erik, your sister’s deaf AND stupid,” he put his hand over his mouth.

The video ended on the tall one saying “whoops.”

“Who is that?” Mr. Navarro said. “The tall one. I want his name.”

“He’s already been called,” Halvorsen said. “He’s next.”

Then Mr. Navarro turned to his son. Ryder was sitting in the plastic chair by the window still in his letter jacket, with dirt on both knees.

“Stand up,” his dad said.

Ryder stood.

“Tell her mother what you did. All of it. Not ‘a bit.'”

This is the part I think about. Ryder had to say it, out loud, to my mom, in her scrubs. Pinned her. Made her apologize. Hit her. Flicked her ear. Called her deaf and stupid on the phone to her brother. Did the hands. He got through about half and then his voice stopped working, and his dad said, “Keep going,” and he kept going.

When he finished, Mom said, “Look at her when you talk. She reads lips. Your coach said you’re good at reading people.”

He looked at me.

“I’m sorry, Paisley.”

“I know,” I said.

Then Halvorsen got off the phone with Pacific Lutheran and set it down.

“The offer’s on hold,” he said. “Pending a disciplinary review and a statement from the family of the student. They were very clear about whose statement.”

The whole room looked at me. Even Bruce.

I could have said anything. I’d been thinking about it since the bleachers, the things you think when someone is pressing a steel post into your spine. I had a whole speech.

I said, “I want my mom’s last sixteen payments gone. And I want him to stay off the field until I say.”

Mr. Navarro got his checkbook out of the fleece vest. An actual paper checkbook. Erik made a face like he’d found a carburetor in a museum.

“Fifty-eight hundred,” Mr. Navarro said, writing. “The full pair. Not the half. And she gets the new ones without waiting on a payment plan.”

“That’s more than the balance,” Mom said.

“It’s the pair.” He tore it off. “He broke the pair. You can’t wear one.”

Mom took the check and folded it once and held onto it with both hands, the way I’d held the vest.

Ryder said, very quietly, “Dad. The truck—”

“The truck’s going to the lot Saturday,” his dad said. “You’ll be riding the bus. The one her brother puts gas in.”

Ryder sat back down like somebody had cut the string.

His girlfriend, who hadn’t said one word, stood up and walked out of the office without her phone. Halvorsen had it. She didn’t ask for it back.

Outside, nine engines started at once.

The top row

Mom didn’t talk to Erik in the parking lot. She didn’t talk to him in the kitchen, either, not while she cleaned my lip, not while she put my one aid in its case. She waited until 9:40 that night, when I was supposed to be in bed, and I was on the stairs with my left ear pointed down like a satellite dish.

“How long,” Mom said.

“Since February. I started riding in March.”

“For HER.”

“For her. And for the bikes a little. I’m not gonna lie, Mom, the bikes are cool.”

She laughed. It came out wrong, like a cough, and then it was crying, and I heard the kitchen chair scrape and I’m pretty sure he hugged her, because there was a long time of nothing and a muffled “you smell like a gas station.”

The next Friday, Mom stood at the counter with her phone like she does every other Friday at 7:15. Except she didn’t tap pay. She turned the phone so I could see.

Balance: $0.00.

“Read it out loud,” she said. “I want to hear somebody say it.”

“Zero dollars and zero cents.”

“Again.”

“Zero dollars and zero cents, Mom.”

She put the phone face down and pressed her hand on it like it might get away.

The new aids came eleven days later. Same model, same beige I hate. The audiologist, a lady named Maxine with a cardigan with pockets full of batteries, fitted them and turned them on, and the first thing I heard in my right ear in almost two weeks was her chair squeaking. I laughed so hard she thought something was wrong.

The tall one got suspended ten days and benched for the season. Ryder lost the captaincy for good, and Coach Arellano gave the C to a junior named Kamil who once lent me a pencil and didn’t make it weird. Ryder’s scholarship stayed on hold through December. I wrote the statement. It was three sentences. I didn’t say he was a good person. I said he’d said sorry to my face and I’d watched him mean it, which was true, and which was about as far as I was going to go.

And he rode the bus. Every morning. I know because my bus goes past his stop.

The Thursday after the aids came in, I went back to practice.

I climbed all the way to the top row of the home bleachers, the one I’d sat in twice. Ryder was down on the field in the outfield in a plain T-shirt, shagging balls for the guys who used to stand behind him. He looked up once, saw me, and looked back down.

The girl whose row it supposedly was sat four rows below me. She didn’t turn around.

I could see the whole field from up there. I always could. That was the point.

At 4:45 the bleachers started to buzz.

I felt it before I heard it, up through the metal, into my shins, the way it had that day. But this time both ears caught up a second later, at exactly the same time. Stereo.

One bike. Not eleven.

Erik rolled around the end of the dugout and stopped at the bottom of the bleachers and cut the engine, and every kid on the field turned to look, which he obviously loved.

The vest still said PROSPECT, but Bruce had told him the other day it wouldn’t for much longer.

He took off his helmet and held a second one up toward me, the little one Mom swore she’d never let him buy.

I came down the rows two at a time.

“Mom said yes?” I said.

“Mom said yes if you wear the vest.”

He took it off and put it on me, over my hoodie, the clean one, and zipped me up himself.

“Stereo?” he said, and pointed at both my ears.

“Stereo,” I said, and got on the bike.

Family betrayals have a way of getting even uglier – read about a brother’s cruel birthday toast in “My Brother Toasted My $19.40 Wage at Mom’s Birthday” and a son who called his mother “dead weight” in “My Son Called Me Dead Weight and Planned to Handle My House”. And for a marriage hiding its own secrets, there’s “My Husband Lied About Six Saturdays While I Mocked His Laundry”.